Campaigners are calling on the government to move older inmates into ‘less secure units’ as the number of over 70s behind bars trebles.
Prison Reform group Howard League Scotland said it is “high time” to move older people into "more suitable environments" as they said the ability to provide social care is becoming “extremely difficult” in the ageing prison estate.
The call comes as the older prisoner population is increasing every year - with the number of people aged over 50 in Scottish prisons nearly doubling and the number of over 70s trebling in the last ten years.
Last year, there were around 507 prisoners aged over 60 - an increase of 56 in comparison to the year before and a rise of 284 in the last decade.
Read more:
- Read all articles in our Scotland's Prisons: Crisis Behind Bars series
- Social care costs in Scotland's prisons nearly £2.3 million
- Record prison overcrowding despite emergency release scheme
- 'We must do better to avoid failing victims of crime'
- Riot fears amid record prisoner numbers and overcrowding
Emma Jardine, Policy and Public Affairs Adviser for the group said: "Many of these prisoners will require intensive social care which is extremely difficult to provide in some of the oldest parts of the estate.
“Whilst current efforts are correctly focusing on reducing the unsustainably high prison population, it's also high time we looked at whether elderly and infirm prisoners could be accommodated in a less secure and more suitable environment."
As the elderly population in jails increases so too does the cost of social care, with The Herald revealing nearly £2.3 million was spent on such care last year alone, representing a £1.6 million increase in the past six years.
The Scottish Prison Service (SPS) has said they have been managing an "extremely high and complex population for more than a year" which is "putting pressure" on staff and prisoners.
The SPS added this is partly due to "the growing demand for health and social care services across our estate, partly due to our ageing population."
There are currently no plans from the Scottish Government to introduce temporary accommodation to the estate in Scotland.
However, in June last year, the justice secretary Angela Constance said “there is an exploration of modular accommodation and there is an exploration of care arrangements” as she added: “I would like to see more compassionate release, where that is appropriate”.
Alison Bavidge, National Director for Scottish Association of Social Work, told The Herald Scotland needs to consider if it is meeting the rights of prisoners under the current system as she spoke in favour of "fundamental reform" to the service.
The social care expert said: “There is an important question around human rights and that’s: are people’s rights being undermined because there’s not the right kind of facilities to support them and keep them and everybody else safe?”
There have been previous suggestions of establishing a care home in Scotland specifically for its ageing prison population.
However, the social care expert said: “There’s issues with that because of the numbers you would need in order to ensure people maintained connectivity with families."
Instead, the National Director believes all prisons could create more separate wings which would accommodate complex needs.
"It might mean that we need a few small wings in different areas of the country that can accommodate people,” the social care expert said.
Speaking in August, former Chief Inspector of Prisons for Scotland, Ms Sinclair-Gieben said Scotland “reached a crisis point” last year with a prison population “far in excess of the ability for the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) to provide a humane, rehabilitative experience.”
In 2020, she told The Scottish Parliament that we either need to put fewer people in prison, or "we recognise that we have to pay for the prison population that we do have.”
Earlier this week, The Herald reported the taxpayer cost of Scotland's jails has soared to over £77,000 per prisoner as the country faces delays in building new prison facilities.
Ministers have said they are considering how to improve care-related assessments and provisions in prisons.
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “We are well aware that the proportion of prisoners aged 55 years or older has more than doubled over the past 10 years, so are considering, alongside the Scottish Prison Service, how social care assessment and provision in prison can be improved to ensure that age related needs are identified and appropriate support is provided to this cohort.
“We continue to progress a range of actions to support a sustainable reduction in the prison population, such as changing the release point for short term prisoners, increasing the use of electronically monitored bail and providing £159 million in community justice funding in 2025/2026 to further strengthen alternatives to custody.”
Share