Today's reports on the financial sustainability of Scotland's colleges and universities show sectors that are struggling to stay afloat. Although the references to insolvency that characterise the colleges' report are absent from the survey of universities, so too is the impact of the significant cash crisis at the University of Dundee and a full discussion of the implications for job losses is included in university "restructuring" strategies.
There are ongoing concerns surrounding the University of Dundee, which received £62 million in emergency relief from the Scottish Government. The bailout, however, is expected to see the university through a tumultuous period of job loss and recovery. It is not meant to be a long-term solution in itself.
Beyond the raw cash crisis, the SFC reports reflect another harsh reality facing universities and colleges: the lack of tangible options.
Although there is mention of “expanding digital delivery” and capitalising on overseas markets, the main thrust of the section labelled “mitigating actions” in both reports is that institutions need to make tough decisions about how to allocate their shrinking budgets.
Beyond Dundee, many universities and colleges are looking to restructure and cut costs. After years of unrest in the college sector, the SFC report warns that there may be more concern over job losses around the corner.
“Staff costs represent the largest element of college expenditure and are therefore the focus of savings. Colleges have been achieving the required savings largely through voluntary severance means.
“Several colleges have raised the possibility of compulsory redundancies as a last resort should they not achieve the savings through voluntary severance.”
The same can be said for universities, where in some cases union members are taking strike action over the possibility of compulsory redundancies.
Dundee, the University of Edinburgh, the University of the West of Scotland, UHI, and Robert Gordon University have all seen union ballots for industrial action over planned cuts, with further action planned for the autumn.
Beyond staffing cuts, more changes may be on the way for Scotland's universities as they attempt to consolidate course delivery and restructure to stabilise for the future.
Budgets for individual universities show some deficits in the coming years, followed by recovery, although, as some sector representatives have already warned, the signs of recovery may be a false dawn.
Sources close to the sector have said that many universities are spending more this year and next to run cost-saving exercises and restructure. These one-off expenses will result in trimmer budgets but also, crucially, fewer staff and in some cases fewer services.
Read more
- Financial reports show 'imminent risk' to universities and colleges
- Future of college campus undecided as talks continue
- Healthy or hurting, Scottish universities face hard choices
The SFC explains more than once in its report that the relatively strong positions at Edinburgh and Glasgow Universities are skewing the data and ballooning the surplus calculations. In the opposite direction, due to a series of detailed reviews and audits, the University of Dundee's most recent financial returns and projections were not available to the SFC and therefore not included in the report.
The result is a picture of university sector finances in which its top performers mask underlying concerns at other institutions, while the most severe case is not even taken into consideration.
Projections have failed to materialise before, and although the SFC has said that no college or university is expected to outperform its already conservative projections, stakeholders have already warned that any projected recovery – particularly for universities – should be taken with a grain of salt.
Any recovery will be more akin to a rebalancing: although more institutions may report surpluses in two years' time, they may be unrecognisable in many ways.
Share