Iain Paterson and Paul Cochrane (Letters, June 30) seem to believe I have an overactive imagination about a notional independent Scotland (Letters, June 29).

Both perhaps forget that the referendum on Scottish independence is a product of mere politics. A vote in the referendum is nothing more than a fleeting vote at one passing period in time by one generation of people. Like all political votes, the motivation too is transient: it takes a very short time for the new bloom to be shed, as we well know from the lessons of the UK parliament.

Please enable cookies in your browser to display the rest of this article.