Church of Scotland under fire over 'frustrating' building sales

Braemar Kirk in Aberdeenshire is one of those buildings that was recently sold <i>(Image: Church of Scotland)</i>
Braemar Kirk in Aberdeenshire is one of those buildings that was recently sold (Image: Church of Scotland)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The organisation which represents community landowners across Scotland is urging the Church of Scotland to be more mindful of locals when selling buildings.

Community Land Scotland has received complaints from a number of community groups who believe the Church of Scotland national administrators have not been supportive when local groups organise to buy church buildings as community facilities.

They claim church authorities are prioritising buyers with the deepest pockets, even if community groups have met the valuation price that was set.

The Church of Scotland is selling buildings around the country due to rising maintenance costs and falling congregations, and it says its trustees have a duty to sell at a proper price and do not have much room for manoeuvre when it comes to the sales.

It has sold 25 properties on an off-market basis since Presbytery Mission Planning process concluded but it accepts that not all have gone the way community groups want.

Some of those are complaining about a lack of communication from Church of Scotland headquarters as well as unhelpful advice and a lack of clarity around the bidding process.

They feel it is leaving them at a disadvantage and Linsay Chalmers, Development Manager at Community Land Scotland, said: “For generations the local communities were usually the ones who supported their local church - their families often built the churches - and the communities paid for the maintenance of the churches often for hundreds of years. 

“If the community has offered a fair price for the church building, and if the community is to get a clear benefit from getting the building, then it would only seem fair that the church authorities would cooperate with the community.


Read More


“We have heard a significant number of cases where local communities have gone through the hoops and raised the valuation price and done the considerable form-filling etc and the church authorities have not been helpful. Given the local church is usually a big part of the community heritage, the community should get priority.”

One group who feel they have been let down is the community trust in Arisaig, who failed in a bid to buy the village church despite matching the minimum asking price of £135,000.

They had tried to get a bit of extra time to raise the funds but when they managed to do so, they were informed it was sold elsewhere.

Anne Widdop is Treasurer of Arisaig Community Trust and she said: “We tried to get a wee bit of extra time.

"We worked tirelessly for many months and completed a community consultation, had a full feasibility study, architectural drawings and a business plan. We were in the process of raising the significant asking price for the Church.

“But Church headquarters in Edinburgh were having none of it: ‘If you want to bid, then bid when it goes to the open market’ was the message from Edinburgh. We basically had a few weeks’ notice which was really challenging for us. 

“We were absolutely delighted when we were offered the money by the donor. We thought we could now bid for the church building for the community. We had drawn up plans to convert the church into 2 additional affordable lets for locals and have a multi-purpose community facility - which the community was keen to use.

 ‘But in the end our offer was turned down anyway, and we were informed the Church went for the highest bidder. 

“A local family originally built the Church over 200 years ago and it contains important commemorative plaques. Generations of people from this community have maintained the church and paid for its upkeep. We weren’t looking for special favours, and we expected to pay the valuation.

“However, it feels only fair that the community be given a proper chance when the church is up for sale. It is a massive blow to the community that the Church couldn't see past a few hundred pounds and have now denied future generations the opportunity to marry or have their funeral in a well-loved, grade B, listed building.”

Others that have left locals frustrated include Braemar Kirk in Aberdeenshire, which was bought by a couple and will be turned into a luxury boutique hotel while residents of Eigg were successful in their bid to buy a church building as a community group but felt the process was unnecessarily difficult.  


Read More


Linsay Chalmers continued: “We totally understand that The Church of Scotland is strapped for cash and it hopes to maximise its income from sale of buildings.

“But these buildings are significant community assets, maintained for many generations by these communities.

“The other prime consideration should be what will benefit the community most. Inevitably the community group will develop it for the good of the community. The highest bidder might not be so interested in the community benefit.

"People expect that the Church of Scotland will be easy to work with, especially when the community has raised the funds to build and look after their church. However, this is rarely the case and we have started telling communities to treat the Church of Scotland like any other private seller such as a hedge fund or developer.

“We are concerned that the Church of Scotland is looking at short-term financial returns and not considering the damage it may do to its own legacy or the impact upon the culture and heritage of the many communities around Scotland who have a close relationship to their kirks and other Church buildings.”

A Church of Scotland spokesperson said: “The Church of Scotland has a strong track record of engaging with community groups over the sale of its buildings.

“Presbytery Mission Plans, which detail proposals for when church buildings will be released for sale in local areas, have been in the public domain for several years now.

“Our experience is that local communities are well aware of the Mission Plans. Since the plans were approved and the programme of disposals started, we’ve had a total of 103 enquiries relating to community transfers of different Church of Scotland buildings. The General Trustees (GT’s), the property-holding arm of the Church, has engaged with the groups in each one of these cases.

“The GT’s are also in regular contact with groups such as Development Trust Association Scotland and the Scottish Land Commission in relation to proposed transfers to communities.

“The responsibility for the buildings sits with the Kirk Session. Whilst the community may benefit from the use of a church or hall building, it is the congregation, not the community as a whole, who have to bear the costs of insuring, maintaining and servicing the building and ultimately, if the building is sold, then it is the congregation who will benefit from the proceeds of sale. This money is then available for the local congregation to invest in other local buildings retained by the Church, from which, the wider community may benefit. 

“The General Trustees have instructed the sale of 25 properties to community groups on an off-market basis since the Presbytery Mission Planning process concluded and are currently managing a total of 51 live interests from community groups. Whilst not all disposals go the way some local groups may want, these numbers show that the General Trustees do have a record of engaging with and selling to local community groups.

“Regarding the acceptance of offers, where properties are marketed, it should be noted that in law, the General Trustees are trustees and have trusteeship responsibilities. It is one of the duties of a trustee not to transfer or dispose of trust property except for a proper price and accordingly, while the Trustees will consider proposed future uses for the building during the acceptance process, their trusteeship responsibilities may give them very little room for manoeuvre in deciding on the offers before them.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos