George Kerevan: Dissension in Alba since Salmond death

Former first minister and Alba leader Alex Salmond pictured at an Alba Party campaign event <i>(Image: Jeff Mitchell)</i>
Former first minister and Alba leader Alex Salmond pictured at an Alba Party campaign event (Image: Jeff Mitchell)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The former SNP MP George Kerevan has revealed that the Alba Party has  been hit by internal arguments in the wake of its founder Alex Salmond's death.

Mr Kerevan was SNP MP for East Lothian from 2015 to 2017 and defected to Alba in 2021 standing unsuccessfully for the party at last year's general election.

He dedicated his column in The National today to assessing the two candidates Ash Regan and Kenny MacAskill vying to succeed Mr Salmond, who died last October, as leader.

And he warned that whoever wins the contest will have to tackle differences within the party - and face an existential battle at the Holyrood election in 2026.

"Alba has also had some internal dissension in the wake of Salmond’s death that a new leader will have to deal with," he said.


READ MORE: 

Salmond's sister and niece back MacAskill for Alba leader

'Moira Salmond has a clear desire to continue court action'

Ash Regan: Alex Salmond would have wanted me as Alba leader


Mr Kerevan did not reveal details of what the dissension has been about.

The winner of the contest will be announced before the party's conference in March.

Mr MacAskill has the support of Mr Salmond's widow Moira as well as his sister and niece Gail and Christina Hendry, while Ms Regan has said Mr Salmond would have backed her to be leader.

Mr Kerevan warned that the Holyrood election next year could put the party's future at stake.

"If they can’t break through electorally come the 2026 Holyrood election, the future is questionable – especially as Reform UK, with fewer members and practically no local organisation in Scotland, has surged in the polls," he wrote.

"Last week’s local by-election in Bannockburn (of all places) saw Reform finish only a smidgeon behind Scottish Labour, though the SNP held the seat."

He added: "Whoever wins, they have a steep political hill to climb. Alba have swayed in the polls but are barely keeping themselves in sight of winning a few seats in Holyrood come 2026.

"Salmond was planning on Alba winning 15-20 seats on the regional list, to put pressure on the next SNP government.

"That prognosis was based on the then Labour surge and Alba’s ability to pick up disgruntled nationalist voters.

"But support for the incoming Starmer administration – admittedly never solid – has collapsed and the SNP now look near certain (accidents apart) of a decent majority.

"That seems to be marginalising Alba again, especially as dissident nationalist supporters might want to rally to the SNP to block the rise of the Faragistas."

In his article, the former MP pointed to Ms Regan's heavy defeat the SNP leadership race and polling suggesting she had a low public profile and weak public approval ratings.

"In the 2023 SNP leadership contest, she garnered only 11% of membership votes compared to 48% for Humza Yousaf and 41% for Kate Forbes. This suggests she still had an ill-defined profile in the party after seven years at Holyrood.

"A January 14 Survation poll asked people a specific question about Regan, inquiring if they “approved or disapproved” of her.

"Around 21% replied they had not heard of her, which is worrying for her...Some 13% of voters approved or strongly approved of Ash, 27% were neutral and 27% were negative to some degree, which gives her an overall negative approval rating of 14 points. Meanwhile, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar – with a bigger profile and more at stake – is at minus 12 points."

However, he did praise Ms Regan for her work in Holyrood.

"Most folks would agree being Alba’s sole MSP is a pretty lonely job but Ash has acquitted herself well. She proposed fresh legislation to give Holyrood the specific power to call an independence referendum – critical to maintaining pressure on Westminster and raising morale in the movement.

"And she gave critical support to the SNP Government over its Budget, demanding in return mitigation of the cuts to the Winter Fuel Payment."

He did not say who would be getting his vote in the contest but did give substantial praise to mr MacAskill.

He wrote: "MacAskill is a rare breed in politics, at least at a British level. He is a forensic, inspiring orator of the old school, while still an effective TV performer. And he is an intellectual and prolific author of books on Scottish history.

"He is a strategist who views politics in the long run, a trait he shared with Salmond. I suspect also that MacAskill long harboured ambitions to lead the SNP but the time and tides were never right. He is not to be dismissed as an accidental candidate or an interim figure."

Alba told The Herald the party did not comment on internal party matters.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos