Nurseries safe for now as parents and councillors are left frustrated

Some members said Tuesday's executive committee meeting of the Scottish Borders Council attracted more attention than any other meeting in the council's history, drawing parents and children out in support of their local nurseries. <i>(Image: Supplied)</i>
Some members said Tuesday's executive committee meeting of the Scottish Borders Council attracted more attention than any other meeting in the council's history, drawing parents and children out in support of their local nurseries. (Image: Supplied)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Following an emotional debate that lasted almost three hours, parents have been left frustrated with their councillors' decision not to fully pause nursery mothballing proposals for the upcoming year.

During Tuesday's meeting of the Scottish Borders Council (SBC) Executive Committee, members debated proposals to mothball seven council nurseries. In the lead up to the meeting, parents and councillors had spoken out against the council's plans, citing concerns that communities had been left in the dark and that the council was not following the correct procedures.

The majority of the meeting was spent debating two competing proposals.

One from Councillor David Parker, Independent, would have kept all of the affected nurseries open in the coming year and put all discussions of mothballing on pause until parents, officers and councillors had more time to workshop a policy.

The other motion, which carried by a narrow win in a 9-7 roll-call vote, was proposed by Councillor Julie Pirone. Her motion ensured that the nurseries would remain open for now, scheduled a four-week consultation to engage with parents at affected nurseries, promised that any final decision on mothballing would be made at a full council meeting and set up a working group to discuss mothballing policies for early years settings.

Prior to Tuesday's meeting, parents had accused the council of attempting to use administrative loopholes to begin the process of closing their nurseries without any official consultation.

Many did not learn that their nursery was being considered for mothballing until it appeared on the council's papers last Monday, despite a discussion at the executive committee stating that officers had been engaging with schools for months. 

A group of parent councils at the affected nurseries, as well as the local MP and MSPs, submitted a joint statement ahead of Tuesday's meeting, calling on the committee to support Mr Parker's call to pause the process.

Paul Fulton, a parent at Channelkirk Nursery that could be affected, said that Tuesday's decision left him and other campaigners "with more questions than answers."

"We feel councillors had the chance today to bring some much-needed clarity to families and teachers affected.

"Councillor Parker's proposal would have given time to pause this chaotic mothballing process and come back next year with a well thought out policy and report parameters that put parents and communities at the forefront of the process from the outset, rather than an obstacle to overcome after the Education Department have made their recommendations behind closed doors.

"This is just the start, and we will continue doing all we can to ensure the long-term future of our nursery, as will all the other communities affected who feel equally let down and forgotten in this fiasco."

Alice Blackwell of the Cockburnspath Parent Council, another of the seven nurseries which will be consulted about mothballing, said that the decision "absolutely does not" put any of her previous concerns about the council's process to rest.

"This was done in haste, with the wording on timing very vague. It is extremely disappointing that the working group does not include parents.

She also expressed concerns that earlier admissions from councillors and officers that the process could have been handled better and that mistakes were made in communications were undermined by a comment from committee chair Euan Jardine, who referred to "conspiracy theories" when discussing the strength of response to the council's initial proposals.

"Such comments are extremely unhelpful and undermine the belief that repairing relations and restoring trust is important to SBC."

In establishing a working group without parents as members, Mr Parker said that councillors were missing the point of parents' complaints.


Read more


Defending his motion, Mr Parker said that he shared many of the concerns parents raised about how the council's officers had carried out the review of nurseries up until now.

"My problem with this process, having seen it and been involved in it, is that I don't think it's been robust. I do think there are deficiencies. I don't think it's been education's finest hour.

"For months, officers have been working on this, not in an open and transparent way with nurseries.

"The nurseries learned about this last Tuesday. One knew, but six did not.

"How do you think they will feel about a consultation this council does in the next four weeks? Do you honestly think they will be inclined to believe us, or will they be confident about our processes?"

Council officers had prepared a report on each of the nurseries in question, explaining why it was proposing whether each should operate in 2025/2026 or not.

Mr Parker said he had asked for extra information on the reports' findings but never received answers, particularly about the educational situation at each setting.

"The paper doesn't give us all of the educational aspects that it should consider. For instance, it's very quiet on transition.

"It doesn't acknowledge that, actually, these nurseries are attached to schools. And it says in the assessment that at the nurseries attached to schools, when you take children to bigger nurseries, it's better.

"I'm not convinced that's true. These nurseries work in partnership with the rural schools that they're in."

Councillor Euan Robinson, Scottish Liberal Democrat, agreed that the reports provided "precious little" about the educational issues in play and said he was concerned that children with autism and other additional support needs were not given full consideration. 

"My problem is we appear, whether we intended to or not, to put the cart before the horse: conclusions before consultation. And that's a problem.

"That's why there are so many people here today, because we haven't had the discussions that we should have had."

Councillor Tom Weatherston, Conservative, said that he felt "rushed" by the way officers had handled the process and felt he needed to vote against his own group for the first time in almost 20 years. 

"I only found out about this last Tuesday and we're here today to try and make this decision, which I think is wrong. I'm not convinced we've explored every option."

He referenced a constituency meeting he had last night with parents in Yetholm, where one of the affected nurseries is located, and said he was "embarrassed" at how many questions parents asked that he could not answer.

Similarly, fellow conservative Councillor Leagh Douglas said she was also voting against the majority of her group because she had been moved by the dozens of messages she received from parents.

"Your messages really have resonated cumulatively. They have shaped how I have chosen to approach this paper."

As a councillor, she said she was responsible for thinking strategically where possible. Still, she has a different perspective as a mother of children who attended a rural nursery beside their village school.

"I see rural provision as much more than a standalone service. It very often plays an integral role in holding rural life together. 

"We have a duty to be strategic, but strategy that forgets people is not a strategy worth having."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos