On the morning of the recent Hamilton and Larkhall by-election, I spent some time interviewing 16- and 17-year-olds to find out if — and whether — they would be bothering to vote.
The answer of two students we spoke to on Hamilton High Street struck me in particular. They wouldn’t be voting, no.
Why? Because, since they didn’t know anything about politics, they didn’t feel they should.
It was like asking a non-driver why they weren’t getting behind the wheel. Since they didn’t know how, they wouldn’t be taking part.
Over the summer at the University of Glasgow’s John Smith Centre, we decided to put this sentiment to the test, polling 16- and 17-year-olds across the UK about their likelihood to vote.
The Hamilton by-election saw Labour pull off an unexpected victory (Image: Jane Barlow) It comes as the age group in England joins those in Scotland and Wales in the franchise.
Many told us they would consider using the vote. But, sure enough, the poll also showed that Britain’s youngest voters feel deeply unprepared to take part in politics, and to use the vote that government is giving them.
Two-thirds said their school hadn’t prepared them to take part in elections. The most common reason for not voting is “because I don’t know enough about politics”.
When we asked respondents to choose one word to sum up their views on politics in the UK, the most common word was “confusing” (followed by “complicated” and “boring”).
Word cloud of 16- and 17-year-olds’ views on UK politics (Image: John Smith Centre)
So what, you might ask? After all, most 16- and 17-year-olds have plenty of other things on their minds than Angela Rayner’s tax affairs or Keir Starmer’s choice of Scottish secretary.
But, to my mind, the poll reveals what’s missing in the way we prepare young people to take part in the world around them.
We’ve given them the vote — and that’s fine. But the poll shows we are conspicuously failing to educate young people about our civic and political realm.
This lack of understanding is then leading to a loss of agency: a sense among many that they can’t make a difference.
Previous research has shown this sense of helplessness is particularly the case for groups who already feel marginalised, such as young women, pupils from ethnic minorities, and those from lower socio-economic groups.
If we want an educated and active citizenry, these need addressing. One answer lies in giving greater prominence to the teaching of citizenship in schools.
As the Association for Citizenship Education has shown, while learning about democracy is embedded in the curriculum across the UK, provision is inconsistent.
It is calling for every pupil in the UK to be guaranteed access to high-quality citizenship education, giving pupils a clear grounding in democracy, voting, rights and media literacy.
Research shows that those students who do get a grounding in citizenship are far more likely to be engaged, to trust institutions and to feel ready to participate in their communities.
The John Smith Centre is stepping up its own efforts this year, taking politicians into schools in deprived parts of the west of Scotland to talk up the idea of civic and political participation, and to show the trade-offs and complexities inherent in political decision-making.
The students we’ve already met have made it clear how much they’re looking for more spaces to debate, discuss and understand the world around them.
Many more don’t feel they have a role to play in society, however. As a result, they’re checking out. To build a stronger society — and create a healthier politics — that needs to change.
Share