There are fears that a rollback in measures such as women quotas for the selection processes ahead of Holyrood 2026 may leave the parliament with fewer female MSPs, according to party members and a feminist policy group.
We are just over a year away from the Scottish Parliament elections and the issue of gender representation should be weighing heavily on the minds of each political party as the selection processes for MSP candidates is underway.
Yet measures for encouraging women to stand are being reduced, sparking concerns from inside Scotland's political parties.
For next year, the SNP has removed a previously implemented policy of replacing a quitting MSP with a woman because it achieved just over a 50/50 representation of women within its ranks at the last Holyrood election.
The Herald also understands there are concerns across the political parties over a lack of all women-shortlists - although some are still being implemented by Labour and the Lib Dems.
In 2021, measures such as all-women shortlists for constituency selection contests and zipped lists, where female and male candidates are alternated on a party's regional lists, were put in place to to improve representation of women.
At the elections in 2021, a record number of female MSPs were elected with the SNP’s Kaukab Stewart and Conservative Pam Gosal becoming the first women of colour to be elected.
There are currently 58 female MSPS and 70 males MSPs, representing a gender balance of 45% women and 55% men.
However, the feminist policy group Engender has warned that parties must not be complacent when it comes to ensuring a gender balance at the elections next year as they say, without “sustained effort", we are likely to see a “rollback of gender equality”.
READ MORE:
Women in Scottish politics speak out on sexual harassment
Slater: Politics 'less respectful' with loss of female leaders
Scottish Government urged to do more to address women’s health
Inequality concerns over pregnant women's health in Scotland
Jessie Duncan from Engender told The Herald: “The record results for diverse representation seen at Holyrood in 2021 didn’t happen by accident.
"They were the result of several major parties adopting equality measures during candidate selection, including gender quotas and All-Women Shortlists.
"While these results were rightly widely celebrated, women – particularly minoritised women – remain underrepresented, so there can be no room for complacency.
“We’re really concerned by recent reports that some of these measures may be dialled back ahead of 2026. Parties have a range of different tools they can use, and they should be exhausting all their options to safeguard the progress we have made."
Ms Duncan added: “Without sustained efforts from parties to tackle the barriers that women face while trying to access candidacy, we are almost certain to see a rollback for gender equality at the next election.
“Diverse representation leads to better decision making, and when women’s voices aren’t equally heard, we all lose out. Parties must make every effort to ensure women are equally represented at ballot boxes come next May.”
Women working behind the scenes in Scotland’s political parties have told The Herald there’s still “much work to do” when it comes to improving gender representation.
Under recently updated EHRC guidance, parties are only able to use all-women shortlists when their group is under-represented.
However, there are alternative measures they could use for driving up female numbers such as zipping lists as well as shortlisting candidates before entering a selection process.
The largest party in Holyrood, the SNP currently have 32 female MSPs and 29 male MSPs, which they say prevents them for using gender quotas.
Yet now, we are expecting an exodus of 13 female SNP MSPs (and 10 male MSPs) from their ranks with prominent senior figures leaving such as former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, finance secretary Shona Robison, transport secretary Fiona Hyslop and MSP Christine Grahame.
Member of the party's National Executive Committee and SNP councillor, Christina Cannon, is involved in encouraging more women to put themselves forward as MSP candidates
Ms Cannon worries that without mechanisms like gender quotas there will be less female MSPs in Holyrood.
"We've got more women than men in the Scottish Parliament which is fantastic but what it means legally is that we can't introduce any gender quotes or sex-based quotas, as the legislation puts it," Ms Cannon told The Herald.
Asked if her party risks not having as many female MSPs at the next parliamentary elections, Ms Cannon said: "That's always a possibility. Our hands are tied in what we can do legally but that is a concern and we don't want to rollback on the progress we've already made."
The Scottish Lib Dems are now faced with the threat of returning an all-male Holyrood team after their only female MSP Beatrice Wishart announced she was stepping down next year.
Caron Lindsay, a co-chair of Scottish Lib Dem Women who has been involved in trying to increase diversity and gender representation in the party since the 80s, has told The Herald that although her party still has work to do, new measures are being put in place to encourage more women and she is "optimistic" about the future.
