Police defend Holyrood rally response after noise complaint

Police speak with a protester at a For Women Scotland demonstration outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh <i>(Image: Jane Barlow/PA)</i>
Police speak with a protester at a For Women Scotland demonstration outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh (Image: Jane Barlow/PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Police Scotland has defended its handling of a rally outside the Scottish Parliament after a Tory MSP lodged formal complaints about noise at a counter-protest.

Pam Gosal, who represents West Scotland, has written to both Chief Constable Jo Farrell and Presiding Officer Alison Johnstone, raising concerns over what she described as a “significant disturbance” during the demonstration organised by For Women Scotland (FWS) on 4 September.


Read more


The rally, timed to coincide with First Minister’s Questions, was called by the gender-critical group to demand ministers implement the UK Supreme Court’s April ruling that the terms “sex” and “woman” in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex.

Ms Gosal, who addressed the gathering, said individuals from the counter-protest group Cabaret Against Hate disrupted proceedings by blasting loud music from a sound system “in an effort to silence speakers”.

In her letter to the Chief Constable, the MSP said organisers had already warned parliamentary security about the risk of disruption.

“Individuals from the organisation ‘Cabaret Against Hate’ blasted loud music on a sound system in an effort to silence speakers, causing significant disturbance,” she wrote.

“It is my understanding that under the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, the police can order someone playing loud music to stop if it causes annoyance. However, there was no intervention.”

She added: “Concerns were raised by organisers with the Scottish Parliament’s security on 26 August. The Parliament’s Security Team Manager, in turn, passed them on to the Parliament’s police unit.

“As a speaker and as an attendee of a rally, I was extremely disappointed in the way this was handled by the police. Therefore, I would like to request that this is further investigated and that all those responsible for the disturbance are held accountable.”

Protesters outside HolyroodProtesters outside Holyrood (Image: Jane Barlow/PA)

In response, Police Scotland insisted officers had acted proportionately and in line with their obligations to balance the rights of those protesting and counter-protesting.

A spokesperson said: “Police Scotland is a rights-based organisation and our role is to ensure public safety while balancing the rights of protesters who wish to peacefully demonstrate. We have a duty to ensure the safety of those protesting or counter-protesting, alongside minimising any disruption to our communities.”

The force said Police Liaison Officers had engaged with demonstrators throughout the day, that the loud music was intermittently reduced and capped by a time limit, and that the level of noise “did not meet the threshold of serious public nuisance or disorder that would justify criminal enforcement.”

A Scottish Parliament spokesperson said: “The Parliament welcomes and facilitates peaceful protest outside its building. The safety of the public outside the building is a matter of public order for Police Scotland.

“The Presiding Officer will respond to Pam Gosal’s letter in due course.”

Marion Calder from For Women Scotland said someone who works in the building had recorded the sound from the counter-protest at 110dB.

She said: “I'm not sure you can claim to be balancing rights when you allow one man the remit to cause physical distress without any discernible goal beyond being a public nuisance.

“There were mums with young children who had to leave, as well as dog owners whose pets were distressed.

“One man disrupted the rights of hundreds who were there to listen to MSPs and other women speakers.

“We've never counter-protested trans events, but if we were to ever abandon sanity and decency and turn up to blast show tunes at them, I wonder how long it would take for the police to act?

“Luckily, for Trans Rights Activists, we prefer to rely on our smarts and arguments rather than being thuggish bullies.”

The demonstration outside Holyrood drew hundreds of campaigners. Many held up signs including “Scottish Government, obey the law”, “Women won’t wait”, and “Contempt for women”.

Those taking part included British sailor Tracy Edwards, known for skippering the first all-female crew in the Whitbread Round The World Yacht Race.

She told the rally: “There are still men in women’s prisons, in changing rooms, in women’s toilets,” despite it being 142 days since the ruling.

Labour's Jackie Baillie told demonstrators: “Nobody is above the law. The Scottish Government is not above the law.

The Supreme Court have ruled, so the Scottish Government should write to all of their public bodies, all of their public bodies, all their agencies, and tell them to follow the law. No delay, do it now.”

While ministers have accepted the judgment, they say they are awaiting updated guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission before issuing instructions to schools, prisons, and other public bodies.

That position has already drawn criticism from the EHRC itself, which has warned Scottish ministers not to delay implementing the judgment.

Last month, For Women Scotland lodged a fresh action at the Court of Session, seeking to have the government’s transgender pupil guidance and prison policy formally quashed.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos