• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Man City v Barcelona: player ratings

Here's how the teams fared individually:

David Silva
David Silva


Joe Hart: Had had a pretty quiet evening until he picked Messi's penalty out of his net, and then beaten again late on. 6

Pablo Zabaleta: Tough task dealing with Iniesta but kept calm and set up Silva for a great late chance. 7

Vincent Kompany: Embodied City's defensive spirit, some terrific challenges. 8

Martin Demichelis: He may be the butt of many jokes, but he was excellent until his red card for bringing down Messi. 7

Gael Clichy: Teamed up with Kolarov to keep Messi and Dani Alves from marauding down City's left flank and it worked for most of the time. 6

Jesus Navas: Played so deep he was almost a full-back, but had the pace to unsettle Jordi Alba at times and set up Negredo for a great chance. 6

Fernandinho: Unyielding at the heart of the midfield, he worked hard to try to draw the sting from Barcelona. 7

Yaya Toure: Rarely ventured forward - not a memorable match against his former club. 5

Aleksandar Kolarov: Good physical tussle with Alves ended honours even. 6

David Silva: His style is so much like a Barcelona player, and came so close to an equaliser late on but shot was well saved. 7

Alvaro Negredo: Would have been bitterly disappointed not to make the most of two good chances. 5


Joleon Lescott: Came on to fill the gap left by Demichelis' dismissal. 6

Samir Nasri: Had a positive impact after coming on. 6

Edin Dzeko: Looked as though he might be the hero but pushed Pique at crucial moment. 5


Victor Valdes: Unsettled at times by Negredo's physical presence but dealt with City's efforts well. 7

Dani Alves: Kept at bay for much of the time by City's defensive-minded set-up but then scored a last-minute second goal. 7

Gerard Pique: Unflustered presence in Barca's defence and had a goal wrongly ruled out for offside. 7

Javier Mascherano: Even against Negredo, refused to be out-muscled. 6

Jordi Alba: Not one of his most eye-catching performances. 6

Xavi: Kept the tiki taka-meter ticking over and a couple of decent strikes. 7

Sergio Busquets: Often looked second-best to Silva. 6

Cesc Fabregas: The now-bearded maestro played his part. 7

Alexis Sanchez: Found City's packed defence difficult to break down. 5

Lionel Messi: Difference between the teams - superb run to win the penalty and fired home the spot-kick with aplomb. 8

Andres Iniesta: Typical skilful performance but just lacking an edge. 6


Neymar: Came on to set up Alves' goal. 6

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.