SNP with big lead in new Holyrood poll despite unhappiness

John Swinney speaks at a press conference in Bute House as his party looks to maintain their grip on government. <i>(Image: Gordon Terris/H&T)</i>
John Swinney speaks at a press conference in Bute House as his party looks to maintain their grip on government. (Image: Gordon Terris/H&T)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The SNP leads a new poll ahead of the 2026 Holyrood election despite the majority of the public believing the Scottish Government is performing poorly in key policy areas.

According to the survey, carried out by Survation on behalf of campaign group Scotland in Union the party would garner 37% of the constituency vote and 31% on the list if the contest was held tomorrow. 

However, the poll, which surveyed 2,051 Scots over the age of 16, found that 56% of voters believe the government’s management of the NHS is 'not well’, compared to just 39% who believe they are performing ‘well’.

Voters have criticised the government's handling of the NHS.(Image: Image: PA)

Likewise, 50% believe the SNP are bungling the education system, while 58% hit out at the party’s handling of the economy. 

The government also received poor marks for crime and policing (58%) and social care (60%).

Despite clear discontent with the SNP, the poll shows that none of Scotland’s other political parties have caught up with the nationalists, who have been in government since 2007.

Survation has Scottish Labour taking home 20% of the constituency vote, followed by Reform in third with 18%. 

The Tories are expected to come in fourth place with 11%, followed by the Lib Dems (7%), the Greens (5%), and Alba (1%). 

Similarly, the SNP is expected to garner 31% on the regional list, followed by Labour at 18% and Nigel Farage's party at 16%. 

The Conservatives would again take fourth with 13%, while the Lib Dems would rise to 11%, followed by the Greens at 8% and Alba at 2%.

Asked how they would vote in an inependence referendum, 60% of the respondents said they would choose to remain in the United Kingdom, compared to 40% who would vote ‘Yes’ to a formal separation between Scotland and the rest of the UK.

The survey also revealed the top priorities for voters ahead of next spring’s election, with the NHS (57%) coming in 30 points ahead of immigration and energy bills (both 29%); as well as the economy (27%) and tax levels (19%).

Reform UK could become the third largest party in Holyrood next spring.(Image: )

Polling guru, Professor Sir John Curtice said the poll showed that many of those critical of how well the Scottish Government is performing across a range of issues voted for the SNP at the 2021 election.

"However, on the issues that matter most to voters – the NHS, the economy and education – the much smaller group of voters who backed the SNP [at last year's general election] are, on balance at least, inclined to give the Scottish Government the benefit of the doubt.

"Among last year’s SNP’s supporters, the SNP has a net score of +30 on the NHS, +28 on education and +17 on the economy. This helps explain why nearly three-quarters (74%) of those who voted for the party last year are willing to do so again.

"To really understand what's happening you also have to look at evaluations of the UK Labour government's record - and the extant evidence is that is even worse - and especially that 2024 Labour voters are more critical of the UK govt than 2024 SNP ones are of the Scottish Government.

"I'm afraid this poll looks at only one half of the picture. "


Read more: 

Exclusive Herald poll predicts dramatic shift in Scottish political landscape

SNP maintains strong lead over Scottish Labour for Holyrood, new poll finds

New poll shows SNP short of majority at Holyrood despite 20-point lead


Keith Brown, Depute Leader of the SNP, said: “This poll gives the SNP its highest constituency vote share in almost three years and puts us within touching distance of an outright majority in the Scottish Parliament. 

“The SNP is focussed on making Scotland a better place to live. NHS waiting times are coming down and GP numbers are up, our young people achieved outstanding exam results this year, and we’ve just scrapped peak rail fares for good - saving commuters hundreds of pounds.

“There can be no doubt that Westminster treats Scotland as an afterthought and is holding us back. Independence is the fresh start that Scotland needs so we can release our nation’s full potential."

Scottish Conservative deputy leader Rachael Hamilton said: “This poll confirms Scots are sick and tired of the SNP’s incompetence.

“The SNP’s 18 years in power have been epitomised by them failing on every major issue that they are responsible for.

“Our NHS is in a state of permanent crisis, our once world-leading educational standards have been destroyed and we have the worst drug death rate in Europe.

“The real priorities of Scots continue to be ignored by John Swinney and his colleagues who are hellbent on pushing their obsession with independence above everything else.

“For the sake of moving Scotland on, we must get this rotten SNP government out at next year’s election.”

Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: “It is no surprise that Scots are unhappy with the state of public services after years of neglect from this dismal SNP government.

“It is damning that just 39% of respondents think our health service is performing well – but this chimes with the dreadful statistics we regularly see, including on lengthy waiting lists for A&E, operations, and heartbreaking figures on drug and alcohol deaths.

“Meanwhile, just 14% of those polled said independence is one of the most important issues for them. Yet, John Swinney has insisted on putting this front and centre of his Holyrood campaign, demonstrating how out of touch he is with people across the country.

“This busted-flush SNP government is out of ideas and out of time. Anas Sarwar and Scottish Labour are ready to unite our country, fix the NHS, end the waste of public money, and restore our public services.”

Alistair Cameron, chair of Scotland in Union said the poll confirmed “widespread dissatisfaction” with the SNP government. 

He said: “People don't want to leave the UK, and they don't want the SNP prioritising it when our public services are in such chaos.

“Scotland urgently needs a competent Holyrood government which focuses on day-to-day issues – the devolved responsibilities which are important to our lives every single day.  

Mr Cameron added: “We need politicians who will fix the NHS, address the housing crisis, and tackle the problems with crime and policing – not populist grandstanding, nationalists picking fights with the UK Government, or an unwanted constitutional obsession.

“Next year’s election is an opportunity to elect politicians who listen to people’s priorities and work to improve lives across Scotland, rather than nationalists seeking to divide us.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos