Exclusive

Douglas Ross to renew probe into Higher History 'injustice'

Scottish Conservative MSP and chair of the Scottish Parliament Education Committee, Douglas Ross, has said that Higher History results in 2025 have "raised serious questions" about marking in 2024. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Scottish Conservative MSP and chair of the Scottish Parliament Education Committee, Douglas Ross, has said that Higher History results in 2025 have "raised serious questions" about marking in 2024. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The chair of Holyrood’s education committee has raised concerns that the 2024 Higher History results “were not sound,” following a significant rebound in attainment this year.

Between 2023 and 2025, the percentage of students earning an A, B or C in Higher History fell by 13 percentage points and immediately recovered with a 14.6-point improvement.

Scottish Conservative MSP and chair of the Scottish Parliament Education Committee, Douglas Ross, told The Herald that he met with Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) officials on 22 July, before results were known, to discuss the potential implications of a change in the Higher History pass rate.

At that meeting, Mr Ross said he raised a concern that, if the pass rate returned to the 2023 level, it would “suggest the 2024 results were not sound,” despite an SQA review that found no change in the marking standard.

Mr Ross said: "I wanted to know what they would judge a success for Higher History in 2025.

"Would a return to pre-2024 levels not indicate their review was wrong?"

He said that SQA officials at the time expected the results to improve, but not to the 2023 level.

Following the publication of pass rates on Tuesday, however, Mr Ross said that this year’s results have renewed his concerns about what happened in 2024.

“While it was encouraging to see pass rates in Higher History back to levels achieved in 2023, the massive fluctuation in the marks achieved in just two years raises serious questions. 

“So far, the response from the SQA has been confusing and contradictory, and understandably, pupils who received poorer than expected results last year will feel a sense of injustice.

“I am seeking a meeting with the Chief Examiner to discuss this further. I also intend to question Ministers about these results when Parliament returns.”


Read more:


Between August 2024 and March 2025, the Higher History marking process was a regular talking point at the Scottish Parliament and the main topic of multiple education committee sessions.

Interest began when the official results showed the pass rate had fallen from 78.7% to 65.7%. The drop was highlighted by a 25% decrease in the average learner score on the Scottish History paper, which fell from 20.6 to 15.3 marks.

In 2025, the average score for the paper was 20.5.

Teachers at the time raised concerns that there had been a change to the marking standard, which they were not told about, and so had no chance to prepare their students.

The SQA's review of Higher History marking in 2024 found that the standard set that year "was not higher than that set in previous years that this examination has run."

The review came under criticism after the SQA admitted that it had not considered conducting a fully independent review.

On Wednesday, an SQA Spokesperson said that this year's Higher History results reflect the "hard work and achievement of learners and the success of a system-wide effort to support subject teachers".

They added: "SQA worked in partnership with History teachers to develop and deliver an enhanced and well-received Understanding Standards programme.

"Our quality-assured awarding, including grade-boundary checks, confirmed the assessment worked as intended and that the national standard was applied."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos