• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Player ratings: Rangers v Dundee Utd

Here's how the players performed:


STEVE SIMONSEN: Deputising for the concussed Cammy Bell, the Englishman could do nothing for first two United goals but blundered badly at the third to kill off Rangers' hopes. 4/10

RICHARD FOSTER: Looked like a rabbit caught in the headlights as he gifted the ball to Nadir Ciftci in the build-up to United's second. 4

BILEL MOHSNI: Nervy display from the Frenchman as he gave away possession time and again. Lucky not to concede a penalty when he barged into Ciftci just before half-time. 5

LEE McCULLOCH: The Rangers captain was culpable as he was caught ball watching for Armstrong's goal. 5

STEVEN SMITH: Curled home a free-kick to give Rangers belief just before the break. 6

FRASER AIRD: Replaced by Nicky Clark with just under half an hour left despite being Rangers best performer as he provided menace down the left. 7

IAN BLACK: Passing accuracy was below par as Light Blues struggled to keep hold of possession. Booked for row with Armstrong. 5

NICKY LAW: Inadvertently hit the bar with a cross but all too often lacked composure under pressure form the United midfield. 5

ARNOLD PERALTA: On basis of first-half display, it is hard to believe Honduran might go to the World Cup. Better after half-time. 5

DEAN SHIELS: Glaring miss went put clean through on Radoslaw Cierzniak with game still goalless. 5

JON DALY: Should have scored against his old side with Rangers 1-0 down but blazed horribly over. 5


NICKY CLARK (on 64, for AIRD): Struggled to get himself involved in Rangers' attacks. 3


RADOSLAW CIERZNIAK: Went down in stages as he was beaten by Smith's set-piece but made amends with reflex save when another free-kick from the Rangers defender took a wild deflection. 6

MARK WILSON: Hooked after an hour just moments after picking up a booking for a foul on Shiels. Replaced by Keith Watson. 6

JOHN SOUTTAR: Played in Armstrong for the goal with a header in behind the Ibrox side's back four and looked steady dealing with Shiels. 6

GAVIN GUNNING: Had to wrestle with Daly a few times but coped well overall with the physical test. 7

ANDY ROBERTSON: Young full-back was busier in the second half as Peralta upped his game but still did not look ruffled. 6

PAUL PATON: Snapped at Black and Law's heels every time they got near the ball. Energetic display. 7

JOHN RANKIN: Looked far stronger than his opposite numbers in the Rangers midfield. 7

STUART ARMSTRONG: Kept a cool head to put United ahead and was involved in their second too. Less involved after the break, though. Cautioned after spat with Black. 8

RYAN GAULD: Quiet day for the Scotland Under-21 international. Replaced by Dow midway through second half. 5

GARY MACKAY-STEVEN: Got lucky with the second goal when his mis-hit shot bounced over Simonsen. Came close to a fourth for his side near the end. 7

NADIR CIFTCI (pictured): Will never score an easier goal after Simonsen's gaffe presented him with an empty net. A great shift. 7


KEITH WATSON (on 61, for WILSON): Added solidity to United's backline. 3

RYAN DOW (on 67, for GAULD): Did not see much of the ball. 2

MORGARO GOMIS (on 86, for ROBERTSON): On for the final stages. 1

Contextual targeting label: 

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.