Can the Conservatives attract centre-right leaning Scot nationalists?

Only one in 50 of self-identifying Yessers thought it more likely than not that they would ever vote Scottish Conservative. <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
Only one in 50 of self-identifying Yessers thought it more likely than not that they would ever vote Scottish Conservative. (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

More than a decade ago, in the run-up to the independence referendum, an elderly gentleman in tartan trews painted a giant “YES” on to his land.

The pensioner, Dutch-born Peter de Vink, wanted passengers flying in to and out of Edinburgh Airport to see his huge message on the constitution.

There was something unusual about de Vink’s passionate nationalism: he had been a near lifelong member of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist party.

True, the financier by 2014 was an independent member of Midlothian council and a friend, of sorts, of former First Minister Alex Salmond. 

He was one of 200 leading Scottish business figures who signed a letter in this newspaper declaring their support for independence a month or so before the big vote.

Earlier De Vink had been deselected by the Tories for his stance on the union. The party, he said in response, “looked complete plonkers”. Its spokesperson countered by saying supporting independence was entirely at odds with its philosophy.

De Vink died in 2023 - after eventually falling out with SNP colleagues on his council - with obituaries describing him as “colourful”.

A decade on from the indyref, academics and analysts are still wondering why there were no more De Vinks. 

Where is Scotland’s pro-independence right? Other sovereignty movements, such as in Catalonia, have conservative elements. Why doesn’t this country’s?

Moreover, independence supporters have been prepared to vote for another pro-union party, Labour, as demonstrated in the UK general election of 2024.  

With a second referendum seemingly off the table for at least the medium term, are there centre-right leaning nationalist voters who might back the Tories?

The centre of gravity of Scottish politics is on the moderate left.The centre of gravity of Scottish politics is on the moderate left. (Image: Dan Kitwood - WPA Pool/Getty Images) Well, basically, no, there are not. 

Fraser McMillan, a political scientist at Edinburgh University, is one of the researchers behind the Scottish Election Study, the gold-standard survey of how and why we vote the way we do. 

Citing data from a pre-election poll, McMillan found only one in 50 of self-identifying Yessers thought it more likely than not that they would ever vote Scottish Conservative.

In a blog on the poll, McMillan wrote: “It won’t surprise observers of Scottish politics that the Conservatives are unpopular, but the scale of anti-Conservative sentiment on the Yes side is striking. 

“Fully 87% of these voters give the party a 0, indicating they are unlikely to ever vote for them. 

“And the remainder hardly consider themselves more likely to back the party – incredibly, just over 2% of pro-independence SES respondents consider themselves more likely than not to vote Conservative at some point in future.”

The Tories, of course, are in the electoral doldrums, way off the peak of popularity they enjoyed shortly after De Vink was calling them “plonkers”. 

Their anti-independence line worked for them when a second referendum looked possible. It has become less potent a stance - and they face being outflanked on the right by Nigel Farage’s anti-immigrant and staunchly pro-union Reform UK.


Read more from David Leask:


The SES survey asked respondents to grade themselves from left to right on a ten-point scale, where one was very left and 10 was very right. 

There are, scholars acknowledge, some problems with this methodology - but it does tell us how people see themselves, rather than how experts might judge their views.

Just over half of Scots - some 54% - rank themselves as between a three to a five on the left-right scale.

In other words, the centre of gravity of Scottish politics is on the moderate left. Independence supporters, moreover, strongly skewed left. 

“Those who place themselves at a six on the left-right scale and support independence – potentially those who could fairly be described as ‘Tartan Tories’ by temperament – represent less than 2% of the overall electorate,” wrote McMillan.

Social attitudes studies generally show little ideological difference between Scotland and England - or, indeed, between many northern European countries. 

“While Scottish respondents are overall slightly more left wing and liberal than their English counterparts, the gap is not all that big, and much smaller than one would expect given the centre-left consensus at Holyrood,’ wrote McMillan.

“There is clearly a gap in the market for centre-right politics in Scotland, but the continuing importance of constitutional politics and current unpopularity of the Conservative Party and right wing identity makes this difficult to navigate.”

The SES is studying the electorate - not party membership or elected politicians. 

Andy Maciver, Herald columnist and former Scottish Conservatives strategist, stressed these are very different things.

He reckons there are Tartan Tories - even if he doesn’t call them that. And some of them are SNP ministers. “I know a lot of these people, I know them personally,”  he said. “There have always been a large number of pro-independence SNP supporters, who purely saw the SNP as a vehicle for independence, and whose view was that as soon as independence was achieved, there would be a party of the centre right.”

There are SNP politicians Maciver sees as of the centre-right, such as Kate Forbes. The deputy first minister has long espoused socially conservative views - but she is also seen as more sympathetic to business interests than, say, her leadership rival Humza Yousaf.

Maciver believes that in an independent Scotland that Forbes would be in centre-right party alongside former MSP Donald Cameron, another Gaelic-speaking Highlander.  Equally, he thinks First Minister John Swinney and Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar would be in the same centre-left party. Why? Because this is where their views would get them in neighbouring countries like Norway or Denmark.

The public affairs consultant added: “The ascension of Kate Forbes into the government of Scotland was a very bad day for the Scottish Tories. 

“There will be voters, especially in rural areas, who look at that and say: ‘I'm actually pretty pleased.’"

Dutch-born politician Peter de VinkDutch-born politician Peter de Vink (Image: YouTube)

That does not mean that Maciver rejects the idea that Scottish nationalism - rather like its Welsh counterpart - has aligned to the left. 

It has, he said, especially as the SNP over its period in government after 2011 came to be seen as a counter to the UK Conservative government. 

And Scottish politics in the devolution era has focused on issues seen as traditional strong points for the left, such as spending on schools and health care rather than tax, macro-economics, defence and immigration.

“Devolution has conditioned us to move a little bit left towards because of the nature of the debates that we have and the fact that the Tories have been so weak as part of those debates. 

“Everything from land reform to free personal care for the elderly, even the smoking ban, have been sort of leftist. 

“I'm not saying all these things are good or bad, but that there has been, an absence of centre-right counterbalance.”

There are still De Vinks in the Scottish electorate, Maciver is suggesting, even if they not always seem themselves as right wing. They might not have tartan trews and their own hills to decorate with Yes slogans. But they are going to feel a little easier voting SNP under Forbes and Swinney than for Yousaf and Nicola Sturgeon. 

In other words, he thinks there is a small bloc of centre-right pro-independence Scots. But they are not going to vote Tory. "The brand is just too toxic," he said.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos