A GIRL of 12 told a fatal accident inquiry at Dunoon yesterday how she
tried to save her best friend, Kellie Lynch, from being savaged to death
in an attack by two prize winning rottweilers.
The girl described how she lay down between the dogs, Jodie and
Cassie, to shield Kellie, but they just leapt over her and returned to
the attack.
Procurator-fiscal David Webster asked the girl: ''Did you realise you
were putting yourself in mortal danger?'' She replied: ''Yes.''
The dogs were later destroyed by their owner, hotelier Brian Simpson,
as were his two other rottweilers, Smutts and Jess.
Sheriff Principal Robert Hay ordered the public to be cleared from the
court while the girl gave her evidence.
He also made an order that the girl should not be identified, under
Section 4 (4) of the Fatal Accident and Sudden Deaths Inquiry Act of
1976.
Sheriff Hay came down from the bench, removed his wig, and sat at a
table in the well of the court while the little girl gave her evidence
from the witness box.
She and slightly built Kellie, 11, of Cotton Street, Dundee, were
spending their Easter holidays at the Cot House Inn, Kilmun, Argyll.
They regularly walked the dogs and early in the afternoon of last
April 14 had Jodie and Cassie out on leads and choker chains.
''There was never any problem with them,'' she said. ''They always
behaved. They never growled or were aggressive. We took them round the
grounds and then to a gravel pit. Both were on leads. They were quite
normal and hadn't given us any bother. When we got to the pit we sat
down, then I took Cassie because Kellie said she wanted to go to the
toilet.
''Kellie walked away and I turned my back. Suddenly the dogs leapt
towards Kellie and I tried to pull them back by their leads, but they
slipped off their necks. Kellie was nearly pulling down her trousers.''
The girl continued: ''The dogs ran up to her and both licked her face.
She started to laugh then they started biting her, I don't know why.
They were biting her arms and face and she was screaming. She was
shouting 'help' and calling my name. I started kicking them and tried to
haul them off. They were both biting at the same time.
''When I kicked them they turned and stared at me then they went back
to bite Kellie again. I couldn't get them off. I tried to pull their
paws apart. Then I lay down between the dogs and Kellie to protect her.
''They didn't bite me. They just jumped over me to get to her. She was
still screaming and I ran for help . . .''
She said that Cassie, a bitch, and Jodie, a male, had always been
obedient and obeyed her commands to sit or come or stay. ''They did
everything together. They never snarled or growled. Kellie was not
frightened of them.''
The girl said the dogs were fed once a day and did not get meat. ''I
last saw them at Christmas and I noticed Jodie was thinner when I went
back at Easter.'' She was told that it was due to his getting more
exercise.
Mr Simpson related how the girl told him Kellie had been attacked by
the two rottweilers.
''I ran to the pit and found her lying beside the river which runs
into it. She was on her side and was dead.''
Mr Simpson said the dogs were about 15ft away, standing and very calm.
Kellie had bites on her throat. A Mrs Veronica Falconer arrived and
''became hysterical. She started screaming and grabbed my arm.
''Jodie started to get very excited. He started to bite Mrs Falconer
on the arms and ankles. I hit him in the face with my hand and, when Mrs
Falconer calmed down, so did Jodie.
''I was in a state of shock.''
A vet was called and the two-year-old dogs were put down immediately.
One of the other two rottweilers destroyed was a pup of the pair, the
only survivor of the litter.
Mr Simpson said he had bought the dogs for showing but Cassie did not
take to shows and her head went down and she lost interest.
He paid #200 for Jodie and #180 for Cassie from different Belfast
breeders and made it clear he wanted them for showing, not as guard
dogs. He was assured that there was no background of aggression in their
pedigrees.
They were kept in a kennel in a run outside the hotel. Mr Simpson
estimated their weights as 11st for the male and 9st for the bitch.
The fiscal asked Mr Simpson if it had caused him some concern that
such muscular and powerful dogs were being exercised by two young
schoolgirls, and he replied no.
The fiscal said: ''Rottweilers can be a menace, sometimes a dangerous
menace. Would you agree with that?'' -- ''Yes.''
Mrs Falconer, of Afton Court, Dunoon, had been in the hotel for lunch
and heard of the attack on Kellie.
She said: ''I ran as fast as I could to the gravel pit. Then the owner
of the dogs came towards me and shouted: 'She's dead'.
''I saw Kellie lying on a sand spit in the middle of the river. Mr
Simpson had put something over her face. When I moved it away I saw a
very large wound in her neck. It really was very large. He said the dogs
had bitten her.''
Mrs Falconer thought of trying ''resuscitation or something. At the
same time I saw a large dog circling. I said to Mr Simpson: 'Why in
God's name did you let children out with dogs that size'?'' She added he
was shouting at the dog, which was circling, and it bit her on the arm.
Then it bit her other arm.
Mr Simpson used the sleeves of an anorak to tie round the dog's neck,
but it got free and bit her leg.
''I shouted: 'If you don't get that dog it will kill me.'
''When I saw the wound in Kellie's neck I couldn't say anything. I
just shut my eyes. I was shocked rigid. I remember saying: 'What in the
name of God has happened to her'?''
She said the dog was ''certainly out of verbal control''.
She added that she had been badly affected emotionally and could not
sleep without a light being left on.
Deputy police surgeon Dr Alexander Smith said Kellie's larynx was
completely separated from the rest of her body.
Asked by the fiscal about the ferocity of the attack, Dr Smith replied
it had been extremely ferocious, adding: ''I have never seen anything
like it in 15 years as a police surgeon.''
Consultant pathologist Dr John More told the inquiry the muscles of
Kellie's neck were torn and this was consistent with a dog having shaken
and violently worried her. The injury to the throat had been massive and
the back of the spinal chord could be seen.
Animal behaviour research scientist Dr Michael Baxter said that
Kellie's laughter or her first scream could have touched off the
aggression, and the more she screamed the more aggressive the dog would
become. Her throat might have been ripped out because it was the source
of the noise the dogs disliked.
Rottweilers, he said, had a 50% stronger bite than alsatians. They did
not give any warning when they were going to attack.
The hearing continues today.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article