Exclusive

In data - the full costs of Scotland's PFI/PPP schools

PFI/PPP schemes were encouraged by the Labour government led by Tony Blair. Photo: Jonathan Brady/PA Wire
PFI/PPP schemes were encouraged by the Labour government led by Tony Blair. Photo: Jonathan Brady/PA Wire
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Education specialist James McEnaney breaks down the official data on school PFI/PPP projects, exploring the overall costs of the scheme, the value of the buildings being financed, and the organisations turning huge amounts of public money into private profits.


The first payments for PFI/PPP schools in Scotland were made in the year 2000, when Falkirk Council paid £7m.

The Scotland-wide cost then jumped substantially over the course of the next decade, reaching a total of around £361m by the year 2010. By 2020, this figure had increased to £457m, and in the current financial year councils will pay a total of around £555m – more than half a billion pounds. This, of course, comes at a time of enormous financial pressures in Scottish education – in recent years, councils have cut funding for teacher numbers, school transport and ASN provision in an effort to balance their books, and a several settings have been mothballed or permanently closed.

Payments for PFI/PPP schools are expected to peak in 2029, when the national cost will be around £564m. This figure then falls to £466m by 2036, with the final payments being made in 2041.

 

In total, more than £7.7bn has been spent on PFI/PPP schools over the past twenty-five years, but a further sum of nearly £6.9bn remains outstanding. The chart below shows that a little over half of the total bill has been paid so far.

 

Data provided by the Scottish Government also breaks down the specific annuals costs of PFI/PPP schools for each of the councils to make use of the scheme. Using the drop-down menu in the chart below, you can select individual local authorities and see how much they have paid in each year of the scheme, and how much they are expected to have to pay for each year before their contracts come to an end.

 


READ MORE


It is also important to note that councils are at different stages of their PFI/PPP deals. Some have already cleared the majority of the outstanding balance, but others are less than halfway towards this point. This year’s payment of around £5m will be the final instalment due from Falkirk Council, and Aberdeenshire Council will be free of PFI/PPP school payments by 2031. The expected £18m bill for Perth & Kinross Council in 2041 will be the final payment under this programme.

The chart below allows you to see how much each council has paid, and how much it still owes.

 

When councils reach the end of the contract for their PFI/PPP schools, the buildings will be transferred public sector. However, a key criticism of the scheme is that the costs for servicing the debts far exceed the value of the assets being created.

Using the drop down menu in the chart below, you can select individual councils and see the disparity between the total expected cost of their PFI/PPP schools agreement compared with the capital value of the buildings that they will eventually take possession of.

 

Criticism of the costs of PFI/PPP programmes is long-standing, and led the SNP to pledge to move away from the approach in their 2007 manifesto, but official data shows more than just the millions of pounds being spent by councils – it also details the organisations who are profiting from these contracts.

The table below details the registered ‘equity holders’ for each council. Some projects are backed by a single organisation, whereas others have multiple financers sharing the payments. Several councils also have two separate PFI/PPP schools programmes in operation at the same time, with different companies benefitting financially.

Finally, the chart below gives an idea of the scale of PFI/PPP payments by comparing them to other areas of spending in the education portfolio. As you can see, the amount of money being spent servicing the debt on schools is much higher than the sums allocated to ASN, teacher numbers, and pupil equity funding (sometimes referred to as anti-poverty funding) - in fact, even of those three areas of spending are combined, PFI/PPP payments are still around £200m higher.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos