Updated

Swinney criticised for £20,000 government minister pay rise

First Minister John Swinney <i>(Image: Andrew Milligan/ PA Wire)</i>
First Minister John Swinney (Image: Andrew Milligan/ PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The pay for ministerial positions has risen for the first time since it was frozen by Alex Salmond 16 years ago, creating a wave of criticism from opposition parties. 

The increase came into effect on April 1 which sees junior SNP ministers now earning £100,575 and cabinet secretaries taking home £116,125 per year.

The salary boost means all ministers will receive an additional £19,126 from this month. 

According to the Scottish Mail on Sunday who first reported the rise, the decision to increase minister’s pay was taken after those at an SNP group meeting raised the idea. 

The Herald understands the First Minister took the decision to remove the freeze to ministers' salaries shortly before answering a question on this in the Scottish Parliament on April 3. 

Ministerial and MSP salaries are set and paid by the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government has no role in this.  Salaries are agreed by the whole Parliament in line with proposals put forward by the Scottish Parliament Corporate Body.


READ MORE: 

SNP urge Labour government to officially recognise Palestine

Patrick Harvie won't rule out backing Green leadership candidate

Trump’s tariff war is a transformational moment for old world order


The Scottish Mail on Sunday reported today that Mr Swinney decided not to take a pay increase of £155,000 after he was made aware of the media’s interests in the rise. 

The news comes after this month saw some Scots face council tax rises of 15.6%. 

Scottish Labour’s deputy leader Jackie Baillie said the pay increase shows “SNP government rewards Ministers for their failure” while “people are struggling”. 

The MSP said “While Scots are struggling, the SNP Ministers are being rewarded for their failure. 

“As the bill for Ministerial salaries rises, Scots will be more frustrated than ever to see services continue to decline on the SNP’s watch.

“This tired and out of touch SNP government simply is not delivering for the people of Scotland – we need a new direction and Scottish Labour is ready to deliver it.”

The Scottish Conservatives have said their will be speculation the pay rise may be as a result of SNP MSPs who expect to lose their seats at the Holyrood election next year trying to 'boost their pensions and payoffs' before they leave. 

Scottish Conservative shadow cabinet secretary for finance and local government Craig Hoy said: “The huge salary increase John Swinney has given SNP ministers can’t be related to their performance in office, which has been uniformly dismal.

“Nationalist politicians have made a mess of everything they touch – our NHS, education, housing, policing and transport – while stifling the economy, pushing through savage cuts and making Scotland the highest-taxed part of the UK.

“That’s why so many Nats expect to be turfed out if they stand in at the next election, and many have already thrown in the towel. There’s bound to be speculation that this eye-watering rise is a way of boosting their pensions and payoffs, and getting as much as they can from the hard-pressed taxpayer on their way to the exit.”

The Scottish Liberal Democrats questioned the timing of Mr Swinney's decision. 

Their leader, Alex Cole- Hamilton MSP, said: “SNP ministers may regret the timing of this pay overhaul, given the extra costs that households and businesses are counting this month.

“For so many Scots the cost of living crisis has never gone away.

“Scotland deserves better than SNP ministers who have been in power too long and have a derisory record of looking after your money, wasting millions on projects from the ferries fiasco to the botched deposit return scheme.”

Ministers receive government and MSP salaries and it is the MSP element which is increasing. 

In response to a written question from by SNP MSP Rona Mackay, Mr Swinney wrote: "The freeze of the ministerial element of pay...will remain in place..."

However, he added: "From April 1, 2025, the MSP element of ministers’ salaries will be equalised with that of MSPs who are not currently serving ministers, providing parity in line with their roles.”

Since 2008-09, the pay freeze has made more than £2.2 million available for public spending.

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “Ministerial and MSP salaries are set and paid by the Scottish Parliament. The MSP element of pay for ministers for 2025-26 will be identical to that of other MSPs.

“The Ministerial element of pay has been frozen for 16 years at 2008-09 levels and this will remain in place for 2025-26.

"The First Minister has made clear that he will forego the equalisation of the MSP element of his salary in order to avoid any perception that he benefits from his own decisions." 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos