Exclusive

Bad schooling experience linked to increased chance of prison

Expert highlights link between school experiences and chances of imprisonment <i>(Image: Derek McArthur)</i>
Expert highlights link between school experiences and chances of imprisonment (Image: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

There is a “strong relationship” between imprisonment and extremely negative experiences of schooling, a leading expert has told The Herald.

In an exclusive interview as part of our special investigation into Scotland’s prisons, Professor Susan McVie told education specialist James McEnaney that there is a “strong body of evidence” showing that some of those who come to the attention of education services during childhood are “much more likely to be in in the prison system at some later point.”

Prof McVie, the Chair of Quantitative Criminology at the University of Edinburgh, is also co-director of the Edinburgh Study of Youth Transitions and Crime (ESYTC), a long-term study of the experiences of 4,300 young people who started secondary school in Edinburgh in the autumn of 1998.

Over seven phases of study, the project tracked cohort members regularly between ages 12 and 17, with later updates at ages 24 and 35.

The study found that just over a quarter (26%) of the cohort’s members had a criminal conviction by the age of 34, but that only 6% of those with convictions were sentenced to a prison sentence. Amongst this group, however, the data shows higher levels of negative educational, socio-economic, and family experiences.

In a 2024 policy briefing for the Scottish Prison Service, Prof McVie and co-author Prof Lesley McAra summarise that cohort members who went to prison had the “poorest school experience,” which is measured by “truancy and feelings of weak attachment to school and poor relationships with teachers.”

They also reported significantly more challenging behaviour and a higher level of punishments than other groups.

Those with prison experience by age 34 were also more likely to have been assessed by teachers as having behavioural difficulties by age 13, including a lack of concern for others’ feelings, being restive or overactive, and having a poor attention span that hampered their ability to complete tasks.

Prison-experienced people were also likely to have been excluded from school at some point in their secondary career. The majority (60%) of those who went to prison attended a special school at some point, while 38.3% were identified as requiring some form of additional support.

Professor McVie told The Herald that the study had been developed in order to examine “pathways into and out of offending.”

She said that although there is no way to “accurately predict” who will go to prison later in life, the data from the study suggests areas where the education system can improve and help identify children who might need help earlier in their lives.

“It's important to say that it isn't inevitable that someone who has poor experiences early in life, or who doesn't do well in the school system, will end up in prison – absolutely not. Most people that go to school don't end up in the prison system, but what it does mean is that the chances are much higher.

“For the children that end up having a more problematic, difficult experience in school, there's a there's a very strong association between that and having prison experience.”

Prof McVie also argued that that research into the so-called “school to prison pipeline,” which is particularly prevalent in the US, further illustrates the wide range of factors that correlate to imprisonment and how school experience plays a key role.

“There's a there's a strong body of research evidence that shows that some individuals who come to the attention of their school – whether that's because of behaviour, whether it’s an inability to sit down and learn in the classroom, whether that's other external things about their lives – are then much more likely to end up in the prison system at some later point.”

Still, she said, it is important to note that poor schools experiences are likely to interact with a range of other contributory factors in terms of influencing someone’s chances of ending up in prison. Individuals with prison experience are, she pointed out, affected by a “complex cluster” of other issues which may be connected to school but do not necessarily originate there.

Because of this, she said partnerships between education and other services can help to address problems in school which lead to issues later in life.

“There have been some really experimental projects where third sector and some statutory services were placed within schools to support the educational staff to deal with other wider issues.

“And it works because if you can keep kids in school and you can and you can keep them getting the educational benefits, then the evidence shows that this is a protective factor around getting involved in longer term offending from which they could end up in prison.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos