HeraldScotland: Neil Mackay unspun banner NEW

The SNP has just effectively admitted that its vision of an independent Scotland back in Europe is sheer fantasy.

The problem is: the party won’t admit that to the Scottish public, and is once more treating us like the mushrooms the leadership clearly thinks we are - keeping us in the dark and feeding us on the unmentionable.

A decision has been taken - conveniently - not to debate a motion at its upcoming annual conference calling for a frictionless border between an independent Scotland and England. The motion was earlier on the draft agenda. But abracadabra! It’s now gone.

To anyone with half a brain, the decision to drop the motion makes complete sense: why debate something that’s entirely nonsensical.

Regular readers will know that I’m a pro-European and a moderate supporter of independence - with a hefty loathing for any form of nationalism, Scottish or British. So I’d really like to see an independent Scotland one day return to the EU. I also detest the idea of a hard border with our friends and neighbours in England. However, those two positions are entirely incompatible. Although I may wish these opposites to both be attainable - they are not, as Northern Ireland post-Brexit proves.


To read the rest of this analysis, sign up to The Herald's political newsletter, Unspun, for FREE and get unrivalled political analysis in your inbox every day at 6pm.

Sign up here.