BOOK REVIEW

Review: Castaway by Francesca de Tores is about Alexander Selkirk

The Robinson Crusoe movie from 1954 with Daniel Peter O'Herlihy <i>(Image: Buñuel)</i>
The Robinson Crusoe movie from 1954 with Daniel Peter O'Herlihy (Image: Buñuel)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Castaway, Francesca de Tores, Bloomsbury, £18.99

ANYONE coming to Castaway hoping for a 21st century reprise of Robinson Crusoe will be sorely disappointed. 

Yes, the book is based on the life of Alexander Selkirk, the marooned Scottish sailor fictionalised in Daniel Defoe’s 1719 novel, but we’re in very different territory. 

Defoe, evidently, didn’t write scenes featuring his hero feverishly masturbating whilst crying in the sand dunes.

This isn’t an adventure novel, this is a novel about the brutal business of being human. 

Francesca de Tores takes the literary device of a man on a desert island and uses it to explore what happens when a human is detached from companionship and civilisation, from even the sound of another voice or sight of another face.

What happens psychologically when we’ve nothing to rely upon but our own inner world?

De Tores could easily have given us an exercise in misery, instead she bounces readers from laughter to heartbreak, sometimes in the space of a few sentences. And her writing is exquisite. She’s a poet after all.

There are echoes of Shakespeare’s Lear in Castaway. Selkirk becomes like the ageing king an “unaccommodated man”, a human stripped of everything. 

Indeed, is Selkirk even human anymore? Has he, like Lear, become “a poor, bare, forked animal”? A hairless creature without possessions or friendship, standing alone on its hind legs.

Selkirk realises: “The great question I must answer here is: who is a man, when all the things that make up his life are stripped away.”

De Tores presents a very existential novel which seeks to uncover the true nature of humankind. She’s does so in rip-roaring, page-turning style.

Fittingly, it’s animals who provide the supporting cast. 

Once Selkirk is abandoned by his shipmates - for reasons he initially refuses to share with readers (the novel is narrated by our castaway) - he finds the island he’s imprisoned upon overrun by feral cats, wild goats and savage rats.

To keep the gnawing rats away at night, he catches and tames kittens. To provide him with food, he corrals wild goats. 

Scottish sailor Alexander Selkirk (1676 - 1721), on the uninhabited island of Mas a Tierra in the Juan Fernandes Islands, where he lived alone for four yearsScottish sailor Alexander Selkirk (1676-1721), on the uninhabited island of Mas a Tierra in the Juan Fernandes Islands, where he lived alone for four years (Image: Getty Images)

One day, a goat and cat begin speaking to Selkirk. Only slightly perturbed, he strikes up a conversation.

And so we’re introduced to Sleek, the haughty blood-thirsty cat; and the Reverend Vicarious Cronch, a wise goat fond of biblical quotations and Socratic questioning.

I’ll leave it to readers to discover whether Sleek and Cronch are figments of Selkirk’s imagination, but I assure you: we’re not in the realm of magical realism here.

In fact, it may be best to set aside any debate about what’s real and unreal in this novel and simply accept the events which occur on the island with the same stoicism as Selkirk. 

Yet you feel compelled to ask: if Selkirk is talking to animals, perhaps he’s no better than an animal himself? 

In turn, we are next compelled to ask ourselves: yet why should humans be judged ‘better’ than animals anyway? Are we of more use to the universe or planet than a goat or cat?

Selkirk even says, when Cronch and Sleek encourage him to satisfy his ravening hunger by sucking milk straight from a nanny goat’s teat: “How fearsome narrow the space between man and beast has become.”

Selkirk is spectacularly good company. As a young man in the town of Nether Largo in Fife, he was a rebel, a thorn in the side of his father and the church. 

Castaway by Francesca de Tores (Image: Bloomsbury)

He leaves his first love behind in their village and runs away to sea where he soon rises up the ranks of the navy as an accomplished navigator. In port, he’s a fighting, drinking, womanising cliche.

Yet he’s fearsomely clever and very funny. He notes at one point that “goats when distressed have an ungodly shriek like a drunken man falling and landing on bagpipes”.

Selkirk takes part in Scotland’s infamously shambolic attempt to start its own empire: the Darien Venture. 

Once that fails, he heads back to sea as a privateer, hunting Spanish galleons around Cape Horn. His anti-authoritarianism puts him in conflict with the officers above him, and leads to his marooning.

Selkirk is a man shackled by the demands of his time: religion, family, duty. The isolation of the island sets him free.

Alone, he has the wisdom to stare deep inside himself. He doesn’t just navigate the high seas, Selkirk marooned navigates his own soul.

His animal friends put him on trial (or is it Selkirk’s subconscious subjecting him to inquisition?) for all his crimes and failings. 


Read more


He has done wrong to many people in his life, particularly his first love Effie back in Fife. 

Certainly, Selkirk is a man capable of repentance, and therefore he’s also worthy of redemption. But this isn’t a book about religion, nor about a religious man. 

Selkirk has a bible with him, however he uses it for a very unconventional form of spiritual sustenance. 

He takes charcoal and blacks out whole sections of the bible so what’s left behind becomes a kind of personalised ‘found poetry’.

Selkirk, for example, redacts Genesis until it reads: “The Earth was filled with … stories … I … have … seen … the face of the … beasts … and … everything … opened.”

Selkirk is one of the most complex and fascinating Scottish characters ever created. He’s a curmudgeonly fool at times, yet he has the spirit of a poet. He can be vile and cruel, yet he’s also loving and kind beyond measure. Selfish, yet selfless; cowardly yet brave; witty, yet a melancholic. 

As his time on the island progresses, Selkirk eventually loses the need for language. A man who once found joy only in sex and drink is moved to ecstasy at sunlight dappling leaves.

Evidently, we know how the story ends - history tells us. Selkirk is rescued from the island.

But our Selkirk is also rescued from the horror of an inauthentic life before a ship finally arrives. He purges himself of all that’s unnecessary. 

There’s an almost Buddhist sense to the way Selkirk accepts that being truly human means not fighting against the world but going with it, flowing with it.

“I am my body,” he says. He no longer looks at the Earth and wishes to dominate it and and the animals upon it, as we’ve all been taught to do. Rather, Selkirk says: “I have learned to let rock be rock.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos