Exclusive

What is life really like in a Scottish asylum seeker hotel?

Pro and anti migrant groups confronted each other outside a Falkirk hotel last weekend. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Pro and anti migrant groups confronted each other outside a Falkirk hotel last weekend. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

'Migrant hotels’ have become the focal point of backlash against the presence of asylum seekers in Scotland this summer. 

Protests have been held at scores of hotels in recent weeks, outside venues in Aberdeen, Falkirk, and Perth. 

Robina Qureshi is the founder of Positive Action in Housing, a charity that works with asylum seekers and refugees. 

Speaking to The Herald, she explains how life for those living inside the hotels is much different than often imagined.

“How can you enjoy being in a 4 or 5 star hotel if you are forced to live there and are only given nine pounds a week,” she notes. “You don’t have a choice.

“95% of the people we speak to have said the same thing - ‘help me get out’. No one wishes to be in a hotel - they want to cook and live in their own home.”

Asylum seekers living in hotels which are self-catering are given £49.98 on a pre-loaded card. Those living in hotels which provide meals are given just £9.95. 

Conditions in the hotels - which Qureshi calls ‘hostels’ - are spartan.

Robina Qureshi has advocated for refugee rights for more than 30 years.

“We support 4,000 people and routinely monitor what is going on,” she says. “We have been told they are suffering badly in the hotels. They want out, they are desperate to work.

“There’s no room service, of course. They are served packet food, chips and pasta. The rooms can be cold and damp.”

The Home Office outsources its accommodation provision to third party contractors like Mears Group. 

Mears, which operates dozens of hotels across the nation, states on its website:

“We are a trusted provider of housing to various central Government departments, including the Ministry of Defence and the Home Office. We provide affordable housing to ex service personnel, to key workers and to people seeking asylum in the UK.”

The firm had previously been criticised by a number of charities working with asylum seekers. 

In Glasgow, an accommodation unit run by Mears was forced to suspend services for mothers and babies in 2022 after a report found it to be “cramped and unsafe”.

Qureshi says it is no surprise that protests have materialised around hotels this summer.

She notes: “There’s often an image of immigrants coming into the country as not working. 

There’s always been a danger that this would become a flash point. We feared this for a long time.

“This is a tool used by the far right to give the impression that people of colour are coming here not to work and instead just live in hotels. They just need permission to work. 

“It’s a performative narrative and is the exact opposite of what is happening. But it is difficult to argue against a mob.”

A migrant hotel in Erskine was picketed in 2023.

The mental health of people living in the hotels has suffered amid the rising protests, Qureshi says.

She remarks: “People have told us they are frightened particularly during the summer. People were thanking us for telling them how to contact the police. 

“Their mental health has been affected and some fear going outside. They have expressed a desire to be invisible but they can’t.”

One asylum seeker from Aberdeen told The Herald: “There is fear from what we have seen recently, and people need to know we are here for safety. We are people who are trying to change themselves and contribute to community.”

According to the Royal College of Psychiatrists, refugees and asylum seekers face ‘systemic barriers’ to accessing mental health treatment, often due to a lack of specialist care, interpreting services, and digital poverty. 

Their report states: “Common mental illnesses in displaced adults include PTSD (31%), depression (31%), anxiety disorders (11%), and psychosis (1.5%). There are also high rates of distress, grief and PTSD in displaced people under the age of 18, especially in the context of war and trauma.”

The key, Qureshi argues, is for the government to speed up the asylum process and grant people the right to work while waiting for their claims to be processed. 

Many asylum seekers are professionals, such as doctors and businesspeople.

She points to the story of one asylum seeker she knows, a respected doctor back home.

“One asylum seeker we worked with was an orthopaedic surgeon who trained in Egypt,” she notes. “He was put into a hotel and couldn’t work. No one gave him advice. 

“Finally, he was able to apply for permission to work and got a job in an NHS hospital. Not as a surgeon, but it was a start.

“The government would be better placed not asking what your colour is but looking at what your qualifications are.”

Qureshi believes that the growing tensions can be assuaged if asylum seekers are given the ability to work and are moved out of the hotels to more suitable accommodation. 

“The government should build more affordable housing,” she says. “That way it can be used for both asylum seekers and local communities. Yet, this country has operated a policy of self-harm and denied the Scottish public billions in taxes. 

“People aren’t able to work and have to go where they are told. By outsourcing these things, the government is depriving our communities of capital.”

Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey speaking in the House of Commons.

In May, the Liberal Democrats put forward legislation in the House of Commons which would have changed the law to allow asylum seekers to work after three months of waiting for their claim, rather than the current 12 months. 

However, the government did not consider the amendment as part of the Border Security, Asylum, and Security Bill, which passed 316-95.

Lib Dem MP Lisa Smart said: “We need an asylum system that makes decisions fairly and swiftly - which is why we’ve been calling to tackle the backlog by establishing a dedicated unit to improve the speed and quality of asylum decision-making.

“We will keep pushing Labour to take the action that’s needed. If they really cared about improving integration, they would have backed our amendment this week that would have scrapped the ban on asylum seekers working.”


Read more:

'Shouting at people in a hotel won't fix anything': Inside the Falkirk asylum protest

Asylum seeker hotel protests are 'completely unacceptable' says John Swinney

'Asylum seekers don't want donations - they just want to live in peace and safety'


A spokesperson for Mears said: “All hotels used by Mears are assessed to ensure they are of an appropriate standard and meet the Home Office contract requirements.  In hotels, three meals a day are provided, menus meet NHS Eatwell standards, are nutritionally balanced, reviewed regularly and tailored for dietary, cultural or medical needs. Snacks and drinks are available throughout the day.

"Our welfare support officers are on site daily to speak with service users, support them to access healthcare and education, and address any concerns. We are committed to ensuring accommodation is safe, habitable and fit for purpose and to treating all our service users with dignity and respect”

A Home Office spokesperson added: "The government inherited a broken asylum system, with tens of thousands stuck in hotels and costs reaching £9 million a day.

"Over the past year, we have doubled decision-making rates and cut nearly £1 billion in hotel spending. We are committed to close all asylum hotels by the end of this Parliament."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos