exclusive

Plan for 'UK's biggest and most efficient' energy powerhouse

Roderick MacLeod, owner of the Balmacaan Estate <i>(Image: Glen Earrach Energy)</i>
Roderick MacLeod, owner of the Balmacaan Estate (Image: Glen Earrach Energy)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A family-owned firm is to bring forward “the UK’s largest and most efficient” hydropower project on its own estate above one of Scotland’s most famous lochs.

The Glen Earrach Energy company is weeks away from submitting its blueprint for the £3 billion plan for Loch Ness. It will include how the estate operator is broaching concerns around salmon welfare and how the long-term community benefit might look.

The venture is launched in earnest as the sector is on the edge of a renaissance in Scotland, and is not the only Pumped Storage Hydropower (PSH) project at the 22-mile-plus long loch.

There is one existing plant at Foyers, operated by SSE Renewables, and other proposed Loch Ness projects include Statkraft’s Red John, now known as Loch na Cathrach, while there was one outlined by Statera linked to Loch Kemp.

With Pumped Storage Hydropower (PSH) enjoying a resurgence in Scotland, the family behind Glen Earrach Energy and the UK’s largest hydropower project, reveal their hopes for the future.With Pumped Storage Hydropower (PSH) enjoying a resurgence in Scotland, the family behind Glen Earrach Energy and the UK’s largest hydropower project, reveal their hopes for the future. (Image: Damian Shields) According to the British Hydropower Association, the trade membership association representing the interests of the UK hydropower industry, there are currently 11 PSH schemes “in various stages of development” across the UK.

Another, Balliemeanoch at Loch Awe, by Intelligent Land Investments Group, is currently being considered by the Scottish Government.

Hydropower projects are among those set to benefit from the proposed UK Government mechanism aimed at paving the way for a range of new Long Duration Electricity Storage (LDES) projects.


READ MORE FROM BUSINESS HQ MONTHLY:


Ofgem has just closed a consultation on how the new regime aimed at stimulating investment and in the coming weeks will set out how it will operate.

Hydropower storage is expected to play a key role in the future of energy provision, standing in at times of other renewables outages or over-production.

In an interview with Business HQ Monthly, the architect of Glen Earrach describes how height and proximity will play a role in what is claimed will be the biggest and most efficient project in the UK, and how the family-business ethos is also significant.

“My father grew up in the Highlands and purchased the Balmacaan estate 30 years ago,” Roderick MacLeod, owner of the Balmacaan Estate, where the Glen Earrach Energy plant is planned, said. “Over that time, we have invested heavily in restoring and enhancing the estate’s natural beauty. The estate’s suitability for a large-scale PSH project was recognised by a leading hydro-power developer over 15 years ago. But the demand for long-duration energy storage was insufficient to justify a project of this scale at that time. We went on to build a successful run-of-the-river hydro scheme on the estate with hydro experts. A few years ago, these experts advised us to re-evaluate the site’s potential for PSH, given the growing need for this technology in achieving net zero and lowering energy costs for everyone.”

The family firm commissioned studies and consulted with international experts around the technology which works by pumping water to a head pond, here, a lochan called Loch nam Breac Dearga, and released as and when it is needed, and the location.

MacLeod said: “Our advisers quickly identified Balmacaan as one of, if not the, most promising PSH sites in Europe. That’s because of the site’s high hydraulic head, the vertical distance between the upper and lower reservoirs, and the upper reservoir’s close horizontal proximity to Loch Ness. The site’s 500-metre hydraulic head means we can generate greater water pressure, which allows the turbines to produce more energy for the same volume of water, and therefore more power and store more energy than all other projects on Loch Ness combined.

“To put that into perspective, there are three new PSH projects planned for Loch Ness with a combined energy storage capacity of 42 Gigawatt hours. Glen Earrach Energy accounts for nearly three-quarters of the planned energy storage and two thirds of generating but uses only half of the water.

“Being close (in grid terms) to wind farms, both offshore and onshore also really boosts the efficiency of the project.”

