DAVID Arthur's reflections on his own experience working within two national charities, Samaritans and an unnamed medical charity, have convinced him that separation from the UK would be a mistake (Letters, April 23).

Samaritans' charitable purposes can be summarised as supporting people in distress or despair, including those who may be at risk of suicide; and promoting a better understanding of suicide in society.

From a policy perspective, the saving of lives (and the advancement of health) are matters devolved to Scottish Government. In these matters, nothing would change if Scotland were to become indepen­dent. Our primary concern is to continue the effective delivery of our service to callers wherever they are, and it is not apparent that either referendum outcome will affect this positively or negatively. Conse­quently, Samaritans' board of trustees has adopted a neutral position on the referendum.

We are immensely proud of the Samaritans service, which has been delivered exclusively by volunteers for more than 60 years across Scotland, Wales, England, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. We will continue to be available all day, every day for anyone who needs us.

Andrew Sim,

Samaritans' executive director for Scotland, 2 Powderhall Road, Edinburgh.