Two senior leaders of commercial property firm CBRE’s new planning division in Scotland have signalled an appetite among developers to invest in new projects in the country’s biggest cities.
But they warned that developments continue to be constrained by the high cost of finance and construction.
Kate Donald and Colin Smith joined CBRE as senior directors in November, as part of a planning team recruited from Turley that also included senior planners Hannah Munro and James Wall. CBRE heralded the recruitment and creation of its new planning division in Scotland as a crucial step in the development of its client offering north of the Border.
The new team joined as Glasgow city centre was continuing its slow recovery from the impact of the pandemic. But, speaking to The Herald in CBRE’s office at 177 Bothwell Street, the duo said they are encouraged by the level of developer activity in Scotland’s major cities.
Asked to assess current market conditions, Mr Smith, who has worked in planning development for 28 years and has a strong background in urban living, hospitality, leisure, and commercial planning, said: “I think broadly speaking there’s an appetite to do things. It is just really hard right now with the cost of funding and finance, the cost of construction, [and] the economic rollercoaster we have been through over the last few years.
“There’s no lack of desire to do things. If you are a commercial developer, that’s what you do and that’s what you want to do. It is finding the right opportunities that are viable to take forward and deliver. I think viability is going to be a word growing in significance over the next few years.”
Read more:
- Energy chief's price pledge as £300m Glasgow district heating scheme takes shape
- Revealed: State of Scottish tourism detailed in new report
-
Tax changes 'fundamentally shift the landscape', leading Scots law firm warns
Ms Donald, who has 20 years’ experience in planning and development, and worked with Mr Smith at Turley for 10 years, said: “I think it is worth noting that we are still seeing enquiries from clients looking at sites in Edinburgh and Glasgow, and in the past year, in Aberdeen. So there is development interest.
“There’s obviously a steady stream of applications getting approved. We are delivering consents for our clients all the time, which is the mainstay of our business. There is activity [but] all the headwinds that were there earlier in the year are still here.”
Mr Smith added: “The good thing is that there is activity. There are lots of things we are working on that we can’t talk about, and that’s a good thing, because it means there are things happening in the background that have not yet transacted or progressed into the public realm. If that wasn’t the case, it wouldn’t be so good.”
Asked if there was any sign of the cost of development easing, Mr Smith said: “Speaking to those who are closer to the contracts and delivery side, there are signs of that, but we are not necessarily close enough. We hear from others about construction and funding costs, but it is not easy just now.”
One factor which in recent years has been cited as barrier to progress has been an apparent lack of resource in city council planning departments.
Commenting on the level of support developers receive from city officials, Ms Donald said: “They have had some resourcing challenges over the last few years. I would say that they have increased their headcounts in their teams. Glasgow in particular has been going through a process of reinvigorating its pre-application process. They have spent a lot of time and energy trying to understand what is helpful to developers and to investors, because they realise that sometimes that is the first contact you have with people who want to invest in the city. They do understand their role in facilitating development and creating positive energy around coming to work with the council.”
Ms Donald added: “I find Glasgow City Council, in particular, good to work with. There are obviously cases sometimes where they don’t agree in terms of planning, and that is just planning. Generally I find them good to work with and I think the strength of our relationship really assists with that.”
Read more:
- Meet the Scottish company boss who wants you to buy less of its goods
- Scottish firms hail 'transformational' employee model
-
Hotel giant upbeat as new openings planned for Scotland
Mr Smith noted: “I think across Edinburgh and Glasgow the senior level of engagement is very good. At officer level, there have been varying patterns of resource constraint. I think Glasgow has invested well of late and broadly speaking, working a lot in Edinburgh, the engagement office is very good. You are never going to get a 100% round of applause when you walk in the door. Generally speaking, they can be challenging and when that’s appropriate that’s absolutely fine. When you are dealing with sites that are challenging and require creative thinking and high-quality product that is absolutely fine. Generally speaking, they are there to be worked with.”
The CBRE planning team is currently working on the New Town Quarter development in the former Royal Bank of Scotland office on Dundas Street in Edinburgh, where original plans for build-to-rent apartments and offices have been revised to a purpose-built student accommodation offer with additional residential properties for sale.
Mr Smith said Scottish Government rent controls, initially introduced by ministers to protect tenants during the cost of living crisis, were the “direct cause” of the build-to-rent plans being scrapped. But he expressed hope that proposals to alter the Housing (Scotland) Bill, including a “carve out” for build-to-rent projects in the rent controls mechanism, will make it more viable for such projects to move forward. “It is still in process,” Mr Smith said. “The ultimate outcome of the bill should really be to facilitate the delivery of more housing, and it can do that by providing stability and certainty in the market that it covers, and that will facilitate investment.”
Share