Surveying the lochan above Loch Ness.Surveying the lochan above Loch Ness. (Image: Glen Earrach Energy) He continued: “We decided to pursue the project independently to begin with so we could build in long-lasting environmental, social, and economic benefits to the Scottish Highlands. By taking this approach, we can ensure the project’s design minimises environmental impacts and maximises its contributions to the local area. As the project requires large amounts of capital, we will bring in outside investors.

“Having established Glen Earrach Energy, which translates to Valley of Spring in Gaelic, we assembled a consortium of leading advisors and experts, including international hydropower expert Martin Lacey, AECOM, Alpiq, LCP Delta, AFRY, and Frontier Economics, to guide the project’s development."

The firm submitted a scoping report to the Scottish Government’s Energy Consents Unit for a 30GWh pumped storage hydro project on the estate last April and will submit its planning application next month.

“The project is set to be the UK’s largest and most water-efficient pumped storage hydro scheme, with the capacity to power one million fully decarbonised homes,” Mr MacLeod said. “We plan to begin generating power in 2030 with up to two of our eight turbine units, delivering up to 500 megawatts of electricity – enough to power approximately 250,000 homes – for up to 30 hours. Full commissioning of the project is expected in 2032, at which point it will be capable of powering over one million homes for up to 30 hours, or two million homes for up to 15 hours”.

Water management and environmental considerations are also central to the project, in the same way the estate has been run. Mr MacLeod noted “water is a finite resource and it must be managed very carefully” and will be included in calculations.


READ MORE:


“Projects with high hydraulic heads generate more power per unit of water, resulting in lower fluctuations in the lower reservoir's water level for a given power output,” he said. “These projects also require less water to be stored in the upper reservoir to achieve the same energy storage capacity, thereby reducing their overall environmental footprint.”

He continued: “The UK’s electricity grid cannot currently support the volume of renewable energy generated at peak times. To avoid grid overload, the system operator instructs and pays operators to curtail generation. This resulted in over £1bn in costs for UK energy consumers last year and significant wasted renewable energy.

“By storing up to 30GWh of this otherwise wasted electricity, GEE will reduce the need for curtailment and in turn is estimated to save nearly £3bn in grid operating costs in the first 20 years of operation. It will also reduce our reliance on fossil fuel-based power generation, contributing to a substantial decrease in the carbon footprint of the electricity network. Once fully operational, GEE’s project is projected to reduce the national grid’s post-2030 carbon footprint by 10%.”

LOOK THROUGH THE LATEST EDITION HERE

Asked about concerns including around salmon, an issue also being considered by Holyrood, he said: “By actively listening to community concerns and ideas from the very beginning, we have been able to refine and improve the project’s design. This includes minimising visual impact through reduced above-ground infrastructure, relocating the temporary construction compounds and providing temporary on-site accommodation for the project workforce to reduce traffic to and from site.

“Overall, it is a fairly neat and simple design, which is facilitated by the site’s topography. When complete the only major visible structures will be the three dams and two access tracks. The upper reservoir’s flat and wide shape ensures the highest dam only reaches a maximum height of 55 metres and will be effectively screened by Meall Fuar-mhonaidh, a prominent hill overlooking Loch Ness.”

The Glen Earrach Energy company is weeks away from submitting its blueprint.The Glen Earrach Energy company is weeks away from submitting its blueprint. (Image: Getty Images) On salmon welfare concerns, he said: “Our team of environmental experts are conducting a comprehensive range of studies to assess potential environmental effects of the project. These studies will inform the development of avoidance and mitigation measures to minimise and manage any potential impacts. This information will be documented in our Environmental Impact Assessment Report, which we plan to submit as part of our application in March 2025.

“We have proactively addressed environmental concerns raised by stakeholders and continue to work with them on issues raised. For instance, in May 2024 we started actively engaging with the Ness District Salmon Fisheries Board, NatureScot, The Scottish Environment Protection Agency and the Highland Council. This collaboration includes commissioning a smolt tracking study by academic experts to enhance our understanding of smolt behaviour in Loch Ness, which will be used to inform the operation of the scheme. This study, initiated in December 2024, is currently underway, with the surveying phase scheduled for the 2025 smolt season (April-June). Data analysis will commence in the summer of 2025. This smolt tracking data will be used to evaluate the Environmental Impact Assessment Report, which is needed for our planning application, and will have been informed by a study consisting of a detailed literature review and existing data on salmon smolt.”

