Langholm, the muckle toon at the centre of a sitka battle

In Langholm, members of the community campaign group (SWAG) Save Warblaw Action Group, from left- Iain Bannatyne, Jane Gifford and Jamie Telford. In the background is Warblaw Hill. <i>(Image: Colin Mearns)</i>
In Langholm, members of the community campaign group (SWAG) Save Warblaw Action Group, from left- Iain Bannatyne, Jane Gifford and Jamie Telford. In the background is Warblaw Hill. (Image: Colin Mearns)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

From the top of Whita hill, on a hot humid summer’s day, Iain Bannatyne points out the flanks of Warblaw rising above Langholm which, he says, are set under current proposals, to be cloaked in forestry.

“You can see the potential consequences,” he says, swatting away clouds of flying ants as he speaks, “of what we think is a quite catastrophic proposed land use change. These hills have been farmed for centuries. Some of the landscape we see opposite on Warblaw Hill is proposed essentially to be covered in invasive and non-native commercial conifer.”

Bannatyne is a member of the Save Warblaw Action Group (SWAG) which has been fighting the forestry development.  

But, in the Langholm area, Warblaw is not the only site of changed land use or management.  Walk further, under the day’s humid blue sky, and we see the Tarras Valley Nature Reserve stretching out towards, beyond the hill-line, Blackburn & Hartsgarth. All this, which Bannatyne points out to me, was once owned by the Duke of Buccleuch. Some of it was once grouse moor, some hillside farm. But the new owners and their approaches are very different.

There is, for instance, the community development trust, the Langholm Initiative, which has bought the Tarras Valley Nature Reserve and is managing it for biodiversity. Then, at Blackburn & Harsgarth, there is the company which says it wants to be the first “conservation-focussed” unicorn, Oxygen Conservation, aiming "to reverse the decline in biodiversity through creating high integrity natural capital products for investment”.

Then there is Warblaw, sold in 2019 to James Jones & Sons, the UK’s biggest timber manufacturer, who bought it with the “objective of afforestation; providing a sustainable and local timber supply" for their sawmill at Lockerbie nearby.

Looking out over Warblaw and Langholm, Save Warblaw Action Group, from left to right, Iain Bannatyne, Jane Gifford, Jamie TelfordLooking out over Warblaw and Langholm, Save Warblaw Action Group, from left to right, Iain Bannatyne, Jane Gifford, Jamie Telford (Image: Colin Mearns) Those sales and the new patterns of ownership and management mean that Langholm is surrounded by a patchwork microcosm that takes in many of the approaches pursued in Scotland to nature, rewilding, forestry, use of government funding, natural capital and net zero.

Famously this sell-off by Buccleuch followed the perceived failure of the grouse moor at Langholm and its decline and neglect over a period from the late 1990s when it was at the heart of debate and experiment over grouse moor management and raptor conflict.

During this time, the Duke of Buccleuch first allowed a nature-oriented unmanaged approach, in which hen harrier numbers grew, then later attempted to “establish a commercially viable driven grouse moor”. But the project was deemed a failure.

Both TVNR and Oxygen Conservation took on an area that had been alternately managed and then unmanaged, and are bringing in new approaches. In the case of Tarras Valley this means peatland restoration, herbivore monitoring, the introduction of Highland cattle and other measures designed to increase the variety of habitats on the moor.  

Warblaw, however, wasn’t part of the grouse moor. It was, says Margaret Pool, a former chair at the Langholm Initiative, previously “a very productive sheep farm".

But it’s this forestry planting, especially its areas of commercial conifer plantation, that bothers these Langholm residents.

Unusually for the industry, Scottish Woodlands Ltd, which developed the proposal for James Jones, voluntarily opted to carry out an EIA on its Warblaw woodland creation scheme. They say that they are "committed to ensuring the Warblaw project is designed responsibly, transparently, and in full compliance with the UK Forestry Standard."

"We are voluntarily undertaking a comprehensive Environmental Impact Assessment to guide decision-making," a spokesperson said, "with detailed surveys and ongoing community engagement shaping the evolving design. Our approach balances woodland creation with productive agriculture, while delivering environmental, social, and economic benefits for the local area.

As Bannatyne points out, this makes Warblaw a rarity. “Hundreds of forestry grant schemes representing many thousands of hectares of forestry development have been approved by the regulator in recent years with only four requiring an EIA.” 

Earlier this year, in an article in the Herald, The Royal Society of Edinburgh (RSE) called for “mandatory EIA’s for tree planting proposals over 50 hectares”.

Kat Mayer, education and outreach officer for Tarras Valley Nature Reserve, holding some sphagnum mossKat Mayer, education and outreach officer for Tarras Valley Nature Reserve, holding some sphagnum moss (Image: Colin Mearns)

Jamie Telford, a member of SWAG, points out that fighting such a proposal is a financial challenge.  "Communities," he says, "are left under-informed to face the might of the legal departments and forestry planting companies proxies with no prior knowledge of the Forestry system and its workings."

