SCOTTISH rugby's New Year honours make scant recognition of the new
McEwan's district champions. Only the Stirling County pair, Ian Jardine
and George Graham, have come through from the Glasgow team who beat the
Anglo-Scots 18-15 at Burnbrae to win the title on Saturday.
Even those two are in the Reds, the junior team, and only four other
Glasgow players are in the reserves. David Barrett, Glasgow's
match-winning goal-kicker, is among those 15 invited to sit and wait. So
are three of Graham's forward colleagues, Derek Busby, Alan Watt, and
Brian Robertson.
Kevin McKenzie, the Stirling hooker, propped by Graham and Robertson,
has been bypassed, even though he was in Scotland's team in the drawn B
international against Ireland last month. He has been eclipsed by the
rising star of John Allan, Edinburgh Academicals' hooker, who, though
born in Glasgow, established his rugby career in South Africa.
Sympathy for McKenzie can flow on to George Breckenridge, Ewan
McCorkindale, and Fergus Wallace. On the evidence of the game against
the Anglo-Scots, the Glasgow High/Kelvinside trio merited places among
the trial reserves ahead of Richard Cramb, Stuart Jardine, and Jeremy
Macklin.
Breckenridge has proved an effective pivot for Glasgow in the district
championship. Indeed, I am not alone in believing that the Anglo-Scots
would have won the Burnbrae match and the title had they had
Breckenridge as stand-off instead of Cramb.
McCorkindale's sharp hands would be a joy to any New Zealand coach. On
that count, the GHK captain would rank ahead of Greig Oliver as well as
Stuart Jardine, and Wallace, though leading from No.8, did much at
Burnbrae to mark himself as an ideal blind-side flanker.
Viewed in isolation, the breakdown of the trial teams district by
district would seem unfair. Yet a Glasgow representation of half a dozen
out of the 45 players called to the trial is no more than a realist, be
he biased or not, could have expected.
Glasgow players knew that themselves almost as soon as they had won
the championship. In the immediate aftermath, Richie Dixon, the Glasgow
coach, warned his troops not to hope for too much. Their strength was in
the unit, and even as champions, they had no super nova to light the way
to individual honours.
Glasgow rugby has an indirect interest in the senior XV with Stewart
Porter's inclusion on the left wing. The 26-year-old former Kilmarnock
and Glasgow Academicals wing, now with Malone and Ulster, came through
the B international to challenge Iwan Tukalo and Lindsay Renwick.
Tukalo played against Fiji in October, and when he dropped out because
of an arm injury, Renwick took over for the match against Romania. Those
two now are in the Reds, with Tukalo having proved at least his match
fitness by scoring four tries for Selkirk in the 39-9 win over
Corstorphine on Saturday.
As for other points in the trial teams, the area of most general
debate will centre on the selection of Finlay Calder, OBE, the Lions'
victorious captain last year, and his fellow tourist, John Jeffrey, as
wing forwards in the Reds. Iain Milne, long the keystone of Scotland's
scrummage, also is in the junior XV.
Derek Turnbull and Adam Buchanan-Smith are the Blues' wing forwards,
flanking Scotland's other Lions breakaway, Derek White. Who knows,
however, whether the selectors are looking for Turnbull and
Buchanan-Smith to depose the more established pair? The more gratuitous
view would be that Calder, especially as captain, and Jeffrey are where
they are to provide direction and impetus for the Reds to give the Blues
the kind of competition that would make the trial all the more
meaningful.
Whatever Calder's fate, he will play no international rugby after this
season. That final curtain was hung on its rails when he intimated after
Edinburgh's 40-12 victory over the South at Myreside on Saturday that
that district match, his fortieth, was his last.
Turnbull has been out of rugby for the past two weeks with rib damage,
but he has assured the selectors that he will be fit for the trial. So
have Damian Cronin and Gary Armstrong, both injured in district matches
on Saturday. Cronin retired from the Burnbrae match with recurrence of a
back injury, though afterwards he said he was sure that it was nothing
that an osteopath's treatment could not rectify, and Armstrong had a
groin-muscle strain while he was playing for the South in the Myreside
match.
Turnbull, whose last cap was against England two years ago, and Porter
alone of the Blues have not played in either of Scotland's international
wins over Fiji and Romania this season. Most of the old guard remain
despite the relegation -- if it is such -- of Calder and Jeffrey and the
absence of Craig Chalmers because of injury.
John Allan is among just six uncapped players in the Reds along with
Jeremy Richardson, Andy MacDonald, Cameron Glasgow, Paul Rouse, and Ian
Jardine. Rouse, the 23-year-old Dundee High centre, though the only
North and Midlands representative in the teams, undeniably deserves
inclusion as one who, like his trial partner, Ian Jardine, is a direct,
strong runner who meets the modern requirement to stay on his feet in
the tackle.
Finally, to return to Glasgow's first district championship since
1973-74, Barrett's six penalty goals not only edged out a narrow win but
also took the West of Scotland full back past two records for his
district. He scored 79 points in all matches for Glasgow this season and
50 in the championship, and the first of those figures, moreover, is
second in the overall list only to the 97 by Peter Dods for the South in
1983-84.
Yet even those substantial hauls, like the limited trial
representation, cannot deny the worth of a team effort. The next stage
is for more individuals to develop from the unit that they have made.
Dixon's Devils responded to Fergus Wallace's lead with no less vigour
than those who answered the call from the Glasgow captain's ancestor all
those centuries ago.
Trial teams
Blues -- A G Hastings (London Scottish); A G Stanger (Hawick), S
Hastings (Watsonians), S R P Lineen (Boroughmuir), S T G Porter
(Malone); D S Wyllie (Stewart's Melville FP), G Armstrong (Jed-Forest);
D M B Sole (Edinburgh Academicals), captain, K S Milne (Heriot's FP), A
P Burnell (London Scottish), C A Gray (Nottingham), D F Cronin (Bath), D
J Turnbull (Hawick), D B White, G A E Buchanan-Smith (both London
Scottish).
Reds -- P W Dods (Gala); W L Renwick (London Scottish), P F Rouse
(Dundee HS FP), I C Jardine (Stirling County), I Tukalo (Selkirk); I C
Glasgow (Heriot's FP), G H Oliver (Hawick); G Graham (Stirling County),
J Allan (Edinburgh Academicals), I G Milne (Heriot's FP), J F Richardson
(Edinburgh Academicals), A E D MacDonald (Cambridge University), J
Jeffrey (Kelso), G R Marshall (Selkirk), F Calder (Stewart's Melville
FP), captain.
Reserves -- G R T Baird (Kelso), D N Barrett (West of Scotland), R I
Cramb (London Scottish), B Edwards (Boroughmuir), S Jardine (South
Glamorgan Institute), A Moore (Edinburgh Academicals), A C Redpath
(Melrose), J D Busby (Glasgow High/Kelvinside), I Corcoran (Gala), C D
Hogg (Melrose), A J Macklin (London Scottish), G B Robertson (Stirling
County), A G J Watt (Glasgow High/Kelvinside), G W Weir (Melrose), G D
Wilson (Boroughmuir).
Referee -- J B Anderson (Currie).
McEwan's district championship
Final table
PWDLFAPt
Glasgow
McEwan's Tankards for most tries -- Edinburgh 13; Glasgow 8;
Anglo-Scots 7; North-Midlands 6; South 5.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article