IT came as no surprise that our energetic Prime Minister, Tony Blair, saw the shambles in the European Commission as a glorious opportunity to reform the Brussels institutions and ensure that they became efficient, progressive, forward looking and sensitive to the needs of people.
However, these sentiments are as unrealistic as the multitude of optimism which has been expressed about the EU since the Treaty of Rome was signed.
The real tragedy is that, even if we were to dismiss permanently all the Euro commissioners, and to replace them with shiny-faced idealists, the same problem as we have today would re-emerge in a few years.
Older readers of The Herald will recall that I have argued from the day I resigned from Ted Heath's government, over the decision to join the EU, that the structures of management in Brussels were wholly inappropriate for the management of a continent.
The commission is a body with massive powers, not just to spend taxpayers' money but also to initiate the laws which affect us all.
The placing of contracts, the appointment of staff, the management of agricultural policy, the distribution of foreign aid, and the decisions of what issues can be discussed by the various councils of Ministers are in the hands of commissioners.
And unlike national governments, where the chief civil servants are highly qualified and experienced professionals with high standards strictly controlled and observed, the commissioners are simply a bunch of redundant politicians placed in positions of massive power by member states.
Some, like Sir Leon Brittan, do have professional qualifications, but others have no real qualifications at all.
But year by year, instead of seeking to control and manage the authority of the commissioners, we have simply agreed to proposals to give them ever-increasing power.
The move towards the single Euro state without democracy has been like a roller coaster - we can put on the brakes, but we cannot stop the inevitable progress down the slide.
But why can nothing be done to control the massive spending of the EU and the increasing fraud and mismanagement?
The problem in the structure of the EU is that some member states like Germany and Britain contribute a great deal, but others, like Ireland and Spain, have gained a great deal. So any savings would mean less cash for them.
It is the same with the Common Agricultural Policy, which is the greatest protection racket ever devised by man. The latest so-called reforms will simply mean that the expenditure on the CAP will rise again.
But perhaps Europe's greatest tragedy is that, instead of seeking to sort out its structural problems, the demand has always been that if only we will take a further step towards integration, the problems will disappear.
I have seen Prime Ministers stating that they are anxious to sit round the tables of Europe to solve problems, and that to secure the goodwill to achieve this, they will sign another treaty. We saw this with Lady Thatcher with the Single Act, which enshrined majority voting, but simply created more problems. John Major gave Maastricht as his contribution to progress, but progress never came.
Now we are being advised that with Mr Blair, a step into the single currency will bring the required delights.
But he must surely realise that all the previous attempts to establish single currencies - and there have been many, including two in Europe - have all ended in economic distress and mass unemployment. A single currency can work only if you have one government, one Treasury, and a feeling of nationhood. Europe has none of these.
It is time we stopped living in cloud cuckoo land. What benefits have come from the EU?
Trade? Sadly, our trade with Europe since membership has been a great disaster, with a total deficit of #155bn.
Money? Wrong again. We've paid in #100bn and got back #67bn, which means that the average family has contributed about #2400 net.
Investment? Wrong again, because the majority of investment comes from elsewhere although the finance can be misleading because US investment flowing through Holland is regarded as EU investment.
Jobs? It is no secret that massive unemployment is the real nightmare of the EU and Britain's escape from the ERM has given us the freedom to do better.
Surely the message we should take from the shambles in Brussels with the commission is that the time has come to say no to further power surrenders to the European Union.
Share