Council to begin consultations for mothballing seven nurseries

Scottish Borders Council will begin a consultation on mothballing nurseries, but any final decisions will be left to elected members. <i>(Image: Pembrokeshire County Council)</i>
Scottish Borders Council will begin a consultation on mothballing nurseries, but any final decisions will be left to elected members. (Image: Pembrokeshire County Council)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A local authority is set to begin consultation on mothballing nurseries.

The process will have an extended consultation period and a promise that the full council will make any final decisions, following backlash from parents and councillors who claimed that officers were making decisions without wider input.

Following a debate lasting more than an hour and a prolonged recess for committee members to speak with their wider groups, the Scottish Borders Council Executive Committee voted 9-7 in favour of a motion to delay any final decisions on mothballing nurseries, establish a working group to review the council's mothballing policy and carry out a four-week consultation with affected parents at seven nurseries.

The initial officers recommended that the Director of Education should have delegated authority to decide on mothballing, following a consultation period with parents.

The council had initially scheduled a three-week consultation, which a spokesperson said was "enough time" and that the council had "allocated dedicated resources to ensure the timeframe is sufficient."

Tuesday's vote extended the consultation period to four weeks.

The motion proposed by Conservative councillor and education committee chair Julie Pirone confirmed that no nurseries will be "mothballed at this time" and that a "meaningful policy consultation" will take place with the hope that it will be presented at the October full council meeting or earlier.

Ms Pirone conceded that the council could have communicated better in the earlier stages of this process and promised that "officers always learn and will do better."

She asked parents to allow the council time to conduct the consultation and to participate in it.

"It is clear we need to look at a much more rounded view here. I want that to happen in consultation and in very firm and clear impact assessments.

"I would ask you to allow us to do that."

During the debate prior to the vote, officers clarified that there is "no specific guidance" that says mothballing can only happen at the start of an academic year. This leaves the possibility open that the council could approve mothballing some nurseries in the middle of a term, depending on the outcome of the consultation and any following full council decision.

Councillors who spoke in favour of the various proposed amendments and officers who presented the initial report and recommendations all acknowledged mistakes during the process that led to "confusion" for parents and communities. 

Of the seven nurseries recommended for mothballing – Channelkirk, Cockburnspath, Ednam, Fountainhall, Walkerburn, Westruther and Yetholm – six only learned that they were in consideration last Tuesday.

Many councillors spoke on Tuesday morning to say they were in the same situation and had to explain to constituents as recently as this week that they did not have information to answer parents' questions.

Councillor David Parker proposed an amendment which would have put a full pause on any nurseries being mothballed in 2025/2026, and to establish a working group that included parents in addition to councillors and officers.

Mr Parker said that he felt there were significant gaps in the reports provided by officers about the potential educational and social impacts of mothballing at the nurseries in question.

"I've become dismayed with this process, because during February and March and April, my interactions with (the education) team have simply gone unanswered.

"Emails I've sent have not been responded to. Information I have requested has not been provided.

He said that the council had "dropped the ball" and that there should be a complete pause on the process to "give the council time to properly consult and develop a policy around mothballing in the early years" and to involve parents in the process. 

Of the motion that eventually passed, Mr Parker said that councillors were not taking parents' concerns seriously by not including them in the official working group.

"Parents should be a fundamental part of that group. If, after all this debate and discussion today, you do not understand that, that is why these parents and communities are rejecting what you are saying."

Multiple councillors recognised this issue as one of the most contentious in recent memory, and suggested that Tuesday's meeting was one of the largest turnouts in the history of SBC.

Speaking to The Herald after the vote, parents said that they were disappointed with the decision which they feel is only a continuation of the council's initial plans. 

Paul Fulton, a parent at Channelkirk Nursery, said "common sense has not prevailed."

"We have no faith in their consultation and there is real anger amongst everyone here.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos