This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.
Earlier this week, Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee told Holyrood magazine that the government needed to be “tighter and leaner.”
It was an admission that the public sector is currently too slack and, er, fat.
After years of promising, is the government finally about to tackle public sector reform?
In her budget, Shona Robison announced a new £30 million “invest to save” fund, which, she said, would “improve productivity and ensure longer-term sustainability.”
The money will be used to act as a "catalyst" for efficiency.
But what does that mean? Well, one of the reasons we’ve had a lot of talk and not very much doing with public sector reform in the past is that reform often means cuts, or asking people to accept significant changes to their working lives.
No government of any stripe relishes picking a fight with public sector workers.
But the Scottish Government has a significant cash gap looming.
According to the Scottish Fiscal Commission, while the overall funding for the government 2025-26 is projected to increase by 2.1% in real terms compared to 2024-25, resource funding, the money covering day-to-day costs like social security and staff pay will only see a real terms increase of 0.8%.
After factoring in inflation and social security deductions, resource funding is actually forecast to decrease by 0.3% in 2025-26.
This is largely driven by spending on benefits, which is due to exceed the associated Block Grant Adjustments by £529 million in 2025-26.
Money has to be found somewhere.
Read more from the Unspun newsletter
- Is Starmer hurting Sarwar's chances of becoming FM?
- Disgruntled Tories could help Nigel Farage get his hands on Holyrood
- Scottish Budget: Swinney corrects missteps by Yousaf
- Violence towards women in Scottish schools must be addressed
In March 2024, there were 605,600 people employed in the public sector in Scotland, roughly just under a quarter of all workers in Scotland.
That was up by 7,500 on the previous year.
The Scottish Government estimates that including local government employees such as schoolteachers and social care workers, the public sector pay bill is equivalent to around half the resource budget.
(Image: Herald Design)
The cost has been steadily increasing for some time, driven by growth in staff numbers, inflationary pressures, and above-inflation pay settlements.
There will be redundancies — McKee said as much in a letter to Holyrood's Finance Committee in September — though they will be voluntary rather than compulsory.
Will that be enough to tackle the gap?
The other argument for reform is that the public sector needs to be up to the task.
Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox
“There are big structural changes happening in our society and the economy,” Professor Graeme Roy, the Chairman of the Scottish Fiscal Commission said at a briefing on Wednesday morning. “We've spoken about net zero. We also get demographics as well. We get questions around ill health and rising disability payments.
“So we need to actually really reform our public services, because the demand on public services is going to increase significantly over the coming years.
“So the ability to use the existing funds we've got much more effectively and much more efficiently is going to be really, really important, because without that, then it's going to become even more challenging in terms of balancing the books.”
The challenge for the Scottish Government is to balance the books while ensuring public services remain fit for purpose as the 21st Century moves into its second quarter.
The question is whether ministers are prepared to take the tough decisions needed.
Share