• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Scotland v England player ratings

Here's an assessment of how the players performed:


STUART HOGG: Boggy pitch limited his chances to attack but dependable in defence. 6

TOMMY SEYMOUR: A frustrating day for the wing but not the worst Scot on show. 5

ALEX DUNBAR: Defended stoutly before being sin-binned for not releasing Jonny May. 5

MATT SCOTT: Struggled with the pace of the game as he made his first start since November. 5

SEAN LAMONT: Try-saving tackle just before the break as Scotland clung on. 6

DUNCAN WEIR: Reverted back to his kicking game but faded after the break. 6

GREIG LAIDLAW: The new skipper's box-kicks pinned England down. Busy around the breakdown. 6

RYAN GRANT: Toured with the Lions in the summer but the prop is well short of form. 4

ROSS FORD: Four line-outs lost from Edinburgh hooker's throw in just 42 minutes of action. Will fear for his place. 4

MORAY LOW: A better performance than last week's in Dublin but that is not saying much. 5

TIM SWINSON: Quiet afternoon from the lock despite putting in a tremendous shift. 5

JIM HAMILTON: Nowhere near Courtney Lawes and Joe Launchbury at the line-out contests but usual warrior self at the breakdown. 6

RYAN WILSON: Carried well but lucky not to take a stint in the sin-bin after clashing with Lawes. 5

CHRIS FUSRARO: Picked ahead of captain Kelly Brown and showed promise on his debut. 6

DAVID DENTON: Another battering-ram from the Edinburgh number eight. 7


MIKE BROWN: Scored a try in a man-of-the-match performance. Superb. 8

JACK NOWELL: Another strong afternoon from the rookie wing. 6

LUTHER BURRELL: Clearly belongs in the Test arena. Strong and direct. 7

BILLY TWELVETREES: Less conspicuous than his centre partner. Quiet. 6

JONNY MAY: Lively and elusive throughout. Enjoyed his third cap. 7

OWEN FARRELL: Niggly at times, but finished in credit overall. 7

DANNY CARE: Once again the heartbeat of England's attacking game. 7

JOE MARLER: Solid at the set-piece. Developing into a class act. 7

DYLAN HARTLEY: Always where the action was at its fiercest. 7

DAN COLE: Anchored the scrum and impressive overall. 7

JOE LAUNCHBURY: Did a lot of the unseen work in a fine shift. 7

COURTNEY LAWES: Combative and forceful as always. 7

TOM WOOD: England's warrior flanker imposed himself. 6

CHRIS ROBSHAW: One of his quieter games for England. 6

BILLY VUNIPOLA: Immense. Carried strongly and showed great hands. 8.

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.