Campaigners have accused NHS Dumfries & Galloway of "not acknowledging" safety concerns raised by pregnant mothers after reassurances from the health board and the Integration Joint Board (IJB) that the system is “safe".
An action group looking to improve maternity services in Wigtownshire also said the current care available to women is "like something out of the Middle Ages".
In 2018, Galloway Community Hospital’s maternity unit closed due to staffing shortages and left local women facing long and stressful journeys to Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary (DGRI)—sometimes up to 90 miles away.
An independent review commissioned by NHS Dumfries and Galloway previously recommended the creation of an on-call, midwife-led unit in Stranraer to improve the situation.
However, the IJB rejected the proposal last year, maintaining the current system of antenatal checks in Stranraer and births at Dumfries or at home.
Now, concerns have reignited about the health board's portrayal and handling of the situation following a briefing issued by the IJB.
The document, published on September 23, said that the IJB had "taken assurance" that the current birthing service approach in the board was being "delivered safely".
IJB Chair Kim Dams said: “A decision was taken last year not to reintroduce a birthing service within Galloway Community Hospital for purely low-risk births, but with a request to receive a subsequent assurance on how this position was being implemented.
“Almost one year on from that decision, I’m pleased to note that the IJB sub-committee stated that they were satisfied with the progress.”
However, only a week earlier, mums were sharing safety and trauma concerns with Scotland's Patient Safety Commissioner, Karen Titchener, who said she feels there is a "gap in care" which needs addressed.
Ms. Titchener met with the Galloway Community Action Group on September 16, hearing firsthand accounts from mothers about the dangers posed by long journeys for maternity care.
Speaking to ITV Border on the day of the meeting, Ms Titchener said: "We have to do something because the status quo isn't working for the people of Stranraer.
"I do feel that there is definitely gaps in care."
Campaigners say the closure has forced expectant mothers into dangerous situations, including giving birth in cars, on the roadside, or in the hospital car park.
Read More:
- The Scottish mums driving 100s of miles for maternity services
- NHS Dumfries & Galloway: Waits and recruitment issues explained
Asked about the recent IJB briefing, retired GP and member of the Galloway Community Hospital Action Group, Angela Armstrong, told The Herald: “It is in total contrast to what was discussed with the patient safety commissioner.
“There have been deaths, but not here. That doesn’t mean that it’s safe."
Ms Armstrong said the current approach has resulted in women giving birth in laybys on the A75 or in the hospital car park.
“The IJB looks at statistics such as whether there have been any deaths—and thankfully there haven’t been—but what you need to start looking at is the chances of something happening,” Ms Armstrong said. “They’ve been told by the health board that it is safe, but what they haven’t done is take account of expert advice they asked for a year ago.
"They’re risking death to a mum or a baby by not acknowledging safety concerns. It’s horrific—it’s like something out of the Middle Ages.”
Jack McConnel, the Scottish Labour PPC candidate for Galloway & West Dumfries said the IJB's briefing was "disappointing" as he pointed to a lack of action on the maternity crisis.
Mr McConnel said: "This is disappointing from the IJB. Some feel they have their fingers in their ears. This has been going on since 2018. The era of politicians' handshakes and warm words has changed nothing."
A petition calling for the maternity unit to reopen in Wigtownshire and raising safety concerns has also gathered nearly 1,000 signatures.
It states: “The lack of a local birthing unit forces expectant mothers to travel long distances during pregnancy and in giving birth, which is not only inconvenient but potentially dangerous, especially in emergency situations in which women have given birth at the side of the road. This situation disadvantages the women of Wigtownshire, denying them the same level of care available to others in more urban areas.”
A local resident told The Herald: “Nearly a thousand people have signed this petition, but they won’t listen.
"The health board is covering up problems and pretending that it is a safe approach when mums are saying otherwise.”
NHS Dumfries and Galloway has strenuously denied claims the current approach is unsafe.
A spokesperson said: “Strong local feeling around maternity services in Wigtownshire is matched by the recognised importance of ensuring that the service provided is safe, reliable, and sustainable. Our commitment is to deliver maternity care that serves the whole of Dumfries and Galloway, giving parents confidence in the support available to them.”
The board said they wrote to the Patient Safety Commissioner on September 12, immediately after she raised this issue of the model in Wigtownshire, seeking an opportunity to meet.
A spokesperson added: “The assurances around the safety and stability of the current model were provided in July by the senior maternity team, acting on the explicit direction of the IJB when they adopted this last September.
“We strongly reject any claims that the current model is unsafe, or that the discussions which led to the decision on this approach have been anything other than open and transparent—with the IJB meetings having taken place in public, and recordings of these meetings made public.”
The health board added that the current model ensures all high-risk births take place at DGRI under a consultant-led service with a neonatal care unit on site, and that the IJB’s decision was informed by consultation with staff, the public, and Healthcare Improvement Scotland.
The spokesperson said: “The alternate option which was not adopted would have provided for only pre-planned, low-risk births at Galloway Community Hospital, attended by a midwife—which, on current data, would account for just 15% of pregnancies in Wigtownshire, or around 28 births a year.”
The Herald understands that the Patient Safety Commissioner has meetings arranged with senior managers in the Galloway health board to discuss these ongoing concerns.
Share