• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Go compare: we test first west of Scotland asparagus against its competitors

This week, the first spears of Scottish asparagus - named 'albaragus' - were harvested from a farm in Inchinnan after two farmers decided last year to plant 30,000 asparagus crowns and see what happened.

Albaragus 1
Asbaragus 1

The vegetable is notorious for preferring dry weather conditions - not ordinarily found in the farm's Renfrewshire location. However, the farm's produce prospered and the farmers behind the venture - Robert Ritchie and James Mackie - are now proud to call it a success and can list themselves among the handful of Scottish farms growing asparagus.

But how does it compare to what's already out there? We compare this locally-grown Scottish asparagus to its supermarket rivals…

Name 1: Albaragus.

Name 2: Asparagus.

Name 3: Asparagus.


Brand 1: Barnhill Farm.

Brand 2: The upmarket supermarket where wages go to die. 

Brand 3: A supermarket whose name rhymes with Gwyneth Paltrow's blog. Kind of.


Price 1: £3 per 250g bundle.

Price 2: £2.50 per 200g bundle.

Price 3: £1.69 per 170g bundle.


When picked 1: Less than 24 hours ago.

When picked 2: Unspecified.

When picked 3: Judging by its looks, age more difficult to determine than Cher's.


Where grown 1: A field minutes from Glasgow airport, an area usually reserved for clandestinely winching air stewards (probably).

Where grown 2: Wye Valley, by the Chinn family. This isn't just any Chinn family, either. This is the M&S Chinn family.

Where grown 3: An unspecified region of Peru. Anywhere in an area measuring 1,285,216km2, then.


Appearance 1: A slim and sinuous body topped with a quiff Elvis would envy.

Appearance 2: Supersized, with an on-trend purple to green ombre effect.

Appearance 3: As thick and off-green in colour as a gangrenous finger.


Smell 1: Nothing.

Smell 2: Clean.

Smell 3: Kissed by angels. Angels wearing detergent flavoured lip-balm.


To touch 1: Like a magic wand.

To touch 2: Like a rubber band.

To touch 3: Like a dead hand.


Taste test 1: Sweet and crisp. Eat raw as a snack. 

Taste test 2: Squeaky on the teeth but relatively mild. Eat raw if nails down a blackboard don't bother you.

Taste test 3: Neutral flavours to begin, finishing in a bitter after-taste. Eat raw if you hate your taste buds.


Barnhill farm's 'albaragus' is available to buy from the farm's on-site asparagus hut. Find out more on the business at facebook.com/BarnhillAsparagus

Additional Images: 
Contextual targeting label: 

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.