This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.
Earlier this week, the SNP tweaked their selection rules for next year’s election, ditching a decade-long measure to boost the number of women in Holyrood.
Since 2015, the party’s rule has been that when a sitting MSP steps down, their replacement must come from an all-women shortlist.
If there’s a selection contest for a constituency seat the SNP doesn’t hold, at least one candidate must be a woman.
The party also required “balanced” regional lists, with an equal number of male and female candidates.
And the approach worked. After the 2016 Scottish Parliament election, 43% of SNP MSPs were women, up from 27.5% in 2011.
A slight increase in 2021 brought this to 45%, after the party selected women for 47% of its candidate slots.
Ironically, this success is why the policy is being changed.
As first reported by ITV Border’s Kieran Andrews, the internal section of the SNP website told candidates: “Having achieved 50/50 in 2021, there is no legal basis for corrective mechanisms to be used this time.”
Read from more Unspun:
- Alex Salmond's Alba Party is spiralling into civil war
- Fergus Ewing has passed vetting but will he stand for SNP in 2026?
- Brilliant or reckless? The school leaving age divide
Section 104 of the Equality Act states that a party can make arrangements “to reduce inequality in the party’s representation in the body concerned” and which are a “proportionate means of achieving that purpose".
Having reduced inequality, the SNP fears that using an all-female shortlist this time round could see them sued by a disgruntled man.
Of the 18 SNP MSPs who have so far announced that they are standing down, 12 are women.
Under the old system, that would have meant 18 more women vying to come to Holyrood.
But now, the lads can throw their hats into the ring, and it looks like they probably will.
Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.
What about the other parties? Like the SNP, the Greens and Lib Dems have backed corrective arrangements, while Labour has previously relied on “zipping” regional lists — alternating men and women — which helped in 2021 when Pauline McNeill topped the Glasgow list instead of Anas Sarwar.
The Tories don’t go in for this sort of thing, instead encouraging more women to stand rather than using special measures.
Talat Yaqoob from Women 5050, who campaigns for an equal gender split in Holyrood, told me she was worried about the possible consequences of the rule change.
“There is no shortage of examples of when equality is rolled back because action is not maintained.
"It’s welcome that a party has achieved parity in candidates previously, but systemic inequality does not disappear overnight. This was only achieved because of positive action measures that level the playing field.”
Nominations to stand as an SNP candidate in one of Holyrood’s 73 constituencies open on Monday for the next month.
Local members then have another month to hold hustings and vote for whoever they want to stand.
The idea is that the party’s candidates will be in place a year out from the election.
The lack of corrective measures means the gender balance of those candidates will also be in the hands of members.
Will they think about that when they pick their potential politician?
Or could the successor to Nicola Sturgeon in her Glasgow Southside constituency be a man?
Share