Exclusive

Record 2700 complaints against councillors - is process being misused?

West Dunbartonshire Council headquarters <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
West Dunbartonshire Council headquarters (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Scotland’s standards watchdog received a record 2,714 complaints about councillors last year, an almost nine-fold increase on the year before.

Yet despite the surge, just 128 cases were investigated in 2024/25 — around 5%.

The figures, released under Freedom of Information, have raised fears the complaints process is being “weaponised” against councillors, with vexatious or ineligible submissions stretching resources and slowing down the handling of legitimate cases.

What makes the numbers even more striking is that there are only 1,227 councillors in Scotland.

The authority’s press office expressed surprise when The Herald shared the numbers.

Complaints are first assessed by the Ethical Standards Commissioner to decide whether an investigation will take place. If one is opened, the complainant, the councillor involved, and their council or public body are notified.

The Commissioner then investigates, and if it is determined that the Code of Conduct may have been breached, the councillor is given the chance to respond before a final report is submitted to the Standards Commission for Scotland.

The West Dunbartonshire complaints did not pass the first threshold. They were also all submitted in a single email.

The missive, signed by 210 people, complained about 12 councillors. That had to be recorded by the Commissioner as 210 complaints about each councillor.

It is understood the email came from Balloch and Haldane Community Council in June 2024 and was about the 12 councillors who voted in favour of the development at Flamingo Land.

In 2023/24 there were 317 complaints to the Commissioner, with 173 investigated. The year before there were 130 complaints, of which 94 were investigated.

The Commissioner’s data shows the 2024/25 spike was categorised as being about “quasi-judicial or regulatory applications”, relating to councillors’ involvement in planning or licensing decisions.

By contrast, some categories that traditionally generate high numbers of complaints actually fell. Complaints about disrespect towards employees or the public halved from 150 to 65, while allegations of disrespect towards fellow councillors remained at 33.

Even when cases are investigated, breaches are rarely found. In 2024/25, just 12 breaches were established. Meanwhile, 25 investigations concluded with no breach, and 29 cases remain open.

The Commissioner’s workload has ballooned, but the number of substantiated breaches remains low, prompting questions about the effectiveness of the system and whether large, co-ordinated complaint campaigns need to be managed more efficiently.


Councillor Fiona Higgins, who is under investigation, said the sheer volume of complaints was down to “misuse of the system, not a sudden collapse in councillor behaviour”.

She told The Herald: “Almost anything can be submitted, and that makes it too easy to weaponise complaints for political or personal ends.

“Sometimes complaints are political, sometimes personal — but the effect is the same. Instead of protecting trust, the process gets diverted into silencing critics. That undermines confidence in the very standards it is meant to uphold.”

Cllr Higgins, Labour member for Canal ward in Glasgow, said a complaint “carries stress, reputational risk, and wasted energy”.

She added: “Councillors see that and think twice about scrutinising too hard. The result is a chilled democracy where accountability becomes dangerous instead of necessary.

“The Ethical Standards Commissioner plays a vital role. The problem is misuse. We need stronger filters so vexatious complaints do not drain resources, and clearer guidance on what really counts as a breach. The framework should protect scrutiny, not punish it.

“High standards in public life matter. But the cost of battering scrutiny into subjection is real — serious financial decisions, like large exit payments, can pass unscrutinised.

“Misuse of complaints does not raise standards, it weakens democracy and wastes public money. Reform is urgently needed to stop abuse while strengthening genuine accountability.”

A spokesperson for the Commissioner said: “There have been 2,714 total complaints made against councillors in 2024/25 and 2,520 of those are connected to one case.

“The case with 2,520 complaints was submitted through one email regarding 12 councillors in West Dunbartonshire Council and had 210 signatories. We are required to record complaints individually, regardless of whether they are made collaboratively, and as such this resulted in the high volume. This case was closed and dismissed at the assessment stage due to not meeting admissibility criteria.”

The spokesperson added: “We do not take account of the motivations of complainers. Our role is simply to assess whether there may have been a breach of the Councillors’ Code of Conduct and, where it appears that there has or may have been, to investigate in accordance with our published procedures.”

A spokesperson for West Dunbartonshire Council said: "The Council is not notified about inadmissible complaints."

Additional reporting by Emily Moore.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos