Exclusive

Scottish prisons: 'Postcode element' to who ends up in jail

'There's a very strong relationship between school experiences and imprisonment' <i>(Image: Derek McArthur)</i>
'There's a very strong relationship between school experiences and imprisonment' (Image: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Professor Susan McVie of the University of Edinburgh speaks to education specialist James McEnaney about the connections between school experiences, patterns of offending, and the prison population.


Thanks for your time today and for taking part in The Herald’s special coverage of Scotland’s prison system. Could we start by talking a bit you and your area of research?

I'm Professor of Quantitative Criminology, which means my work involves collecting data about crime and criminal justice related issues. For nearly 30 years, I've been a co-director of the Edinburgh Study of Youth Transitions and Crime.

This is a longitudinal study that's been following the same group of about 4,300 individuals who started high school in the City of Edinburgh in 1998.

We have interviewed them at various different points in their lives, but we’ve also collected a lot of other information about these individuals from school records, social work records, children's hearing records – and we’ve collected information from criminal records for those who have received a conviction. This has allowed us to get a holistic picture of who is involved in offending but also to find out other things about them, including their educational attainment and attendance or any contact they'd had around social work or hearings, and of course also looking at how their criminal careers changed over time.

This has helped us to look at pathways into and out of offending.

Pathways into and out of offending, with a focus on education, sounds like it might be similar to what some people call the ‘school to prison pipeline’?

Yes, the school to prison pipeline is a phrase that's been coined because there's a very strong relationship between certain types of behaviours and patterns and trends in school years and then transitioning into the criminal justice system, particularly amongst those who end up in prison.

And there's a strong body of research evidence that shows that some individuals who come to the attention of their school – whether that's because of bad behaviour, inability to sit down and learn in the classroom, or other external things about their lives – are much more likely to be in the prison system at some later point.

So there’s evidence that negative school experiences are a common factor for many people who end up in prison?

Yes, but it's important to say that it isn't inevitable that someone who has poor experiences early in life, or who doesn't do well in the school system, will end up in prison – absolutely not. Most people that go to school don't end up in the prison system, but what it does mean is that the chances are much higher.

For the children that end up having a more problematic, difficult experience in school, there's a very strong association between that and having prison experience.

If you look at people who have ended up in the prison system and then look back at their school experiences, they tend to be far worse compared to people that haven't ended up in prison, even if those people have been involved in some kind of quite serious offending.

Professor McVie says that school experiences play a part in imprisonment rates, but that the full picture is a complex one.Professor McVie says that school experiences play a part in imprisonment rates, but that the full picture is a complex one. (Image: Susan McVie)

Especially bad school experiences can, then, be a factor in people ending up in prison, but that’s not the whole story?

No. The people who end up in prison tend to have a complex cluster of other issues which are connected to their poor school experience.

Many of these individuals will be coming from a very low income household. When they were growing up, they might have lived in areas of high deprivation and high crime. They may have been surrounded by other families, other children, that were involved in offending. Many of them will have associated with peers who were involved in offending, and if they've fallen out of the school system, they might end up being involved in criminal gangs.

What you tend to find is that the people who end up in the prison system are a small proportion of all the people that get involved in offending, but they are much more likely to have more complex needs and very difficult backgrounds that include offending, but also victimisation, trauma, deprivation, and disadvantage in their early years.

You’re talking now about people with complex and additional needs, and that’s a group that we talk about more and more in the context of schools. Is the suggestion here that a failure to properly resource and manage ASN provision in schools is linked to Scotland’s prison population?

It certainly wouldn't be unreasonable to propose that.

I think we as a society have become much better at recognising support needs and the types of support needs that we now recognise go much wider than the learning difficulties or educational supports that we used to look at. As a society, though, we haven't got better at dealing with a lot of those support needs. We might recognise them, but we’re not actually providing children and their families with the supports that they need to deal with them.

Having very complex needs can impact on someone for their whole life, and we know that in the childhood years some support needs are not being addressed. The education system is the obvious place to identify these children, but the schools need an awful lot of help to deal with these issues.

We also know that the factors that affect children in school go well beyond educational issues. You just look to have to look at house prices in areas where schools do well to see that there's a huge social dimension, and that's the same with the ‘school to prison pipeline.’

There’s not a strong school to prison pipeline from Edinburgh’s highest performing schools, for example, but there will be from some of those schools that sit in the more socially disadvantaged parts of the city where, again, there's more complex economic and social factors that impact on children and their ability to learn.

There's a postcode element to who ends up in prison.

There have been some really experimental projects where third sector and some statutory services were placed within schools to support the educational staff to deal with other wider issues. And it works because if you can keep kids in school and ensure they get the educational benefits, then the evidence shows that this is a protective factor around getting involved in longer term offending from which they could end up in prison.

 So to sum up: based on your research, it’s not the case that we can look at any one factor, or even any specific set of factors, and predict with any accuracy which individuals might end up in prison – but we absolutely can see a connection between those who do end up in prison and those who have acutely negative experiences both at school and in wider childhood?

I guess that's the key. If we look at people that end up in the prison system and look back the way, we can see that they're much more likely to have had a very difficult time in school in terms of their learning, their behaviour, their attendance, exclusions, all of those sorts of things.

They are also likely to have had very complex upbringings in terms of family factors, neighbourhood factors, links to peer groups and difficult social backgrounds.

You can't accurately predict what's going to happen to people, but you can identify, based on the research we have done, the children who might need help. We're good at identifying support needs, we just need to get better at providing the support to help those needs.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos