A rundown of what potential reform to the Scottish Elections Bill could mean for those holding onto more than one job in the Scottish Parliament.
Today in Holyrood, MSPs will consider amendments to an election reform bill on a change in the law around banning dual mandates for MSPs.
So what does this all mean? Here is everything you need to know ahead of the bill being discussed in parliament this afternoon.
What would changes to the bill mean?
The Scottish Government has been working with Tory MSP Graham Simpson on amendments to election legislation. These changes have also been seconded by Green MSP Ross Greer.
If passed, one change would prevent MSPs from also sitting as MPs, ending the practice known as “double jobbing”.
The Scottish Government says it will support MSPs being banned to also sit as MPs in Westminster. However, ministers have said a public consultation is needed on this.
If passed, ministers will draft regulations to disqualify MSPs from also being a member of either the Commons or the Lords. It will not prevent them from standing, but if they are elected there will be a “period of exception” to allow them to resign from their other job.
Any MSP who is currently an MP or a Peer will be allowed to keep their Holyrood seat until the next election.
Parliamentary business minister Jamie Hepburn has said he aims to introduce this change next year ahead of the Scottish election in 2026.
Another amendment could also ban councillors from simultaneously serving as MSPs, though this would only happen after a public consultation in January. However, Mr Hepburn is hopeful MSPs will back changes to the bill.
Giving his support to these changes, Green MSP Ross Greer wants to go further and ban dual mandates completely.
The MSP has said: "It is impossible to be an MSP in Edinburgh and an MP in London at the same time and to do a good job in both of those roles.
"Serving Scotland is a privilege and a challenge. It requires elected representatives who are completely dedicated to serving their constituents, not their personal career ambitions."
What’s the context?
The suggested changes come after SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn announced his intention to stand for Holyrood in the 2026 Scottish Parliament elections. He had initially planned to remain as an MP, but criticism forced him to admit he “got it wrong”.
This has certainly not been the first time an MSP has held onto more than one political position.
A number of MSPs have previously served in both Holyrood and Westminster, including both former first minister Alex Salmond and former Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross.
The current First Minister John Swinney has also held seats both at Westminster and Holyrood between 1999 and 2001.
Yet, for former SNP MP Joanna Cherry, who lost her seat in this year’s general election, the SNP changed their internal rules once to stop her from taking up a dual mandate, however, failed to extend that to any similar attempts in the future.
Various MSPs have also remained as councillors when elected to parliament.
Labour’s Katy Clark, MSP for West Scotland, is currently a peer at the House of Lords, though she has taken a leave of absence from the Upper House.
What happens now?
Today MSPs will decide whether to vote through the amendments and, with cross-party support, it is likely they will pass with a majority of support from MSPs. This is the final stage of the bill to decide whether or not it becomes an act.
Mr Simpson said amendments being proposed to the Scottish Elections (Representation and Reform) Bill today would “give Parliament the opportunity to say whether the practice of dual mandates should be ended or not”.
The Tory MSP added: “I hope that a majority of MSPs will agree with me that our job is full-time and should not be done at the same time as sitting as an MP or peer.”
With Mr Simpson adding that it is “right that time is taken to get the details right”, the Scottish Government will carry out a consultation on the changes.
Regulations would then be introduced in time for the Holyrood elections in May 2026.
Mr Simpson said: “Most people think that this is the right thing to do and I hope that Parliament votes that way next week.”
Meanwhile, Mr Hepburn said the Scottish Government “has been clear that it is supportive of ending the practice of dual mandates where MSPs are also able to be MPs or peers”.
Mr Hepburn has said that he will publish public consultation in January 2025 and introduce regulations in autumn 2025 which will be subject to scrutiny and a vote by MSPs.
Share