Unspun 🗳️

Will there be protests at SNP conference over indy plan?

There is dissatisfaction among SNP members over the First Minister's independence strategy. <i>(Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)</i>
There is dissatisfaction among SNP members over the First Minister's independence strategy. (Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


Could we see loud and disruptive protests next month at the SNP's conference, not by external groups but by the party's own members?

Such has been the level of dissatisfaction among the party's grassroots that some activists have been discussing going on hunger strike while others have been talking about whether to invade the stage during a major debate.

It's not the best backdrop for the First Minister's second speech as leader to his party's annual conference which will take place over three days in Aberdeen.

John Swinney managed to reduce tensions in the SNP last year when he promised to listen to members following the party's devastating defeat at the July general election when it lost 39 seats on its 2019 tally.


Read More:


But can he do so again? He faces a tough test.

The focus of ire currently is his strategy on independence.

Mr Swinney has previously said the SNP winning a majority at May’s Holyrood elections will serve as a mandate for another independence vote.

However, polls uggest the SNP is highly unlikely to achieve a feat only achieved by Alex Salmond's SNP in 2011.

At the party's conference next month Mr Swinney and the SNP's depute leader Keith Brown have put down a motion which they want their party to approve in a vote.


Read More:


It says next year’s election should be fought “on a clear platform of national independence”.

However, it adds that “how Scotland becomes independent matters” and that the “process must be agreed, democratic, constitutional and legal so that our nation gains recognition both at home and abroad”.

This, the two men argue, means a “national referendum remains the right way forward”.

The motion also states the party should aim to repeat “the 2011 achievement of securing an SNP majority in the election, with at least 65 SNP MSPs”.

To put it mildly many SNP members aren't currently convinced.

They fear the party is not going to win a majority and wonder what happens to the independence cause then.

Instead local SNP branches have tabled amendments to the leadership's resolution calling for the party to adopt a position of using the Holyrood elections next May as a “de facto referendum”.

They argue that that would mean if the SNP and other pro-independence parties won a majority, it should be “considered a mandate to negotiate independence”.

While that was latterly the party’s policy under Nicola Sturgeon, it was abandoned shortly after her resignation and Mr Swinney has said it's a plan that won't work.

But SNP members see the fight for independence as now stalled and there is growing frustration.

It was reported on Wednesday that some groups of supporters had been considering going on hunger strike in protest at the First Minister's indyref2 strategy.

In a press release on Sunday, a group by the name of Scotland For Independence urged activists to join them in consuming only water, zero-calorie drinks and electrolytes in an effort to pressure the SNP leadership into abandoning its referendum plan.

In a 7,500-word manifesto, the three anonymous activists, who claimed they had been SNP members for three decades, then quit the party but now planned to rejoin, sent detailed instructions for others to take part and “change the course of Scottish history”.

Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.


However, the next day, the group abruptly axed the plan, citing health concerns among those who might have joined them and fears hunger strikes could cause divisions within the SNP before the Holyrood elections in May.

Meanwhile, The Herald was told that some SNP members were considering charging onto the stage to try to stop the leadership's strategy from being debated.

We were told, however, that on reflection they decided against, fearing it could weaken the SNP's performance at the Holyrood elections.

So the First Minister may not have to deal with independence activists on hunger strikes or taking to the stage in protests when he faces his party next month.

But will activists remain calm should the SNP not get its majority to advance indyref2?

That could well be another matter indeed.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos