Another day and another row rocks the BBC

US President Donald Trump gestures while speaking during a “Make America Wealthy Again” trade announcement <i>(Image: Andrew Harnik)</i>
US President Donald Trump gestures while speaking during a “Make America Wealthy Again” trade announcement (Image: Andrew Harnik)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Another busy day for the BBC press office. Not long after the broadcast of this year’s first Reith Lecture on Radio 4 on Tuesday morning, the lecturer, Dutch historian Rutger Bregman, went online to say that his words had been censored by the BBC and they had deleted comments he made about US president Donald Trump.

“The irony could not be bigger,” Bregman continued, “because this lecture, titled A Time of Monsters, is exactly about the cowardice of today’s elites. About universities, corporations and, yes, media networks.”

Cue headlines.

In truth, even without the Trump line, Bregman’s lecture was pretty depressing about where we are right now.

Talking about the current state of politics in the United States, he said: “We see armed troops patrolling the streets. We see masked men dragging people into vans.”

By which point I was thinking, ‘Isn’t Bregman meant to be an optimist about human nature?’ He is, yes, but this first Reith lecture - 'censored' as it may have been - was a diagnosis of where we’ve gone wrong in recent decades. He was equally critical of the left and the right for our current moral rot.

Rutger Bregman (Image: Maartije Horst)

“We’ve built a meritocracy of ambition without morality, of intelligence without integrity. And now we are reaping the consequences.”

What’s the answer? A moral revolution, he suggests. One that will remind us that “the purpose of power is to do good.” But we’ll have to wait until next week to hear how that’s going to work. That’s if the BBC broadcast it.

How quickly things change in politics. On Sunday afternoon on Radio 4, Dani Garavelli, regular contributor to The Herald, looked back over the last 10 years (and counting) since 2014 and the independence referendum.

Garavelli wanted to ask what had happened in the years since and where we stand now, What was most striking, though, was how many of those she talked about have since moved from the political column into the historical column; David Cameron, Theresa May, Boris Johnson (well, here’s hoping in the wake of last week’s damning Covid-19 report), the late Alex Salmond and, of course, Nicola Sturgeon. “All political lives,” as Joseph Chamberlain once noted, “end in failure.” Has that ever been truer than in the last 10 years in the UK?

Ultimately, Garavelli argued that the SNP’s Robert the Bruce approach (“try, try and try again”) isn’t sustainable and the party needs to find a new approach.

One possibility mooted was to push for something similar to the provision in the Northern Ireland Act of 1998 which set out the triggers required for an Irish unification referendum.


Read more


Garavelli suggests that something similar would benefit both the SNP in offering up an alternative strategy, and unionist parties in Westminster, who would know the whole question of independence would be off the table until such time as particular conditions are met.

But the Northern Ireland Act was the result of a concerted international effort to end the Troubles. Is a UK government really going to put into law the conditions to end the union by choice? Or will we still be having these same arguments 10 years from now?

Another question. Are there any reasons to be cheerful, right now? The return for a third series of Whatever Happened to Baby Jane Austen on Monday afternoon, perhaps. A genuinely funny Radio 4 comedy. How often do you get that? It stars Dawn French and Jennifer Saunders (which is good) and is written by Emmy award winner David Quantick (which is even better).

Quantick was part of the writing team on both The Thick of It and Veep. This doesn’t scale those heights, but it’s a very entertaining, broad-brush comedy with French as egocentric writer Flo and Saunders playing her sister Selena, an equally up-herself actor. (Emphasis on the second syllable.) The result can be a bit panto at times. (Listen out for Saunders’s attempt at a Fife accent in the first episode). But the joy of it is the dialogue. This week’s episode saw Flo becoming the subject of a portrait painted by David Hockney no less. Selena found that difficult to accept.

“David Hockney doesn’t do portraits,” she argued. “Or threesomes. But that’s a story for another time.”

Listen Out For:

Gareth Malone’s Classical Selection Box, Classic FM, Friday, December 5, 9pm

If I was a dictator my first edict - after banning brown sauce - would be that there should be no mention of Christmas on TV, radio and newspapers until December 5 at the earliest. But as this showcase of seasonal music goes out on that very day I’ll let Gareth away with it.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos