Exclusive

Edinburgh University pulls 'don't be snobs' guidance

There have been increasing complaints about class and background-based discrimination at the University of Edinburgh <i>(Image: Damian Shields)</i>
There have been increasing complaints about class and background-based discrimination at the University of Edinburgh (Image: Damian Shields)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The University of Edinburgh has withdrawn guidance urging students from privileged backgrounds to not be “snobs” which has been criticised for undermining efforts to tackle discrimination on campus.

Grace Mai Clark, president of the 93% Club, a society representing state-educated and working-class students, said the message “oversimplified the issue”.

Last year official guidance was issued to students attending the institution, where 70% of those enrolled come from England and 35% went to private school, following reports of Scots being mocked over their backgrounds.

It said: “Don’t be a snob...When you meet new people, be curious about their interests and aspirations rather than their backgrounds.”

It continued: “Don’t assume that everyone’s life or family is like yours…Try to undo some of the unhelpful mythology about the relationship of wealth to intelligence or hard work.”

However, it has now been removed from the university's website, The Herald can reveal. 

Aimed at easing tensions fuelled by mounting claims of class-based discrimination and controversy surrounding The Edinburgh Tab, an independent student news website accused of being hostile towards Scottish students on their TikTok account, Clark said it was counterproductive.  


READ MORE:


She told The Herald: “I think most people would agree it was not the way to go about it.

“In terms of the ‘don’t be a snob’ thing it’s just written every headline for itself. It’s been a thing people have grabbed on to and it can undermine what people like us and other equality, diversity, and inclusion [EDI] colleagues have been working really hard on for years.

“I think that gets a bit undermined when ‘the university’ as an institution puts out something like that. It’s speaking on behalf of everyone who works there when, in reality, most people think it was clunky at best.

“It’s oversimplifying the issue and people don’t feel it’s an accurate representation of the hard work we’re trying to do.”

Instead, she said the university should have "reached over the aisle" and spoke to working-class students "rather than telling the students who have come from a privileged backgrounds ‘just don’t be a snob’.

“It really should have been to the working-class students to say, ‘we are really sorry you’ve had this experience, and we want to change things and make things different’.”

The university said the wording was removed "to ensure our guidance is up-to-date and in line with specialist advice". 

Clark is near the end of her tenure as president of Edinburgh’s 93% Club, which takes its name from the percentage of people in the UK educated in state schools and, in her words, works to “debunk the myth that places at universities like Edinburgh are reserved for a certain group of people in society, and make people more aware of the experiences of particularly those from working-class backgrounds”.

The fourth-year philosophy and politics student, who grew up in rural North Yorkshire with “not a lot of money”, said: “I got told at school ‘people like you don’t go to places like this’.

“When I came to Edinburgh it was a bit of a shock, I spent my first year feeling like I didn’t fit in, meeting people who were privately educated who had money beyond what I could ever imagine. I didn’t meet anybody else who sounded like me, who had the same accent as me, until I went to a 93% club meeting.

“The end goal is to remove those barriers to accessing higher education. The university likes to promote the admission statistics for working-class students, but how do those students get on? And do they actually graduate?

Grace Mai Clark, outgoing president of Edinburgh's 93% ClubGrace Mai Clark, outgoing president of Edinburgh's 93% Club (Image: Grace Mia Clark) “We have found the last few years the dropout rate for state-educated, working-class students has been massive; people can’t afford to stay the course.”

The issue of anti-Scottish discrimination and classism is not new to the 441-year-old university. But it has been put under the spotlight in recent months as students have highlighted examples and called for meaningful action to be taken to ensure everyone is made to feel welcome.

It became a hot topic on social media last year after The Tab came under fire for saying the lack of Scottish students in one of its TikTok videos was “as God intended” in the comments section on one of their posts. 

Clark said this was a "very prominent incident that has brought it to the forefront," but added "this isn’t the first time this has been felt in any way.

"This is a long-standing issue and people have been banging on about this for years, it’s just this grabbed attention.”

The Tab’s comment sparked outrage on campus and beyond. It also led to the formation of a new student-formed anti-discrimination watchdog, The Scottish Social Mobility Society, which subsequently received over 200 reports of Scots being mocked over their backgrounds and accent by both students and lecturers.

The 93% Club has also had numerous reports of this — a problem the society is tackling through "accent bias" training sessions for university staff. 

“Accent bias sets in when accent becomes a proxy for other kinds of discrimination and people are making associations about a person from their accent that actually have nothing to do with them," Clark continued. 

“We’ve had people share experiences with us say when they open their mouth in class, and have a thick scouse accent or Geordie accent, it’s the assumption that I’m less intelligent, that my point is less valid.

“We’re talking about it a lot in the sense of its relationship to class; your accent is formed by the communities you surround yourself with. So if you grew up in an area that had issues with poverty  or deprivation you’re going to sound like that, but those places get reputations and then we make associations.

“We’ve had people say the first things lecturers comment on is their accent when they’ve made a contribution to class. Instead of it being a response of ‘that was a really interesting point’, it’s ‘we don’t get many people from your area’ or people being constantly asked to repeat themselves.

“We had a Scottish student who had her accent mocked back to her by a member of staff in class, and comments about working-class people going unchecked by staff in that sense. It’s been allowed to happen."

Clark said the club sees accent bias as "the last acceptable form of discrimination". 

She said: "You would never be able to get away with saying that in the context of race and gender.

“It's been just over a year since we delivered the first in-person training.

“We reckon we’ve spoken to over 500 members of staff across the university. That includes lecturers, tutors, professional staff, administrative staff. 

“We usually do either a longer hour and a half session, which we did recently to the College of Science and Engineering, which is more interactive getting people to think with longer discussions about this." 

While the training started off as voluntary, Clark said her team is now also going into departmental meetings across the university to reach more staff.

"We are really aware that with EDI issues, often these things become self-selective and it’s people like ourselves who are really on board with this kind of stuff and really enthusiastic and it’s the same people who turn up to this stuff over and over again.

"Ultimately that’s not our target audience. Our target audience is like crusty Dave at the bottom of the hall who’s been teaching the same course for 30 years and hasn’t considered re-thinking the demographic of students who attend the university since.

“We do reach them by going into department meetings, everybody’s already there so it’s not optional and you can’t opt out of it.


More from our Edinburgh Correspondent: 


“Generally we've has a positive response, we’ve had a few people saying negative comments or people questioning why it’s necessary.

"The really important thing for us has been working-class members of staff who have come up to us and said ‘this has made me feel more comfortable talking to the people I work with about this issue’.

“Through the 93% Club, I found that we are here and working-class students do exist at Edinburgh; it’s just reminding people that we’re here and reminding future and current students they are just as worthy of their place here, and they add value to the university. It’s just bit by bit.”

A University of Edinburgh spokesperson said: “The University works hard to ensure that our talented students come from all different backgrounds. Being a socially diverse University is a great strength and helps to enrich the lives of everyone studying, teaching and working with us.

 “We know that class-based stereotypes are unacceptably widespread within society and we have a responsibility to tackle this within our own community. Discrimination of any kind has no place here and we ask anyone who has experienced these behaviours to report them to us.

 “We understand that access to university cannot be looked at in isolation from its culture, and that all students need to feel a sense of belonging to thrive. At the University, we continue to work in partnership with our students to address this so that we can be an inclusive and supportive educational environment to all students, irrespective of their background or circumstances.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos