NEWSVIEW: Moment of discovery to rival that of Tutankhamun.
LOUDON TEMPLE reflects on the discovery of a lost masterpiece crafted
as part of the only major European commission for Glasgow's most famous
son.
MUSEUM curators in Vienna made a remarkable discovery in their dusty
vaults when workmen uncovered a lost masterpiece made for Charles Rennie
Mackintosh's only major Continental commission -- the
turn-of-the-century music room for the extravagant home of avant garde
collector Fritz Waerndorfer.
The priceless Art Nouveau frieze, by Mackintosh's wife Margaret
Macdonald, had lain without being noticed in the cellar for over fifty
years.
It was only when contractors began preparation for a basement
renovation programme in Vienna's Museum of Applied Art, that the
astounding discovery was made.
Scholars of Mackintosh and his work have for decades believed that all
of the contents of the Waerndorfer music room had been lost forever.
Then, in 1990, a large wooden crate was found concealed behind a
partition wall and a large chest. When museum staff prised open the lid
they discovered the three long-lost panels, each measuring 60ins by
79ins, illustrating a scene from Maurice Maeterlinck's play The Seven
Princesses.
The discovery must have mirrored the magical moment in November 1922,
when Howard Carter first set eyes on the gleaming solid gold mask of
Tutankhamun.
Protected in its wooden casket from the harmful effects of the
atmosphere and daylight, the triptych, as good as new, presented a
stunning sight.
Mr Reinald Franz, the museum's resident expert on Mackintosh, is in no
doubt that the piece ranks alongside all the important works from the
Art Nouveau period.
Describing the find as ''incredible'' and the frieze as ''amazing'',
he estimates its value to be several hundred thousand pounds ''or
more''.
''As far as we can tell, it was brought to the museum during the
Second World War, as lots of pieces were, to be protected here. Whoever
was responsible must have feared that the slightest hint of its location
would have placed it in some peril,'' he said.
''We have correspondence between the lawyer who was handling the sale
of the house and its contents on behalf of Mrs Lily Waerndorfer in 1916.
She was looking for 30,000 Crowns for some of the artefacts, including
the panels, but the museum just could not afford it at that time,'' he
revealed.
The elaborate frieze, executed in classic Art Nouveau style, captures
the moment in The Seven Princesses when the central figure of the prince
cradles the dead princess in his arms, with two mourning figures on his
right and four to his left.
The exotic, almost fairytale scene, lavishly decorated with huge
sweeping swirls, was built up on a gesso-covered wooden base, on which
layer after layer of plaster was applied, then heavily decorated with
inlays of mother-of-pearl and semi-precious stones.
Following careful restoration, the fabulous tryptych can be seen again
in public for the first time since it was concealed in the darkened
chamber during the Nazi era.
The panels have been placed on permanent display in the museum and are
rated among the most important pieces held in its impressive collection.
''There is no doubt that it ranks alongside the very cream of the work
from the period.
It is of major worldwide importance and, in my opinion, is up there
with the very best of Gustav Klimt,'' added the enthusiastic Mr Franz.
''Quite apart from the fact that it is an extremely rare piece, it is
also in amazingly fine condition, due to the fact that it had lain
protected for half a century.''
Despite being preserved intact, restorers found the frieze was
criss-crossed with hairline surface cracks, and set about a year-long
programme of restoration work, before it could again go on display.
Exactly how the panels came to be hidden away is a mystery that may
never be solved. The crate containing them had no labels.
There is now no doubt that the frieze, one of the most important
pieces from the Glasgow school to have survived, was the dominant
feature of Mackintosh's impressive music room.
The find finally puts an end to the fierce debate which has raged over
the years between rival camps, some of whom believed it had never even
been installed.
Another entirely separate controversy centred on whether or not the
panels had been executed by Mackintosh or his wife.
That argument can finally be laid to rest, as the elaborate panels
carry Margaret Macdonald's signature and are dated 1906.
The fate of the other furnishings, including a peculiar
rectangular-shaped grand piano, still baffles the experts.
Mr Fritz Waerndorfer, the wealthy son of a prosperous family of Jewish
textile manufacturers, gave the Scottish architect the commission after
Mackintosh had submitted entries for Alexander Koch's design competition
in 1902.
An enthusiastic patron and collector of the avant-garde, he had
befriended Gustav Klimt and, over the years, amassed many of his
drawings as well as some of the artist's best-known early canvasses.
