IT is an overrreaction to describe Falkirk Council’s edict on Christmas presents to teachers as an “insult to children”.

Warning parents and pupils not to give presents to teachers and school staff, and advising council employees not to accept them, does have something of the Grinch about it.

But pupils are not being insulted here. Gifts for teacher are usually something parents choose to do, out of genuine gratitude and appreciation, particularly where pupils have been given additional help in overcoming academic problems or in recognition of excellent pastoral care. In some cases it is driven by a particular fondness felt by a pupil.

In some cases, however, the Christmas gift has become close to a competitive sport, or just more festive commercialism – with companies marketing cards and treats for teachers as just another avenue for seasonal excess.

While Falkirk’s approach may seem a little heavy-handed, it is best viewed as a reminder to exercise a little common-sense. Teachers generally appreciate a note of appreciation as much as a gift, and something hand-made from a child is often as welcome as a pre-packaged purchase from a supermarket or card shop.

Teachers aren’t likely to be disciplined and parents aren’t likely to be reprimanded for giving gifts. But both should keep a sense of perspective. It is the thoughts that count.