Crisis Behind Bars: Inside Scotland’s overcrowded prisons

The Herald is launching an investigative series on Scotland's Prisons: Crisis Behind Bars <i>(Image: Derek McArthur)</i>
The Herald is launching an investigative series on Scotland's Prisons: Crisis Behind Bars (Image: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Last October, John Swinney told MSPs Scotland’s prisons were “absolutely bursting at the seams."

Six months on, those seams are starting to split.

Scotland — like England and Wales — has some of the highest incarceration rates in Western Europe. 

The design capacity of the country’s prison estate — how many inmates the country’s 17 institutions were built to hold — stands at 7,905. 

On March 13, 2025, the full prison population in Scotland was 8,315. 

Projections suggest the prison population could rise to a record high of up to 8,400 by the end of June and could reach 8,500 to 8,600 by the end of September.


Read more:


The Herald’s latest series explores what that means for those inside, their families, their victims and the country as a whole. 

Currently, the Scottish Government response to rising overcrowding has been the early release of prisoners.

More than 300 prisoners were released in tranches across six weeks between February and March after emergency legislation changed the rules to allow prisoners to be released after serving 40% of their sentence, replacing the previous 50% threshold.

The change only applied to those serving sentences of less than four years. Those convicted of violent and sexual crimes were blocked.

But there is a problem. This is now the third early release scheme from the Scottish Government and prisoner numbers continue to rise.

HMP Barlinnie  (Image: Colin Mearns) And of course, there are concerns that victims are rarely informed when their perpetrator is released early.

Figures released last week suggested just 10 victims were notified under the victim notification scheme (VNS) of prisoners being given early release.

Over the course of the next week, we will examine why so many of our prisons are overcrowded despite repeated early release schemes by the Scottish Government.

We will discuss the resulting increased risk of violence, and fears of what the extreme overcapacity could lead to.

We will hear from those working in prisons and those running them about the daily challenges they face, and how overcrowding compounds every other pressure they confront.

Those demands include tackling the influx of drugs, particularly psychoactive substances, which has led to frequent medical emergencies and increased violence, putting immense pressure on staff. 

And managing diverse and sometimes dangerous prisoner populations, including members of organised crime gangs.

We will also look at the increasingly ageing prison population with complex health and social care needs, leading to a substantial rise in social care needs — something our prisons, particularly those built in the 19th century, are ill-equipped to handle.

We will talk to those who work with prisoners about why overcrowding is harming rehabilitation efforts and what that means for combatting reoffending. 

We will also speak to politicians, those currently in power and those who held it in the past, about how we solve the crisis.

Is it a case of building more cells or do we need to start having difficult conversations around sentencing and judges incarcerating people who are not a threat?

Or do we even need to start talking about an early release scheme for long-term prisoners?

And what about the role remand plays in overcrowding? More than a quarter of those inside are still awaiting trial or sentencing.

Crucially, you will hear from the victims of crime, who often feel unheard and forgotten by the criminal justice system.

People who often cannot comprehend why the person who hurt them is being let out of prison early. 

We will also hear from prisoners about the profound personal consequences of incarceration, and being separated from family and friends. 

And we will look at HMP Barlinnie, the notorious 143-year-old jail, which has repeatedly been branded as unfit for purpose, with inmates said to experience human rights breaches, including inadequate time outside of their cells.


Read more:


The infamous jail is also due for replacement - at almost 10 times the initial cost estimate.

The replacement - HMP Glasgow - will cost nearly £1 billion and has been delayed for years.

It will have a capacity of 1,344 - just 357 more prisoners than Barlinnie can hold. 

We will also discuss the role of sentencing 

The prison series is the third series of 2025, after a deep dive into Scotland's railway and joint investigation with the Glasgow Times to look at the city of Glasgow.

Join us this week in The Herald for Scotland's Prisons: Crisis Behind Bars. Subscribe here to read the series in full.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos