• Text size      
  • Send this article to a friend
  • Print this article

A mistress driven to murder

It was a triangle that ended with a tragic walk in the woods,

and its small-screen dramatisation, showing on Monday,

proves truth can be more compulsive viewing than fiction

IT would be stretching the imagination to describe Kate Hardie as classically beautiful.

Loading article content

Indeed, there is a distinct possibility that she looks a little like her father. The problem is that no one really knows what her father, the former Goodie turned bird-watcher Bill Oddie, looks like underneath his heavy-duty beard.

But there is an undeniable coquettish charm about razor-haired Hardie, a combination of innocence and mischief in her face. She appears vulnerable, impressionable, gullible. She seems to have the word ''victim'' stamped across her forehead.

In her relatively short screen career to date, the 27-year-old actress has played an abused homeless teenager (in Antonia Bird's award-winning film Safe), the long-suffering wife of East End mobster Reggie Kray (in The Krays), and the girlfriend of transvestite psycho David Martin (in Open Fire).

On Monday her distinguished list of television performances stretches even further with Beyond Reason, a scorching two-hour drama from Carlton. She portrays real-life killer Susan Christie, the mistress who murdered the wife of her Army Captain lover in 1991. So why, as an actress, does Kate Hardie have this thing about traumatic roles?

''I'm very attracted to heavyweight material,'' she says. ''Actually having some sort of input into society and showing things as they are makes acting incredibly interesting to me.

''I'd like to do some lighter work but actually I still find acting a bit embarrassing as a job for a grown-up, so if I do something that has a bit more power I feel more responsible.''

Beyond Reason, which cost #1.5m to make, is based on the trial transcripts of the actual case. It is written by Lucy Gannon (Soldier Soldier, Peak Practice) and co-stars Simon Shephard (Peak Practice, Chancer) and Jennifer Ehle (Camomile Lawn). It is a classic case of truth being far more compulsive viewing than fiction.

On March 27, 1991, two young women, Penny McAllister and Susan Christie, went for a walk in Drumkeeragh Forest, County Down. Fifteen minutes later Penny was lying dead, her throat slashed, and Susan was running from the wood, screaming hysterically.

She claimed that they had been attacked by an unknown man who had attempted to rape her and slain Penny. Three days later, Susan was charged with the murder. The police had made the fatal connection. Penny was the wife of dashing Captain Duncan McAllister, a fast-rising officer in the Royal Corps of Signals who was on a tour of duty in Northern Ireland, and Susan, a private in the Ulster Defence Regiment, was his mistress.

The subsequent and highly-publicised trial ended with Susan being sentenced to four years in prison; increased to nine years on appeal.

The most compelling aspect of the affair was the fact that it should have happened the other way around. In crimes of passion it is usually the mistress who is the victim, not the wife.

The seeds of tragedy had been sown two years earlier when Susan met the ambitious and determined McAllister at a local diving club. What happened next was little more than a casual fling to the officer but it was a torrid and passionate love affair for the young woman.

McAllister may have been an officer but he certainly was no gentleman. His unbecoming conduct started only two weeks after he met Susan, then 19. It was he who suggested that they become lovers. He would make love to her on the shores of Belfast Lough and, when his wife was away, in the bedroom of his married quarters. Once, while on a diving trip abroad, they made love in the water while the unsuspecting Penny sunbathed on the beach.

The affair came to a head in 1991 when McAllister told Susan he was being posted to Germany. It was over. They would, he said, have one final weekend together. They never did. Three days later, Penny and Susan went for their fateful walk in the woods.

Susan Christie's five-day trial in Belfast ended with her being found not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

The case raised questions about the law of homicide, sentencing policy, military discipline and, ultimately, the human heart and mind. How could an apparently respectable, well-brought-up young girl take the life of a beautiful and selfless woman. And, more to the point, how could she think that she could not only get away with it but also end up with her victim's husband?

Writer Lucy Gannon explains: ''I gradually became intrigued by this awful tragedy, by our ability to delude ourselves and to destroy life for the meanest and shabbiest of reasons.

''I did not go into this project lightly. There is a responsibility to the memory of Penny and to her family as well as to the family of Susan, because they too are innocent of wrong doing. There is a duty to the truth, neither to glamorise it nor to blacken any further the names involved.''

Kate Hardie describes the film as ''a terrifying modern study of flawed human beings''.

She goes on: ''I can't understand killing but that's because I'm squeamish. But I can understand losing perspective and reality and rationale so much that in a split second you've done something that your brain is telling you you can't have done.

''I'm sure Susan Christie was an extraordinary, ambitious and forward-thinking girl and got what she wanted in a tough, male-dominated aggressive world.''

Commenting & Moderation

We moderate all comments on HeraldScotland on either a pre-moderated or post-moderated basis.
If you're a relatively new user then your comments will be reviewed before publication and if we know you well and trust you then your comments will be subject to moderation only if other users or the moderators believe you've broken the rules

Moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours. Please be patient if your posts are not approved instantly.