• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Celtic player ratings

Here's how the home heroes rated:

Commons scores the penalty
Commons scores the penalty

FRASER FORSTER - The goalkeeper, who has played so well throughout the Champions League campaign, had a quiet night. Left exposed as Ferreira Ari chipped him for Spartak's goal and made one comfortable save in the second half. 6

EMILIO IZAGUIRRE - Went missing as Ari was given acres of space to equalise for Spartak but linked with Samaras in the second half. 6

MIKAEL LUSTIG - Continuously got forward down the right and won a number of corners, coped well defensively. 7

KELVIN WILSON - Given a difficult game by Emmanuel Emenike and could only help the ball on its way as he chased back Ari's chip. 6

EFE AMBROSE - Composed start as others around him seemed nervous, but outmuscled by his fellow Nigerian Emenike as he threatened throughout. 6

BERAM KAYAL - Came in for the suspended Victor Wanyama and despite lacking the strength of the Kenyan closed down the midfield to good effect. 6

SCOTT BROWN - A captain's performance as he showed no signs of his long-standing hip injury in covering the entire pitch and taking on a more attacking role. 8

CHARLIE MULGREW - Excitement rose in the stadium every time Celtic won a corner but Mulgrew did not deliver the inviting crosses that have led to so many of Celtic's European goals. 6

KRIS COMMONS - Kept his cool to smash the decisive penalty straight down the middle and in off the bar to send the home fans into a frenzy. Later carried off on a stretcher after a reckless Kallstrom tackle. 7

GEORGIOS SAMARAS - Hit the post and won the penalty as he drove Celtic forward in the second half after a subdued opening period. Tried to take on one player too many with his trademark mazy runs. 8

GARY HOOPER - Clinical finish as he capitalised on Juan Insaurralde's mistake to fire Celtic ahead but remained largely isolated up front after his goal. 7


ADAM MATTHEWS (for Lustig, 71 minutes) - Little chance to make an impression. 4

LASSAD NOUIOUI (for Kayal, 73) - Brought on as Celtic searched for a goal and held the ball up well. 5

JOE LEDLEY (for Brown, 84) - Came on as the captain tired and shored up the midfield. 4

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.