In terms of community benefit, it is claimed the project will bring £25 million into the community a year. Mr MacLeod said: “Pumped storage hydro is a proven, mature, and reliable technology, albeit costly to construct. Typical large-scale projects cost in the region of two to three billion pounds, primarily due to extensive civil engineering works like building access tunnels and underground caverns. Because of GEE’s site’s topography, which enables a simple design, and significantly higher hydraulic head we can achieve a substantially lower cost per kilowatt of energy generated and stored compared to other projects. This translates to greater economic, social, and environmental benefits for the same amount of water used. These benefits include job creation, increased local and government revenues, and larger community benefits.

“Achieving clean power by 2030 and reaching Scotland’s net zero emissions 2045 target necessitates pumped storage hydro. My family and I strongly believe that local communities must share in the benefits of renewable energy development in the Highlands.

“Individual pumped storage hydro projects are substantially larger in scale than traditional onshore renewable projects like wind farms. Our project alone will generate power equivalent to all currently operating onshore wind farms in the Highland Council area – approximately 800 turbines.

“If you apply the Highland Council’s social value charter, which looks for renewable energy developers to make a contribution of £12,500 per MW per year to the wider community, our project could deliver £3bn over its initial 120-year lifetime – that’s £25m annually to communities within the charter’s remit. This would significantly surpass the £9.1m total community benefit fund distributed by the entire Highland wind power industry last year and is on a scale we are aligned with. It is only right that local communities should benefit from such schemes.”


READ MORE: 


Broken down, he said, “the scale of these projects presents a unique opportunity for communities to shape their benefits and maximise positive local impacts”, adding: “However, they also present significant challenges and raise critical questions that demand careful consideration. For example, how do local residents envision the distribution of these substantial funds? Distributing the fund equally across the entire Highland Council area would translate to £216 per household or £105 per person annually. However, this approach may not necessarily have the most beneficial impact.

“Our aim is to be flexible and responsible in developing a tailored community benefits approach. It’s crucial this is done through robust engagement with policymakers, experts, and most importantly, local residents. This is precisely what we are undertaking.

“One of pumped storage hydro's key advantages is its long lifespan – well over a century with proper maintenance. It's only equitable that host communities reap the benefits throughout the project’s lifecycle. However, defining ‘community’– a process that must involve, not dictate, community input – and determining the most effective ways to calculate, distribute, and govern community benefit funds for projects of this scale is a vital and complex undertaking.

“We sought input from the public at our early engagement and pre-application events last year and are now working closely with experts and local stakeholders to identify challenges and opportunities and build consensus.

“Last week, we hosted two roundtables in Inverness – one with community representatives and the other with policymakers and experts – to address these issues. We will soon launch a comprehensive local community consultation to gather input on priorities and preferences for the community benefit package and will host an in-person event to ensure we hear from as many people as possible.”

Ofgem, the regulator for LDES, is overseeing implementation of a “cap and floor” system, proposed by the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. Ofgem said: “The aim of this regime is to stimulate investment in Long Duration Electricity Storage projects.

“Under the cap and floor model, when revenues fall below a set minimum (the floor), consumers top up the difference. If revenues go above a set maximum (the cap), the extra money goes back to consumers. This provides investors with revenue certainty and tackles the issues of high upfront costs and market uncertainty for LDES projects.”

Ofgem will publish a joint document with department in the first quarter of this year, adding: “Following the technical document, Ofgem will open an application window in the second quarter of 2025 to approve new Long Duration Electricity Storage projects for the cap and floor regime. We are also developing a cap and floor licensing framework.”

The Herald is partnering with The Scottish National Investment Bank to deliver its annual conference on March 3 in Glasgow - Investing with Impact: A Catalyst for Change. For more details, and to register your attendance, click here.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos