3 out of 5 stars

Why Planes Crash - and which seats the safety experts book

"Sully" Sullenberger successfully landed a plane on the Hudson River after a bird strike <i>(Image: BBC/Windfall Films Ltd)</i>
"Sully" Sullenberger successfully landed a plane on the Hudson River after a bird strike (Image: BBC/Windfall Films Ltd)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Why Planes Crash

BBC One/iPlayer

***

Alison Rowat reviews a new documentary about a recent spate of air disasters. Is flying becoming increasingly dangerous, and are there any measures passengers can take to reduce the risk?

If you are a nervous traveller, it is probably best to steer clear of the BBC’s “Why …” series. Promising to “delve into the mysteries and science behind the stories that hit the headlines”, previous programmes include why trains crash, why ships crash, and why bridges collapse. You get the message. 

This hour-long investigation examined four crashes that happened over the space of a year, starting with the Jeju Air flight 226 disaster in South Korea last December.  First came a bird strike, then the plane crashed into a barrier, killing 179 people on board. 

Bird strikes are very rare said the narrator, before going on to detail perhaps the most famous example of one - the “Miracle on the Hudson” when “Sully”  Sullenberger, played by Tom Hanks in the movie that inevitably followed, successfully landed his plane on the Hudson River after a bird strike. All 155 passengers and crew survived. 

As with other crashes involving birds, samples from the Hudson were sent to a special unit at the Smithsonian in Washington, DC. The lab takes delivery of everything from DNA to bodies. “When we get a bird carcass in the mail, our mail room is very upset with us,” said the head of the unit. In the Hudson River case, the birds were Canadian geese; in the South Korea crash, they were small ducks that can fly in flocks of up to 80,000.  

Among the film’s contributors were pilots, aviation safety experts, eyewitnesses and, most poignantly, the families of those who died taking what they thought were routine flights.

The other disasters covered were the collision of a Black Hawk helicopter and a passenger plane in Washington; the crash landing of a Minnesota-Toronto flight; and the loss of an Ahmedabad to Gatwick flight shortly after takeoff. Only one passenger survived the latter: a British national sitting next to an emergency exit. 


Read more


One expert said there were no “magic seats” on a plane, but he opts for one that is within five rows of an emergency exit because every second counts after a crash. Tell that to those at Toronto Airport who, having survived the landing, went back to retrieve their bags. 

Packed with detail and slickly edited, the film only faltered when it came to clear conclusions. Flying remained one of the safest forms of travel, we were told. While there were some lessons to be learned, including don’t build an airport near bird nesting sites, the main takeaway seemed to be that more people were flying, so there were more chances of things going wrong. 

As Captain Sully put it: “As aviation has become safer, accident causes have become more unique. In terms of low probability/high consequence events, we must understand that given enough time, given enough flight operations, eventually whatever can happen will happen. We must be prepared not only for the predictable but for the unimaginable.”

Not terribly reassuring, even if the advice did come from a genuine hero of the skies. 









Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos