Nigel Farage isn’t just riding a wave — he’s rewriting the rules, and neither Labour nor the Tories seem ready for what’s coming says Herald columnist Andy Maciver.
There’s a book I read, called Waiting for the Wave, about the Reform party. It focuses on the misconceptions of the party’s leader. The establishment parties, you see, painted him as an extreme right-wing conservative. In fact, outside of the political bubble, he was becoming extremely popular because of his well-timed populism.
The author - a former party strategist - describes how the leader listens to what he calls "the common sense of the common people", and outlines the party’s strategy of "catching waves" of popular discontent to mobilise support. That slowly extended from its traditional base far away from the political capital, and eventually overtook the whole country.
This will sound familiar to us. But Waiting for the Wave is not a new book, nor is it about Nigel Farage or the Reform UK political party. Published more than 15 years ago, it details the rise of the Reform party of Canada. Starting in Alberta, in western Canada, in 1986, Reform’s leader Preston Manning cultivated a growing dissatisfaction with the political classes in the east, aloof, out of touch, and blind to the realities on the ground outside of their Ottawa bubble. His populism appealed to supporters of the Progressive Conservatives (PC), among them a bright young economist named Stephen Harper.
Read more:
- Three unpopular ways to make Holyrood better with more power
- Why John Swinney is Scotland's unlikely political genius
- Is an energy policy for Scotland that creates jobs and cuts bills too much to ask?
- Our politicians have created an entitlement culture – now they must end it
Starting with a trickle (in the 1988 election the party polled two per cent), the wave began to grow. In the 1993 election the party polled nearly 20 per cent, causing a dramatic collapse in support for the ruling PC. Rising again in 1997, by the 2000 election the party had changed its name to the Canadian Alliance, in an effort to appeal to Canadians outside of the west.
A ‘Unite the Right’ movement formed in order to consume the emaciated PC, which went out of business in 2003, and the following year a new Conservative Party of Canada (CPC), led by Mr Harper, emerged with 30 per cent of the vote. Two years later, Mr Harper was in his first of three terms as Prime Minister.
I am not given to history lessons on these Herald pages on a Friday morning, and this is a lesson in the present, not the past. It is worth us learning from Canada, because we can be sure Mr Farage has; it is no accident that he named his party after Mr Manning’s.
Substitute western Canada for the north of England and Britain in 2025 is startlingly, eerily similar.
Except, that is, two things; firstly, in the UK, Reform is travelling much, much faster, and secondly, Reform is not only eating the right, but is also eating the left.
Most people in Britain’s Conservative party still consider it immortal. This is the world’s most successful political party, they say. It’s can’t possibly die. The truth is they ain’t seen nothing yet. Today, they have not even yet reached the trough their Canadian brothers did in 1993.
Their only good news, as they enter their annual conference this weekend, is that the painful journey towards death looks shorter. Messrs Manning and Harper took 18 years and five elections to kill, eat and reimagine the right, then walk into government; Mr Farage could be there by the end of the decade. Brits are not waiting for the wave; they are running towards it.
The woes of Britain’s Conservatives and Canada’s PC have the same roots. Both stood still while the country around them changed. In 2009, when Waiting for the Wave was written, our average salary was higher than it is today, adjusting for inflation. The financial crash of that time remains the most consequential factor in today’s economics and politics, compounded by Brexit, Covid and the Russian energy crisis.
This is, of course, where the Labour party also becomes a key actor, because they too have misunderstood the typical Reform voter. We heard from Sir Keir Starmer at Labour’s annual conference last weekend that Reform’s policies are racist. His Deputy David Lammy, that walking face-palm emoji, even decided it was time to haul out the N-word - Nazi.
I understand why. Mr Farage and Reform have shamefully leaned in to a distasteful undercurrent. They hover around xenophobia to supercharge an immigration policy which is, in the final analysis, in the same ball park as those promoted by Labour and the Tories. They flirt with Islamophobia, and one feels their unsubtle embrace of Christianity is not the result of detailed research of the New Testament.
But beware the wrath of the insulted voter. My bet is that the average Reform supporter thinks very little about immigration, or race or religion. My bet is that the average voter is as normal as you and I. Patriotic and, I suppose, nationalist, but a cowed, sad patriotism which simply longs for something better.
This average person, on an average salary, is getting a raw deal out of Britain. They continually have less in their pocket once the bills are paid. They wait longer for treatment on the NHS. The quality of education theit kids receive is highly postcode-dependent. Their ordinary day is hampered by poor infrastructure.
And, here’s the kicker - they look at the family next door, with the same lifestyle as them but whom they know are in receipt of every benefit imaginable, and they say (excuse me, reader) “F*** you”. They search for someone who understands them, and they find Nigel Farage.
This is the new working class, defining ‘working class’ as people who work rather than people who shirk, transcending left and right, and seeing Labour and the Conservatives as two sides of the same devalued coin.
What we are witnessing here is something far more significant than the peaks and troughs of Britain’s established political parties. We are in the middle of a revolution, where the hundred grand banker and the twenty grand baker both think the same thing, and find their political gap filled by Mr Farage, who replaces Boris Johnson as modern politics’ most underrated genius.
There is further opportunity in the chaos. The new market gap will be for a party of centrist economic liberalism, favouring globalisation, easy taxes and social liberalism. The Liberal Democrats could outgrow their lingering naïveté and fill that gap. They might bring some soft Tories with them, and some tough Labour folk too, perhaps.
A smaller gap on the far left could be filled by the interesting new Green Leader, Zac Polanski, and there are plenty Labour types who might prefer that direction. But, for a while at least, they will need to dance to the tune of Nigel Farage, for we live in his world, now.
Andy Maciver is Founding Director of Message Matters, and co-host of the Holyrood Sources podcast
Share