At their Autumn conference, the Lib Dems backed a motion which will see the top seats on their four “most winnable” lists (Highland, North East, Lothian, Fife) reserved for women.
“We are very keen to increase the representation of women,” Ms Lindsay said, “We know we have to do better as a party and we have been increasing over the years.”
“We are hoping we are going to grow significantly [at Holyrood]” said Ms Lindsay, “That’s an opportunity we haven’t had since 2007…We could double or triple our number of MSPs so that gives us an opportunity to get a significant number of women selected.
Ms Lindsay said the moment the Lib Dems ended up with an all male Westminster party in 2015 which was quickly followed by the all-male parliamentary group in 2016 at Holyrood, “really concentrated the mind” and the party began implementing all-women shortlists.
In 2017, their Scottish MP Christine Jardine was elected in one of these all-women seats and although Wendy Chamberlain did not win through this process then, Ms Lindsay said this opportunity gave her “the profile in the seat” to win the seat in 2019.
“These measures [all-women shortlists] are important. The party has a kind of mixed feelings about them but whenever we have adopted them they have worked,” Ms Lindsay said, “I dont think it’s going to do the job completely at this election. We are going to have to keep on going."
Scottish Greens' Shona McIntosh is a co-convener of their election campaigns committee and an East Lothian councillor. Ms McIntosh said driving up female political participation "big concern" for her which seems to stem from a lack of women putting themselves forward.
The Scottish Greens currently have four female MSPs (four male MSPs) and their party requires there to be at least one woman in a leadership position. However, women quotas are currently under review.
Their women's network host something called "Grow" which is an online platform aiming to encourage more women into the party.
"When we are not achieving that target [50:50 gender representation in the party], it's mainly a pipeline problem. So we really need to just try and encourage more women who come forward," Ms McIntosh said.
"I don't have an idea of how it's going to go for Holyrood. We are doing well so far so I hope that continues," she added, saying their main concern was local council representation, "We are going to try and use the Holyrood contest to encourage women to consider local authority to see it as part of their political journey."
Those across Scotland's political parties also stress the impact online abuse has had on putting women off running as representatives.
SNP councillor Ms Cannon said: "It's also unfortunate with where we are at the moment. Politics can be quite a toxic place, particularly for women and especially with the rise of Reform. It's putting a lot of women off from standing."
As the editor of the Liberal Democrat voice, Ms Lindsay told The Herald she knows only too well about the abuse a "woman who dares express opinion" can get online.
Discussing the issue of retaining female MSPs, Ms Lindsay said: “We do need to keep an eye on that and people’s circumstances change…but we need to make sure nothing sort of structural is holding them back.
"Women are subjected to much higher abuse than men and women of colour are subjected to an even higher level of abuse. It can really get you down.”
Despite their party not yet electing a female leader, Scottish Labour's Jackie Baillie said her party has a "proud record" of supporting female candidates and promoting gender balance in Parliament. However, she added: "There is absolutely no room for complacency".
The party currently has 10 female MSPs with 12 male MSPs and they operate selection processes which allow women to pick a female candidate to run against a man.
The deputy leader of Scottish Labour said: “All parties must work proactively to support women into politics – whether it’s through formal equality measures, efforts to encourage potential female candidates, or broader changes to remove the barriers that prevent women standing.
“Scottish Labour will continue to work to not only select female candidates, but elect female Scottish Labour MSPs.”
Scottish Conservative's Rachael Hamilton she is proud of her party's progress when it comes to gender representation but it still has a long way to go.
Only 30% of the Scottish Tory MSPs are women. Out of their 30 representatives, they have 9 female MSPs and 21 male MSPs.
The party does not use quotas but instead focuses on mentoring and outreach programmes for women.
The deputy leader said: “I am proud of the progress we’ve made to increase the number of women standing for the Scottish Conservatives, including by fielding a record proportion of female candidates at the last General Election - but I recognise that we still have further to go.
“We will keep building on that through initiatives like Women2Win Scotland and the Conservative Women’s Organisation, which have already helped many brilliant women start their career in politics."
Alba's sole MSP Ash Regan previously told The Herald her party was considering all-women quotas as she said she was "determined" to encourage more women into politics.
Share