From Stranraer to Dumfries, mothers are forced to travel hundreds of miles for safe births — highlighting a maternity care crisis in rural Scotland.
When Claire Fleming became pregnant with her first child in 2012, she never imagined she would spend the next decade of her life travelling thousands of miles just to access maternity care in Dumfries and Galloway.
Yet after four pregnancies, the 35-year-old has witnessed the steady erosion of local services — a decline she describes as frightening, exhausting, and traumatising.
The closure of Galloway Community Hospital’s maternity unit in 2018 — officially due to staffing shortages —left local women like Ms Fleming facing long and stressful journeys to Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary (DGRI).
The mother of four who lives outside of Stranraer in a village called Glenluce says she can chart the drop in service quality through each of her births.
Her first child was Abbey, who was stillborn in 2012, then she had Molly in 2015, James in 2019, and Andrew in 2021.
“I can see the decline with every one of my births,” she told The Herald, "When I had Abbey, the level of services I received in Stranraer was better than what was on offer just a few years later. There was a midwife on call all the time. When you phoned, you always got an answer from somebody.
“When I had Molly, it had started to decline a little, but nowhere near as bad as it was in 2021 when I had Andrew. By that point, I was unable to get appointments in town, I had to go to Dumfries for everything. I had hyperemesis, so I was extremely sick and had to get put on a drip and taken into hospital on multiple occasions.
“I calculated that I had done 7,500 miles for appointments through my pregnancies.”
Claire Fleming and her family (Image: supplied) Due to the closure of maternity services at the hospital in Stranraer, only a 20-minute drive from her home, Ms Fleming was forced to make the 120-mile round trip to Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary for any appointment.
“Even appointments that only last five minutes, you had to drive to Dumfries each time," Ms Fleming said: "There was just nothing getting done in Stranraer and I really got the impression from the midwives that they were really asking Dumfries’ permission to do anything in Stranraer.”
Her 12-week scans were carried out locally at Stranraer's Oak Tree Centre, but all other care — consultant-led due to her history of stillbirth — required the long journeys to Dumfries.
NHS Dumfries and Galloway has told The Herald the Oak Tree Family Centre in Stranraer now provides enhanced maternity care locally, while all higher-risk births continue at Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary.
However, Ms Fleming says the lack of services near her is not just inconvenient, but the mother of four says it is dangerous, leading to many headline-grabbing stories of women giving birth at the side of the notorious A75.
Her own family was not immune to this sort of experience.
Ms Fleming said: “My cousin had her baby four miles outside of Stranraer because she was being sent down to Dumfries and ended up having to pull into a farm drive and have her baby there. It’s horrendous.”
NHS Dumfries and Galloway commissioned an independent review, which recommended the creation of an on-call, midwife-led unit in Stranraer.
However, the Integration Joint Board rejected the proposal, maintaining the current system: antenatal checks in Stranraer, births at Dumfries or at home.
Campaigners fear this decision puts lives at risk.
Angela Armstrong, a retired GP and member of the Galloway Community Hospital Action Group has spoken to mums who have had to give birth in laybys on the A75 as a result of the long journeys for maternity care.
“My fear is that we are going to have a death and that’s not me being melodramatic, it is a risk. The roads are awful,” she told The Herald.
Ms Armstrong said the problem also feeds into a depopulation crisis in the region as young couples are discouraged from living in the area due to the lack of maternity care.
The retired GP, 83, said: “It is older people who tend to live here now.
“We want people here to have a working population and what we need are young doctors but are they going to come here if they are scared to have a baby? I wouldn’t have.”
Dr Angela Armstrong, retired GP and member of Galloway Community Hospital Action Group. (Image: supplied) And it's not just maternity services which are raising concerns in the area.
The closure of health services across Dumfries and Galloway has made Dr Armstrong worried about the future of the NHS.
“It breaks my heart,” Dr Armstrong added, “Having worked for the NHS for so many years, I just feel very let down by successive governments who have failed to plan properly. I can’t see how the NHS can survive, if I’m honest. We need more doctors, nurses and healthcare workers and we just don’t have them.”