He also possessed numerous drawings, and around 150 letters, by the
English artist Aubrey Beardsley, including the famous ''last letter''
written ''in my death agony'', in which the artist pleaded with his
publisher Leonard Smithers to destroy all of his obscene drawings in the
hope that his immortal soul ''might be saved''.
Mr Waerndorfer suffered severe financial misfortunes and was declared
bunkrupt a few years after the impressive room was completed. He left
Vienna for exile in America in 1914, and his wife Lily tried without
success to sell the house and its furnishings separately.
The entire contents of the room -- including the panels -- were
offered to the Austrian Museum for Art and Industry in 1916, but the
museum declined the opportunity to acquire them.
Records show that the house and contents were subsequently purchased
that year by Wilhelm and Martha Freund. There is an unbelievable
anecdotal suggestion from the period that the Mackintosh furniture was
''chopped up by a little girl of dubious taste''.
It was believed that a Viennese Professor, Mr Eduard Wimmer, from the
School of Applied Arts, had saved the panels from destruction and that
they had later been exhibited at the city's Museum of Arts and Crafts,
but no documentary details survive to support this assertion.
In an essay written in 1981 by a leading authority, Mr Peter Vergo, on
the vexed subject of the missing Mackintosh artefects, he states:
''Despite continual rumours that this or that piece of furniture has
turned up at some sale or in some private collection, not a trace of its
furnishings or decorations has survived.''
He believed the music room was completely destroyed around 1916, and
added: ''We are dependent on verbal descriptions and on surviving
photographs for any idea of what the room was like. The photographs,
however, provide only a partial glimpse of the interior.
''As a result, there have been disagreements among scholars over the
precise details of some of the decoration. Particularly puzzling is the
question of the frieze, which must have run along the upper part of the
walls of the room.
''In the surviving photographs, probably taken in 1903 or 1904, the
spaces above the shallow cornice on each side of the room are bare, and
are clearly waiting for decorative panels of some kind to be inserted.''
In his 1968 catalogue for the Mackintosh Centenary Exhibition, Mr
Andrew McLaren Young doubted whether the panels were ever installed, but
Mr Vergo admits that, from descriptions by art critic Ludwig Hevesi, it
would seem they had finally been in place by 1909.
All those who appreciate Mackintosh and his work were convinced,
however, that the remarkable furnishings and fittings, including the
panels, had vanished, until the triptych was unearthed in the bowels of
the Viennese museum.
Mr Reinald Franz agrees the story has intrigued students for decades
and continues to fascinate those interested in the genius of Glasgow's
most famous son.
Sadly, it is unlikely that the panels will ever be seen outside
Vienna.
He explained: ''It would be almost impossible to transport the piece.
It is extremely delicate and I fear the risk of damage would be far too
great to contemplate such a thing.''
When Mrs Pamela Robertson, curator of the Mackintosh and Scottish
Collections at Glasgow's Hunterian Art Gallery, worked on mounting the
1983 exhibition to mark the 50th anniversary of Margaret Macdonald's
death, she wished forlornly that somehow the panels might miraculously
turn up.
The frieze would certainly have given her a magnificent centrepiece.
But never in her wildest dreams did she imagine that they would
re-appear just seven years later, under such dramatic circumstances.
A leading European expert on Mackintosh and Macdonald, she describes
the frieze as the most ambitious and sophisticated piece of work she
created.
Speaking from her base at Glasgow University this week, Mrs Robertson
revealed that she had been given a sneak preview while it was lying
tucked away in the Viennese museum cellar.
''I was shown them by torchlight as they lay in the basement. It was
indeed like something from the Tutankhamun story. 'What do you see?' I
see wonderful things.
''It was just as if a veil was being drawn back -- hugely exciting --
as this is such an important piece of the Mackintosh jigsaw puzzle,''
she said.
''As one of the commentators on the Vienna scene said, the loss of the
music room was one of the greatest acts of vandalism in Mackintosh's
career.
''There has been so much intrigue about the subject, and all we were
left with was black and white photographs from this mecca for the
artistic avant-garde.
''It's like a miracle. There was an assumption that the work had not
survived.''
Glasgow museums chiefs had hoped to be able to bring the frieze to the
city next year, to coincide with the major Mackintosh retrospective
being staged in the McLellan Galleries.
The exhibition will tour the US after its Scottish run.
A spokeswoman said: ''We asked Vienna to loan us the panels, but sadly
this will not be possible. They are just too fragile and valuable.''
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article