A bill banning politicians from having two jobs will get the approval of voters but is unlikely to see a “significant change” in their trust of politicians, a pollster and analyst has told The Herald.
Pollster Mark Diffley also said recent changes will force scottish politicians to “think more carefully” about whether they want to be in Westminster or Holyrood.
Mr Diffley’s analysis comes after the Scottish Parliament voted through amendments to an elections bill which will see MSPs banned from also sitting in the House of Commons or the House of Lords.
Members unanimously supported amendments from Conservative MSP Graham Simpson which made the change to the Scottish Elections (Representation and Reform) Bill on Tuesday.
Another amendment passed allows ministers to ban councillors from sitting as MSPs, with a decision to be taken after a consultation.
READ MORE:
- Should the practice of dual mandates be banned?
- MSPs vote to ban dual mandates after Stephen Flynn row
- Waspi women: ‘Scottish Labour must make Starmer reconsider’
It also emerged during the debate in Holyrood that the SNP has banned MPs from standing for Holyrood in 18 months’ time unless they first resign their Westminster seat.
The parliamentary business minister Jamie Hepburn has said the regulations will be in place ahead of 2026, in time for the Holyrood elections, subject to parliamentary approval.
The ban came after SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn announced plans to seek a Holyrood seat and sit in both parliaments until the next UK election. Mr Flynn has since walked back from that pledge after a backlash from across the political spectrum, including within his own party.
Responding to the new restrictions, Mr Diffley, founder of Diffley Partnership, told The Herald: “I think it will force perspective and current politicians to think more carefully about which parliament they want to be in and make it more challenging to move between Holyrood and Westminster.”
Mr Diffley also said recent polling shows voters will welcome the change.
The pollster said: “I think voters would approve of the dual mandate ending. However, I’m not sure that this measure by itself will led to a significant change in how politicians are viewed or levels of trust.
“It links to three other related issues, I think. Politician’s salaries, trust in politicians and whether politicians should have multiple jobs.”
Although recent polling on these issues relates to MPs, Mr Diffley said he would expect similar attitudes are held towards MSPs.
“On salaries, a poll in September this year found that 63% think MPs are paid too much (£91,000), 29% ‘about the right amount’ and 3% not enough, so this is pretty clear,” Mr Diffley said, “These numbers were similar across all age groups and across all supporters of all parties.”
Mr Diffley said he understands some who took the dual mandate only took one salary - something proposed by SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn - however, added it is “interesting that most voters think they’re getting paid too much anyway.”
On the issue of trust in politicians, Mr Diffley said it is “clear” that this is a “very significant issue” for politicians. The latest YouGov polling in August suggests this.
When asked "how much do you trust the following [professions] to tell the truth”, 46% of respondents said ‘not much’, 30% ‘not at all’ and only 17% responded ‘a fair amount’.
“Interestingly but commonly, trust in a ‘local MP’ is higher than for the political class as a whole – my instinct is that politicians having dual mandates fuels that lack of trust,” Mr Diffley said.
On the issue of multiple jobs, Mr Diffley said voters are again very clear in their message to politicians.
The pollster said: “Over two thirds think that MPs should be banned outright from second jobs or should only be allowed them ‘with a few limited exceptions’.
"My hunch is that another political job (e.g. being an MSP) is not one of those exceptions.”
The clampdown on dual mandates follows SNP's Westminster leader Stephen Flynn announcing in November this year he planned to stand in the Scottish Parliament elections but keep his role as MP for Aberdeen South in Westminster.
At the time, Mr Flynn said he would not accept salaries from both positions, however he later went back on his decision, saying he had "got it wrong".
Mr Flynn has now said he will decide whether or not to stand for Holyrood in the New Year, once the SNP has decided its own party rules.
The SNP, including Mr Flynn, had criticised the former Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross for being a parliamentarian in both Holyrood and Westminster. Mr Ross is also an Scottish Football Association-registered linesman.
A number of MSPs have previously served in both Holyrood and Westminster, including the former first minister Alex Salmond.
The current First Minister John Swinney has also held seats both at Westminster and Holyrood between 1999 and 2001.
Yet, for former SNP MP Joanna Cherry, who lost her seat in this year’s general election, the SNP changed their internal rules once to stop her from taking up a dual mandate, however, failed to extend that to any similar attempts in the future.
The only current MSP sitting in another parliament is Labour's Katy Clark. The MSP is currently a peer at the House of Lords, though she has taken a leave of absence from the Upper House.
Share