• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Medical expert says Yes vote could be good for your health

THE surgeon who became Scotland's most senior medical official, appointed by Labour in 2005 and retained when the SNP came to power, has come out in favour of independence.

WARNING: Sir Harry Burns, former chief medical officer for Scotland, voices concerns on NHS. Picture Julie Howden
WARNING: Sir Harry Burns, former chief medical officer for Scotland, voices concerns on NHS. Picture Julie Howden

Sir Harry Burns has argued independence would be better for people's individual health and would provide an opportunity for Scotland to avoid the privatisation of the health service south of the Border.

Now professor of global public health at Strathclyde University, Sir Harry has come out in favour of a Yes vote in September on both personal and wider grounds.

Sir Harry, who stepped down as chief medical officer for Scotland earlier this year, also said he feared for the NHS in England, where ministers have made "very different" decisions from Scotland.

Independence campaigners welcomed Sir Harry's comments ahead of the coming referendum.

He told BBC Radio Scotland's Crossfire programme: "The question is, would people in an independent country feel more in control of their lives? If they did, then that would be very positive for their health.

"If people felt that they were able to engage more with local government, with central government and make choices more easily for themselves then that would improve their health."

He said the question of how leaving the UK and becoming independent would make people feel more in control would "depend very much on the political decisions that are made".

He added: "At the moment, decisions - particularly about the health service - being made in England are very different from the decisions being made in Scotland.

"That is very important because I fear for the way the health service is going in England."

SNP MSP Aileen McLeod, a member of Holyrood's Health Committee, said the comments from the "highly respected former chief medical officer are very welcome indeed".

She added: "Sir Harry recognises the opportunities independence could bring for Scotland's health as a nation, stating that if this led to people feeling more in control of their lives then their health would improve.

"Sir Harry also adds to the growing number of people raising concern about the NHS south of the Border. Dr Philippa Whitford, a consultant breast cancer surgeon, recently spoke out about NHS privatisation, warning there would not be a health service south of the Border in five years' time.

"With the powers of the Scottish Parliament we have been able to protect our NHS from privatisation."

She said Westminster was "obsessed" with dismantling the NHS, and cuts to its budget south of the Border would have an impact in Scotland in the event of a No vote.

She added: "This is a risk we can't take. Only a Yes vote gives us the powers we need to ensure Westminster privatisation of the NHS stops at the Border - and that the NHS in Scotland can continue to deliver world-class health care for everyone who needs it."

Dr Willie Wilson, co-founder of the NHS for Yes group, said: "When someone of Sir Harry's stature and expertise says that independence could have a very positive impact on improving the country's health, everybody should take notice."

He added: "What Sir Harry says is both timely and sensible. We are fortunate in Scotland that the NHS is devolved, but devolution cannot give the health service the protection it needs when Westminster continues to hold the purse strings. Unless we seize the opportunity that a Yes vote offers, it is very likely Scotland, against our will, could be forced down the route of privatisation and commercialisation of our public health service, as is happening right now in England and Wales."

A Scottish Labour spokesman said: "Whether Scotland votes Yes or No, we will still face significant challenges in delivering the kind of NHS people want with an ageing population and squeezed budgets.

"Scotland's top doctor has described the SNP's running of the NHS as a car crash and until this Government stops seeing everything through the prism of independence, patients will continue to pay the price."

Contextual targeting label: 
Health

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.

248992