Ms Fleming says hospital facilities are sitting idle while expectant mothers drive thousands of miles.
“There’s a two-bed unit in the Galloway Community hospital," she said, "Which I don’t really know what it’s being used for just now but at one point it was used for storage.
“Everything has been moved to the Oak Tree Centre, where there are no facilities in place for people to have their babies locally.
“A lot of literature that’s given to women when they’re going to have their babies, if you look up online, it still points in the direction of the clinic birthing suite in Stranraer and that just does not exist in reality anymore. It’s really misleading."
Read More:
-
'The blight that strangles the lifeblood': Scots region battles depopulation curse
-
Business leaders demand 'level playing field' in Scottish Border tax row
-
Revealed: Four deaths a year on Scotland's 'not fit for purpose' Euroroutes
And for families living beyond Stranraer, the distances are even more punishing.
Ms Fleming said: “There’s a place called Drummore, which is far out from Stranraer, never mind anywhere else, and the roads aren’t great so it’s a really scary place to be and a stressful situation.
“The A75 is publicly not great and as much as it’s really difficult for the women giving birth, it’s really difficult for the partners, or the person that’s driving, too. You’re trying to keep them calm or looked after and also be concentrating on a really dangerous road too.”
The Herald has launched an investigative series about the region. (Image: Damian Shields) The experience has taken a heavy toll.
“It definitely has,” Ms Fleming admits when asked if being pregnant in Dumfries and Galloway has traumatised her. “When I had Andrew, I chose to get my tubes tied and sterilised at the same time because the thought of going through that same thing again genuinely really scared me.
“I’ve done a lot of research, spoken to people of the same age, and there’s a lot of people who are feeling very much the same that just don’t want to have their babies locally because it’s just such a scary thought.”
For her, the issue is also about women’s rights.
“I do think that women are, quite a lot of the time in health spaces, pushed to the side or not taken seriously," she said, "women have the right to have a safe environment to have their babies or to grow a family and that’s being taken away from them just now.”
Ms Fleming worries about the impact on her children, particularly her 10-year-old daughter Molly.
She said: “I keep telling her, ‘By the time it’s you having your babies, I want you to have the option to have them locally.' We shouldn’t have to send all our young people away places so they can have better lives. That should be able to happen here.”
Claire Fleming is worried about the impact of her situation on her daughter (Image: supplied) Asked if she is concerned her daughter will move away, Fleming says: “I really am. It’s something that I think about a lot. If they continue to make cuts or changes, I worry about just how bad it’s going to get. There’s not a lot of draw in keeping her here if basic things like being able to have your baby safely aren’t in place.
Despite visits from senior politicians, Ms Fleming says she feels ignored.
“We’ve had Anas Sarwar down here, we’ve had the minister for women’s health down as well but nothing is changing.
"It’s not that nobody’s listening to us, it’s the fact that they are now ignoring us. I’m kind of shouting into the abyss," she explained.
NHS Dumfries and Galloway continues to stress that antenatal and postnatal care is still available across the region, and that high-risk pregnancies are safest at DGRI.
However, trust has been eroded.
In Wigtownshire, beds lie unused at the community hospital while mothers drive hundreds of miles on dangerous roads.
Galloway Community Hospital Action group has its next meeting with NHS D&G at the start of September.
Dr Armstrong told The Herald: “The number one issue on the agenda is maternity issues.”
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “We understand challenges in rural areas and expect all NHS Boards to provide maternity services that are delivered as close to home as practicable, balanced with ensuring the safety of mother and baby.”
“The decision to retain the current model in Wigtownshire was made by the Integration Joint Board in Dumfries and Galloway, after an independent review and local consultation. Under this model, care before and after birth is provided either at home, the Oaktree Family Centre in Stranraer or at Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary, if required. The Oaktree Family Centre provides an enhanced antenatal service, including ultrasound facilities, to reduce the need for travel to Dumfries.”
Share