One of SWAG’s key arguments is how the forest planting will impact on the hill’s shallow peat. It's an issue that has increasingly been highlighted across Scotland in challenges to and campaigns against forestry schemes, as research has demonstrated the importance of carbon in soil.

They want to see the EIA look forensically at “the likely significant environmental effects of this proposal, particularly in relation to the impact on the peat landscape, and the associated GHG emissions”.

Bannatyne rattles through a history of planting on peat, starting back in the 1980s when swathes of the Flow Country were planted with monocultures. 

“In the early 2000s it appears that Scottish Forestry started to recognise that peatland had been degraded, but there were no firm guidelines, only references to planting techniques, how you’re cultivating and avoiding planting in peat of depth of over 50cm. Scientists are now saying 20-30 should be the limit. We’ve taken peat probes at Warblaw and they all came out over that.”

The proposed plantings at Warblaw would not be on deep peat, but SWAG say that science is showing that even the shallow peat they would be planting on has potential to release significant carbon.


READ THE FULL SERIES HERE:

The Future of Dumfries and Galloway – Find all articles here 

The Herald has launched an investigative series on Dumfries and Galloway (Image: Damian Shields)What they would like to see is a detailed carbon calculation of gains and losses over the lifetime of the land, the forest and its timber.

As part of the EIA Scottish Woodland says it is carrying out detailed surveys on peat depth, habitats, landscape, soils and other environmental considerations, which are still ongoing. "Only land suitable under the UK Forestry Standard will be considered for woodland creation," it notes.

Over half the entire land area will, in the plan, be kept for productive farming. 

But SWAG members feel there is something contradictory in the approaches being carried out, or planned, for Warblaw and Tarras Valley, with regard to both peat and Sitka.

“On this side you have public funding restoring the peat,” says Jane Gifford, as we wander the reserve. “On the other side of the valley at Warblaw they are planning to plant trees on shallow peat.”

Standing at the side of the road as I passing through Tarras Valley Nature Reserve, I come across its education and engagement officer Kat Mayer, delivering a talk to a group of visitors. She pulls a clump of sphagnum moss from the ground and holds it high. Already their peatland restoration, funded by Scottish Power, is proving successful.

SWAG also note that at Tarras Valley, they are removing Sitka spruce, a challenging process, while at Warblaw it is being planted.

At Warblaw the plan is for an area of 177ha to be planted with Sitka, representing 43% of the planting, according to Scottish Woodlands, of the design area. However, SWAG point out that there is already a 437ha Cockplay James Jones-owned plantation, planted in the late 2010s, “almost entirely enclosed within the current proposed site” and that therefore Sitka represents 55% of the area. 

SWAG also point out that while the 55% is below the 65% regulatory limit, the "planting site" includes "open ground", “much of which has likely been excluded from plantation because the soil comprises a peat layer beyond 50cm which is restricted from planting”.SWAG campaigners on Whita hill, looking out over Warblaw SWAG campaigners on Whita hill, looking out over Warblaw (Image: Colin Mearns) The planting of Sitka, the non-native species which is Scotland’s major source of timber and wood products, has long been criticised. But, as general manager Rob McKenna at James Jones & Sons in Lockerbie pointed out to me on a visit to the sawmill, the UK needs more timber, and is the second-biggest net importer of forest products globally. James Jones & Sons see this fast-growing tree as unfairly demonised.

But for Bannatyne and other SWAG members, it is not only what happens at Warblaw that matters, but the wider proliferation of forestry projects in the landscape.

“Cumulative impact is a massive thing,” adds Jamie Telford. “We’ve got encroaching forestry from the south, from the north. We’ve got Eskdalemuir forest which has planted over everything. And the effect is swamping the town, economically and physically.” Bannatyne echoes this, describing the creep of expanding forestry as "suffocating".


 Read More:


David Stevenson, founder of Edinburgh Woollen Mill and chairman of the Stevenson Trust, echoes this, “It’s the cumulative impact on the wellbeing of our community – and we see it everywhere around here, its like living in a dark tunnel. I thought we’re just going to be carpeted in the way we see it up Eskdalemuir. This is supposed to be rural Scotland. Where are our hills? We can’t see them? Everything is smothered in trees.”

Land management in Scotland is changing, driven by policy and markets. There is a move towards more trees, less sheep, restoring peatlands. People who have lived in the landscape might not always like these processes of transformation or the changes in subsidies driving them.

That applies to the nature restoration and regenerative farming approach adopted by Tarras Valley Nature Reserve or Oxygen Conservation's natural capital approach, which triggered backlash over its cull of feral goats, as much as forestry plantings.  

“There’s that common phrase. It’s aye been,” says one of the locals, observing how people sometimes react to change.

But SWAG aren’t asking for things to remain the way they have been. This is not a group advocating for things to stay the same, but rather one questioning a particular management of the land, and what it means for people, carbon and nature.

 

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos