• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Carney: joining EU may force RBS to go to London

ROYAL Bank of Scotland might have to leave Edinburgh and move its headquarters to London if an independent Scotland joined the European Union, the governor of the Bank of England, has suggested.

AS HE SEES IT: Mark Carney told MPs Scotland would need currency reserves many times its GDP in the event of sterlingisation. Picture: PA Wire
AS HE SEES IT: Mark Carney told MPs Scotland would need currency reserves many times its GDP in the event of sterlingisation. Picture: PA Wire

Mark Carney told MPs pursuing EU membership would result in an independent Scotland having to commit to joining the euro "in the fullness of time", meaning any other arrangement such as Alex Salmond's preferred currency union - ruled out by Westminster - would be only a temporary arrangement.

Appearing before the Commons Treasury Committee, Mr Carney also stressed how an independent Scotland would need currency reserves many times the size of its GDP to withstand the pressures from international markets.

Asked if RBS would have to move to the remaining UK if an independent Scotland joined the EU, the Governor replied: "It's a distinct possibility but I shouldn't prejudge it. It depends on their arrangements."

His remarks came in the context of recent reports about how EU rules required banks to have their HQs in the countries where most of their customers lived; in the case of RBS, this would be England.

Asked if Scotland would need to establish its own currency before joining the euro or if it could apply to join straight away, Mr Carney said "any new application to join the European Union would include a commitment to join the euro in the fullness of time".

The First Minister maintains a currency union is the SNP Government's preferred option despite all three main Westminster parties saying it will not happen. One Whitehall source insisted the idea was now "dead".

In January, the Governor made clear in a speech in Edinburgh that an effective currency union would force a newly-independent Scotland to cede some national sovereignty to London.

Yesterday, he stressed that he would not judge whether a currency union should happen or not but warned the option of so-called sterlingisation - Scotland continuing to use the pound in the absence of a currency union - would leave it without the insurance of a lender of last resort. He said that with a curr-ency union the Bank's services currently provided to Scotland would be "passported over" while, without one, each service would have to be reviewed.

But the Governor agreed a currency union or sterlingisation would be tested by the markets because it "would be seen as a temporary arrangement" and this would mean Scotland would need substantial currency reserves to withstand the pressure.

Asked if £6 billion of reserves would suffice, he pointed to the example of Hong Kong, which had reserves "multiple times the size of its GDP; £6bn is not multiple times Scotland's GDP".

The Governor also noted how viability within a currency union was "a bit like being pregnant. You can't be half viable in a currency union; you need all the components".

A Better Together spokesman said what people in Scotland needed was clarity from Alex Salmond about his Plan B for what would replace the pound.

But Stewart Hosie for the SNP, who sits on the Treasury Committee, said he was pleased by Mr Carney's confirmation about the Bank's "neutrality on the issue of Scottish independence and that his Edinburgh speech was a technical assessment of currency unions not a judgment on independence".

l A major Scottish investor has said independence could lead to prolonged uncertainty. Edinburgh-based Murray International Trust, an investment arm of Aberdeen Asset Management, states in its financial report: "The company is registered in Scotland and the board is mindful that there is uncertainty arising in relation to the referendum on Scottish independence."

Contextual targeting label: 

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.